Truth & Beauty Operations

My presentation at ChALS 2012, Gothenburg

Transcript

1. MORITZ STEFANER TRUTH & BEAUTY OPERATIONS ChALS ’12 // Gothenburg Sep 2012
2. MORITZ STEFANER TRUTH&BEAUTY OPERATOR 1999 – 2002 2002 – 2005 2005 – 2007 2007 – 2009 2004 – working for Skype, World Economic Forum, dpa, OECD… Web designer BSc Cognitive Science MA Interface Design Research assistant FH Potsdam Freelance information visualizer
4. Organic Link Network Moritz Stefaner, 2002
5. Elastic Tag Maps Moritz Stefaner, 2007
6. Elastic Lists Moritz Stefaner, 2007
8. Max Planck Research Networks http://max-planck-research-networks.net With Christopher Warnow / onformative
12. Quantitative analysis with Tableau name Year 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Physik  (Werner-­ Heisenberg-­Institut) Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  extraterrestrische Physik Max  Planck  Institut  für  Kernphysik Max  Planck  Institute  for  Solid  State Research Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Radioastronomie Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Astronomie Max  Planck  Gesellschaft  zur  Förderung  der Wissenschaften Max-­Planck-­Institut  für Sonnensystemforschung Max  Planck  Institute  of  Biochemistry Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Astrophysik 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 10% 20% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% 15% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 2% 4% 6% %  of  Total  Weight Sheet  1 name Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Physik  (Werner-­Heisenberg-­Institut) Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  extraterrestrische  Physik Max  Planck  Institut  für  Kernphysik Max  Planck  Institute  for  Solid  State  Research Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Radioastronomie Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Astronomie Max  Planck  Gesellschaft  zur  Förderung  der  Wissenschaften Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Sonnensystemforschung Max  Planck  Institute  of  Biochemistry Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Astrophysik Max  Planck  Institute  for  Chemistry  (Otto  Hahn  Institute) Max  Planck  Institute  for  Molecular  Genetics Max  Planck  Institute  for  Polymer  Research Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Plasmaphysik Max  Planck  Institute  for  Metals  Research Fritz  Haber  Institute  of  the  Max  Planck  Society Max  Planck  Institute  for  Biophysical  Chemistry  (Karl  Friedrich  Bonhoeffer  Institute) Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Quantenoptik Max-­Planck-­Institute  for  the  Physics  of  Complex  Systems Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Psychiatrie The  trend  of  %  of  Total  Weight  for  Year  broken  dow n  by  name.    Color  show s  details  about  name.    Details  are  show n  for  name.  The  view  is  fil-­ tered  on  name  and  Year.  The  name  filter  has  multiple  members  selected.  The  Year  filter  keeps  22  members.  Percents  are  based  on  each  col-­ umn  of  the  table. name 1993 1998 2003 2008 Calculation1 Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Physik  (Werner-­ Heisenberg-­Institut) Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  extraterrestrische Physik Max  Planck  Institut  für  Kernphysik Max  Planck  Institute  for  Solid  State Research Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Radioastronomie Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Astronomie Max  Planck  Gesellschaft  zur  Förderung  der Wissenschaften Max-­Planck-­Institut  für Sonnensystemforschung Max  Planck  Institute  of  Biochemistry Max-­Planck-­Institut  für  Astrophysik 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 10% 20% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% 15% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 5% 10% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% %  of  Total  Weight 0% 2% 4% 6% %  of  Total  Weight Sheet  1 The  trend  of  %  of  Total  Weight  for  Calculation1  broken  dow n  by  name.    Details  are  show n  f or  name.  The  data  is  filtered  on  Year,  w hich  keeps  22  members.  The  view on  name,  w hich  has  multiple  members  selected.  Percents  are  based  on  each  column  of  the  table.
