Share
Embed
Towards explanatory model building in social data science
Talk presented at RGS-IBG Urban Analytics Workshop, 31st August 2016
Roger Beecham
September 01, 2016
Transcript
29 slides
-
Improving analysis of passively collected data through probabilistic analysis Roger
Beecham, Cagatay Turkay & Jo Wood giCentre, City University London -
Towards explanatory model building in social data science Roger Beecham,
Cagatay Turkay & Jo Wood giCentre, City University London Improving analysis of passively collected data through probabilistic analysis -
Can we use bikeshare data to learn (new things) about
urban cycling behaviour? -
Geographic Data Science Computational Social Science Social Data
Science Empirical Sociology Data-driven Social Science Urban Informatics Urban Analytics … -
Geographic Data Science Computational Social Science Social Data
Science Empirical Sociology Data-driven Social Science Urban Informatics Urban Analytics … Repurposing new, population-level data for social research -
o Measurement validity • Are we observing what (the behaviours)
we think we are? o Incomplete data • We don’t know enough about users Challenges -
o Measurement validity • Are we observing what (the behaviours)
we think we are? o Incomplete data • We don’t know enough about users Challenges ----------------------------------------------------------- Confirmatory / explanatory analysis? -
Research ambition Take a research finding (observed cycling behaviour). …
And provide explanations for that finding. … With quantified measures of each explanation’s effect. -
Exploring gendered cycling behaviours within a large-scale behavioural data-set Transportation
Planning and Technology, 2014 Vol. 37, No. 1, 83–97, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03081060.2013.844903 Exploring gendered cycling behaviours within a large-scale behavioural data-set Roger Beecham* and Jo Wood Department of Computing, giCentre, City University, London, UK Transportation Planning and Technology, 2014 Vol. 37, No. 1, 83–97, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03081060.2013.844903 2015 -
Studying commuting behaviours using collaborative visual analytics Roger Beecham a,⇑,
Jo Wood a, Audrey Bowerman b a giCentre, Information Sciences, City University London, United Kingdom b Delivery Planning - Cycling, Transport for London, United Kingdom a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t Computers, Environment and Urban Systems xxx (2013) xxx–xxx Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Computers, Environment and Urban Systems journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/compenvurbsys -
mid point least quiet routes Provision of cycle- friendly infrastructure
most quiet routes -
Research ambition Explain the observed geography of bikeshare (estimated) workplaces
| given | • Geography of jobs available London and accessed by the same home locations (resident population) of bikeshare users [2011 Census] -
Research ambition Explain the observed geography of bikeshare (estimated) workplaces
| given | • Geography of jobs available London and accessed by the same home locations (resident population) of bikeshare users [2011 Census] • Provision of bikeshare cycling infrastructure [LCHS usage data] -
Research ambition Explain the observed geography of bikeshare (estimated) workplaces
| given | • Geography of jobs available London and accessed by the same home locations (resident population) of bikeshare users [2011 Census] • Provision of bikeshare cycling infrastructure [LCHS usage data] • Provision of “cycle-friendly” routes [cyclestreets.net] -
observed bikeshare jobs at lsoai = available jobs at lsoai
| lsoai...n homeplaces of bikeshare commuters [Census 2011] -
observed bikeshare jobs at lsoai = available jobs at lsoai
| lsoai...n homeplaces of bikeshare commuters [Census 2011] + bikeshare infrastructure at lsoai [Density of docking spaces, LCHS | competition, Census 2011] -
observed bikeshare jobs at lsoai = available jobs at lsoai
| lsoai...n homeplaces of bikeshare commuters [Census 2011] + bikeshare infrastructure at lsoai [Density of docking spaces, LCHS | competition, Census 2011] + provision of “cycle-friendly” routes to lsoai [Quietness scores from estimated routing data, cyclestreets.net ] -
Comparing geography of bikeshare workplaces men’s vs women’s Standardised residuals
for studying lsoa-level variation Cramer’s V for studying effect size across lsoas = obslsoai explsoai p explsoai c = s P 2 N(k 1) -
Standardised residuals for studying lsoa-level variation Cramer’s V for studying
effect size across lsoas Comparing geography of workplaces bikeshare vs modelled = obslsoai explsoai p explsoai c = s P 2 N(k 1) -
Assumptions dataset available jobs at lsoa Cramer’s V: 0.24 Cramer’s
V: 0.25 men women -
Cramer’s V: 0.18 Cramer’s V: 0.20 Assumptions dataset available jobs
at lsoa + capacity men women -
all available jobs all available jobs | bikeshare lsoas all
available jobs | bikeshare lsoas + quietness all available jobs | bikeshare lsoas + capacity Developing a model (quantified explanations) -
Model development Re-evaluate groundtruth (estimated workplaces) Investigate other explanatory variables.
Better modelling infrastructure. Locally-varying (gw) regression coefficients for certain explanatory variables. Policy related outcome -- workplace potential? Parts of London with high labour market demand, poor supply of ‘infrastructure’ – bikeshare and general cycling. Further considerations -
all available jobs all available jobs | bikeshare lsoas all
available jobs | bikeshare lsoas + quietness all available jobs | bikeshare lsoas + capacity