Share
Embed
Going down the RAT hole: Deep dive into the Vuln-derland of APT-class RAT Tools
2024年11月16日のAVTOKYO2024で発表する「Going down the RAT hole: Deep dive into the Vuln-derland of APT-class RAT Tools」の講演資料です(事前公開)。講演詳細についてはこちらを御覧ください(https://www.avtokyo.org/avtokyo2024/speakers#h.u64duq1cbh2c)
NTT docomo Business
November 10, 2024
Transcript
27 slides
-
© 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Going down the
RAT hole: Akitoshi takezaki & Ryo Minakawa @ NA4Sec team AVTOKYO2024 Deep dive into the Vuln-derland of APT-class RAT Tools -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. About
us 2 Org.: NFLaboratories Job: Malware Analyst Ryo Minakawa @strinsert1Na Akitoshi Takezaki @z4ck_key Org.: NTT Communications Job: Intelligence Analyst We are threat intel. team, !! -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Attention
3 Please use the content within the scope of the TLP !! TLP: CLEAR TLP: AMBER Approved for internet discussion Limited disclosure -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Ice
breaking 5 How did this past year feel for you? -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. In
my case… 6 It’s been an exciting year with tons of information leaks from Chinese APTs due to OPSEC failures! Legacy Threat: PlugX Builder/Controller Discovered in Open Directory https://hunt.io/blog/legacy-threat-plugx-builder-controller-discovered-in- open-directory Data From Chinese Security Services Company i-Soon Linked to Previous Chinese APT Campaigns https://unit42.paloaltonetworks.com/i-soon-data-leaks/ -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. The
Benefits by Tool Leaks 7 Analyzing from a forensic perspective is very limited because only modules that can be recovered from memory are available for analysis. Before the Leak After the Leak Malware only loads Module A Module B from C2 server Analyst Dumped the RAT implant from memory. Next stage, analyze malware modules…… Analyst The post-exploitation tool delivers the following modules: Module A Module B Module C Module D The functions of the post-exploitation tool are easy to understand intuitively!! Analyzing from a post-exploitation tool perspective makes it much easier to assess the tool’s capabilities and apply insights for defense. -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. The
Benefits by Tool Leaks 8 Even a small mistake in the investigation might lead to an exploit and could carry a risk of arrest. Before the Leak After the Leak Analyst Even if we are the victims, we can only conduct a limited investigation…. Analyst Set up a C2 server on the host's local network Reduce the risk of arrest and investigate as much as we want!! Setting up a RAT C2 server in a local environment enables investigations that include the scope of vulnerability exploitation!! Internet scanning -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Our
presentation topics • Identified RAT infrastructure’s fingerprint and vulnerabilities from an offensive perspective • Found interesting vulnerabilities along the way • Hoping for future applications in Active Cyber Defense 9 An investigation triggered by the leakage of Nation State- Sponsored APT's Custom RATs -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Discovery
and Collection Methods for RATs Used by Leaked State-Sponsored APTs 10 -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. RATs
Leaked Over the Past Year • PlugX • Used by chinese APT groups for over 10 years • Hunt.io discovered builder and controller on “opendir” C2 Server [1] • ShadowPad • High-functionality modular RAT, considered a successor to PlugX • Management interface found in i-Soon Leak [2] • nao_sec discovered builder on VirusTotal due to operator’s OPSEC failure [3] • RatelS (a.k.a. micDown, HemiGate) • High-functionality modular RAT reflecting PlugX developer’s intent • First reported by LAC last year in incident report noting the builder was uploaded to VirusTotal [4][5] • nao_sec and Trend Micro also reported it, showing connections across all cases [6][7][8] 11 Three RATs developed by state-sponsored APTs identified by us -
