[Paper Reading] Inverse Cooking: Recipe Generation from Food Images

Present "Inverse Cooking: Recipe Generation from Food Images" paper at Paper Reading study group

1. Inverse Cooking: Recipe Generation from Food Images Amaia Salvador, Michal Drozdzal, Xavier Giro-i-Nieto, Adriana Romero Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya, Facebook AI Research @CVPR2019 Presented by Huy Van 1 Paper Reading 2019
2. 1. Introduction Problem • too much food photos but limited detailed information about food Solution • Inverse Cooking: infers ingredients and cooking instructions from a food photo 2 Paper Reading 2019
3. Contributions • Presents a system which generates cooking instructions on an image and its ingredients • Studies ingredients as both a list and a set, and proposes a new architecture for ingredient prediction that exploits co-dependencies among ingredients without imposing order • Superior than image-to-recipe retrieval approaches in ingredient predictions 3 Paper Reading 2019
4. 2. Related Work Food Understanding • Large scale datasets: Food-101 and Recipe1M • Visual food recognition • Esitmating the number of calories given a food image • Predicting the list of present ingredients • Finding the recipe for a given image Multi-label Classification Conditional Text Generation 4 Paper Reading 2019
5. 3. Genarating Recipes from Images 5 Paper Reading 2019
6. Cooking Instruction Transformer 6 Paper Reading 2019
7. Ingredient Decoder • Ingredients as a list (ordered) • Ingredients as a set (unordered) 7 Paper Reading 2019
8. Ingredients as a List • Present each ingredient as a one-hot vector • Use a transformer model 8 Paper Reading 2019
9. Ingredients as a Set • Method 1: set transformer • Use transformer as above • To remove the order → aggregate the outputs accross different time-steps by using a max pooling operation • Method 2: • Present ingredient output as a binary set then convert to a target distribution • Use feed forward network with cross- entropy loss 9 Paper Reading 2019
10. Optimization 2 stages: - pre-train the image encoder and ingredients decoder - train the ingredient encoder and instruction decoder 10 Paper Reading 2019
11. 4. Experiments Dataset • Recipe1M: includes ~1M recipes • Preprocessing: • rule-base to reduce ingredients from 16,823 to 1,488 • tokenize raw text and remove less frequent words → 23,231 words 11 Paper Reading 2019
12. Results: Recipe Generation 12 Paper Reading 2019
13. Results: Ingredient Prediction 13 Paper Reading 2019
14. Results: Generation vs Retrieval 14 Paper Reading 2019
15. Results: User Studies 15 Paper Reading 2019
16. 5. Conclusion • Introduced an image-to-recipe generation system, which takes a food image and produces a recipe consisting of a title, ingredients and sequence of cooking instructions • First predicted sets of ingredients from food images, showing that modeling dependencies matters • Then explored instruction generation conditioned on images and inferred ingredients, highlighting the importance of reasoning about both modalities at the same time • Finally, user study results confirm the difficulty of the task, and demonstrate the superiority of the system against state- of-the-art image-to-recipe retrieval approaches 16 Paper Reading 2019