13. Data analysis with Gephi, custom tools
15. MPI für Physik (Werner-Heisenberg-Institut) MPI für extraterrestrische Physik MPI für Kernphysik MPI für Radioastronomie MPI für Astronomie MPI for Solid State Research MPI für Astrophysik MPI für Sonnensystemforschung Max Planck Gesellschaft zur Förderung der Wissens… MPI für Plasmaphysik MPI for Chemistry (Otto Hahn Institute) MPI of Biochemistry MPI for Metals Research MPI for Molecular Genetics MPI for Polymer Research Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society MPI for Biophysical Chemistry (Karl Friedrich Bon… MPI für Quantenoptik MPI for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein In… MPI for the Physics of Complex Systems MPI fur Kolloid Und Grenzflachenforschung Potsdam MPI für Psychiatrie MPI for Meteorology MPI für Biogeochemie Jena MPI of Microstructure Physics MPI for Evolutionary Anthropology MPI for Developmental Biology MPI for Gravitational Physics (Hannover) (Albert … Max-Planck Institut für Chemische Physik fester S… MPI für molekulare Physiologie MPI für Medizinische Forschung Heidelberg MPI für Züchtungsforschung MPI für marine Mikrobiologie MPI für Dynamik Und Selbstorganisation Göttingen MPI für Experimentelle Medizin MPI of Immunobiology MPI für Informatik MPI für Kohlenforschung MPI für Kognitions- und Neurowissenschaften MPI for Biological Cybernetics MPI of Molecular Cell Biology and Genetics MPI für Hirnforschung MPI for Infection Biology MPI fur Chemische Okologie MPI für Bioanorganische Chemie MPI of Molecular Plant Physiology MPI of Neurobiology MPI of Biophysics MPI für Eisenforschung MPI für Bildungsforschung MPI for Ornithology (Former: Max Planck Research … MPI für Terrestrische Mikrobiologie MPI for Mathematics in the Sciences MPI für Herz- und Lungenforschung Max-Plack-Institut für Neurologische Forschung Kö… MPI für molekulare Biomedizin MPI fur Mathematik MPI for Psycholinguistics MPI for Dynamics of Complex Technical Systems MPI für Limnologie Max-Plack-Institut für demografische Forschung MPI für Verhaltensphysiologie MPI für Ökonomik MPI of Experimental Endocrinology Friedrich Miescher Laboratory of the Max Planck S… Max-Planck-Arbeitsgruppen für strukturelle Moleku… MPI für Evolutionsbiologie Max Planck Research Unit for Enzymology of Protei… MPI für Zellbiologie International Max Planck Research School on Earth… MPI for Research On Collective Goods MPI fur Neurologische Forschung Koln MPI for the History of Science MPI für Gesellschaftsforschung MPI für Virusforschung International Max Planck Research School for Comp… Max Planck Inst. Evol. Anthropol MPI for Terrestrial Microbiology Marburg
19. Layouts
20. Interaction tests
21. DIVIDE & CONQUER FIND THE SMALL DATA INSIDE THE BIG DATA
22. well-formed.eigenfactor Moritz Stefaner & Eigenfactor Team, 2009 | http://well-formed.eigenfactor.org
28. Hierarchical Edge Bundling Danny Holten: Hierarchical Edge Bundles: Visualization of Adjacency Relations in Hierarchical Data, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Vol. 12, No. 5, September/October 2006 Danny Holten and Jarke J. van Wijk: Force-Directed Edge Bundling for Graph Visualization, Eurographics/ IEEE-VGTC Symposium on Visualization 2009, Volume 28 (2009), Number 3
29. GROUP AND ORDER ROUTE THOSE EDGES
30. LOOK MA, NO LINES PHYSICAL METAPHOR
31. OECD Better Life Index
36. x Country score profile User–defined weight profile Dimensions Score x Importance Dimensions Score Importance Dimensions Score Opacity: Importance 1 2 3 …
37. Rank visualization Legend / help Controls for weights Country visualization Country visualization Country visualization Country visualization Country visualization Country visualization Country visualization Country visualization Country visualization Score changes scores and country visualizations Share
38. Controls for weights Controls for weights generic in line with visualization
49. Design Iterations (excerpt)
50. http://vimeo.com/24609043
55. How often has each rating been assigned to each topic? 280 159 75 70 57 0 1 2 3 4 5 Governance is quite unpopular Little clicks, despite being the default Most popular topics: Education, Health, Life satisfaction Housing Income Jobs Community Education Environment Governance Health Life Satisfaction Safety Work-Life Balance
57. emoto design team Moritz Stefaner Studio NAND Drew Hemment (Future Everything) A FutureEverything project with MIT Senseable City Lab for the Cultural Olympiad programme and London 2012 Festival. Co-sponsored by GE and funded by Arts Council England and WE PLAY/Legacy Trust UK. Infrastructure design & development by Gerrit Kaiser. Citizen journalism by Andy Miah Evaluation and blogging by Ege Sezen. Project management by Leon Seth and Nick Lawrenson. Communications by Jo Williams, Anita Morris Associates. Emoto is produced by FutureEverything and Studio NAND. Emoto in London is produced by (or presented by) MIT Senseable Cities Lab and GE as part of Emoto (emoto2012.org).