TLP: AMBER © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Visitors
only How to Get Leaked Tools 12 -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. What
You Can Learn from Using RAT 14 Attacker Victim Infrastructure delivery Command & Control execution BLOB Tools Defense Leveraging TTPs: Likely effective Attribution: Ineffective Defense Leveraging TTPs: Limitedly effective Attribution: Likely effective -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Basic
Analysis Approach Set up the local server and client environment on the Proxmox • Kali Linux • For RAT C2 server scanning • RAT C2 Server • RAT lister is running on Windows server • Victim machine • RAT implant is running on Windows 10 16 Research Environment Starting Point: Identify unique fingerprints of RAT C2 Infrastructure -
TLP: AMBER © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Visitors
only In-depth Analysis 17 -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Key
Takeaway: Active Cyber Defense • These vulnerabilities, if exploited, are highly dangerous • However, with the legitimate use of these vulnerabilities, a takedown operation like Emotet's might be possible. • Yet, even as laws are under review, the feasibility of this approach remains uncertain... 20 Not just for fun -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Key
Takeaway: Active Cyber Defense • Expert meetings continue, but issues remain unresolved • Meeting records raises concerns: • e.g.) Reporting obligations for infrastructure providers — our options are very limited • Need for practical and tactical adjustments beyond theoretical strategies • (even if relevant stakeholders aren't here ) 21 「能動的サイバー防御」 政府 有識者会議の論点整理まとまる https://www3.nhk.or.jp/news/html/20240807/k10014539571000.html -
TLP: AMBER © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Visitors
only Key Takeaway: RAT C2 infra. discovery 22 -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Summary
• Focused not only on understanding the modules but also on: • Identifying unique infrastructure fingerprints • Exploring potential vulnerability-based takedown operation • If this presentation has made you interested in RAT C2 servers, don’t miss the PowerShell Empire workshop today ! 24 Deep investigation on RAT & their infrastructure from an offensive perspective -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. Thank
you for listening! 25 Going down the RAT hole: Deep dive into the Vuln-derland of APT-class RAT Tools Your comments & feedbacks are always welcome!! ☞ [email protected] -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. References
-1- [1] Legacy Threat: PlugX Builder/Controller Discovered in Open Directory, Hunt.io (2024/6/5), https://hunt.io/blog/legacy-threat-plugx-builder-controller-discovered-in-open-directory [2] Data From Chinese Security Services Company i-Soon Linked to Previous Chinese APT Campaigns, UNIT 42 Palo Alto Networks (2024/2/23), https://unit42.paloaltonetworks.com/i-soon- data-leaks/ [3] Building Casper’s Shadow, nao_sec (2024/6/30), https://nao-sec.org/2024/06/building-caspers- shadow.html [4] 新たなモジュール型マルウェア「RatelS」に見るPlugXの面影, LAC WATCH(2023/9/14), https://www.lac.co.jp/lacwatch/report/20230914_003513.html [5] New Modular Malware RatelS: Shades of PlugX, Botconf 2024 (2024/4/24), https://www.botconf.eu/botconf-presentation-or-article/new-modular-malware-ratels-shades-of- plugx/ 26 -
TLP: CLEAR © 2024 NTT Communications Corporation, N.F.Laboratories. Inc. References
-2- [6] The Secret Life of RATs: connecting the dots by dissecting multiple backdoors, JSAC2024 (2024/1/26), https://jsac.jpcert.or.jp/archive/2024/pdf/JSAC2024_1_7_hara_nakajima_kawakami_jp.pdf [7] GroundPeony: Crawling with Malice, nao_sec (2023/8/22), https://nao-sec.org/2023/08/groundpeony-crawling-with-malice.html [8] 攻撃グループ「Earth Estries」が政府機関や技術業界を狙って新たなサイバー諜報活動を展開, Trend Micro (2023/10/27), https://www.trendmicro.com/ja_jp/research/23/j/earth-estries-targets- government-tech-for-cyberespionage.html [9] 「能動的サイバー防御」 政府 有識者会議の論点整理まとまる, NHK, (2024/8/23), https://www3.nhk.or.jp/news/html/20240807/k10014539571000.html 27