58. The games Social media response :) :( Sentiment analysis, classification x #goldmedal #hockey Real time data visualization Data sculpture Data journalism
59. Events Nations !"#$%&'()*%*+,%-(../'/0/*,.%(1%()2%*,&3%*+/.%4,&25% 67%82&9:%&;<%=/,0<>>>%?@,A2,67 {Discipline} {Emotion} {Emotion} {Nation} http://twitter.com/#!/jnadzam11/status/108389262201856002 28/08/2010 by Josh Nadzam 6.&/;%B(0*%1&0.,%.*&2*.%&;<%CDE.%/;%FGG3%1/;&0%/;% C&,H)%@(20<%I+&3-/(;.+/-.%(1%82&9:%J%=/,0<% !""#$%%&&&'()*+,-*.'/0')1%2#0+"%3 {Discipline} {Press article} {Emotion} {Event} {Athlete->Nation} http://twitter.com/#!/NevilleABC17/status/107923209080414208 28/08/2010 by Neville Miller SAMPLE DATA Taken from the Athletics World Championships 2011
60. emoto2012.org https://vimeo.com/46615102
64. Phelps Phelps Phelps Phelps Phelps Bolt Hockey Soccer each triangle corresponds to a number of tweets with a specific sentiment (e.g score +7) for that topic, size and intensity indicate amount of tweets these are crap -->
67. HOCKEY HOCKEY HOCKEY HOCKEY HOCKEY HOCKEY A) shortest cathethus aligned to hypothenuse swapping position alternately B) shortest cathethus aligned to hypothenuse swapping position alternately mirroring after 4th element B) shortest cathethus aligned to hypothenuse swapping position alternately mirroring alternately
74. emoto installation https://vimeo.com/49679699
86. HOW CAN WE USE FOOD FOR DATA EXPRESSION?
88. WHAT ARE THE CULINARY VARIABLES WE CAN WORK WITH?
90. Antti Nurkka Natalie Aubret Susanne Jaschko Miska Knapek pixelache.ac prozessagenten.org foodidea.fi knapek.org
100. Lakmoussetikka http://data-cuisine.net/data-dishes/lakmoussetikka/ Nathalie Aubret & Melinda Sipos
101. Kippis! http://data-cuisine.net/data-dishes/alcohol-consumption-map/ Essi Kärkkäinen
102. Age & Language in Lentils http://data-cuisine.net/data-dishes/age-language-in-lentils/ Matt Zumwalt
103. Happiness Cocktail http://data-cuisine.net Jen Lowe
104. Lettuce de lux http://data-cuisine.net/data-dishes/lettuce-de-lux/ Nathalie Aubret and Melinda Sipos
105. Spice foreigners between pasta http://data-cuisine.net/data-dishes/spiced-foreigners-between- Symeon Delikaris-Manias
106. Criminal herring in fur coat http://data-cuisine.net/data-dishes/criminal-herring-in-fur-coat/ Dmitrii Rogozhin
109. A FEW THINGS I LEARNED
110. LEARNING THROUGH PLAYFUL EXPLORATION
111. TELL A STORY
112. TELL A THOUSAND STORIES …BUT NOT ALL AT ONCE!
113. IT IS ALL ABOUT RELATIONS EVEN WHEN ALL YOU HAVE IS NUMBERS
114. USA Annual health spending per person: $7920 Average life expectancy at birth: 78 years
115. http://blogs.ngm.com/blog_central/2009/12/the-cost-of-care.html
117. Workflow CLARIFY WHAT & WHY EXPLORE & SKETCH DEFINE & PRODUCE MAINTAIN & ANALYZE CONTEXT & GOALS DATA Data analysis with standard tools: Excel, Tableau, R Visual explorations based on real data Functional prototypes High level constraints, goals and intuitions Visual design Interaction design Implementation Testing User tracking and analysis Updates, extensions LAUNCH REDEFINE
118. CLARIFY WHAT & WHY EXPLORE & SKETCH DEFINE & PRODUCE MAINTAIN & ANALYZE CONTEXT & GOALS DATA LAUNCH “LET THE DATA SET CHANGE YOUR MIND SET” (ROSLING) LET THE USERS CHANGE YOUR MIND SET Feedback loops
119. ON TRUTH & BEAUTY
120. "When I'm working on a problem, I never think about beauty. I think only how to solve the problem. But when I have finished, if the solution is not beautiful, I know it is wrong." R. Buckminster Fuller (1895-1983)
121. THANKS! Q? A! http://moritz.stefaner.eu @moritz_stefaner http://well-formed-data.net http://datastori.es
122. http://datastori.es podcast together with Enrico Bertini