Share
Embed
Transcript
50 slides
-
What are minds? ! Minds depend on bodies. Information gets
to mind from physical senses. -
What are minds? ! Minds depend on bodies. Information gets
to mind from physical senses. Damaged brains mean damaged minds. -
What are minds? ! Minds depend on bodies. Information gets
to mind from physical senses. Damaged brains mean damaged minds. ! Minds are independent of bodies. -
What are minds? ! Minds depend on bodies. Information gets
to mind from physical senses. Damaged brains mean damaged minds. ! Minds are independent of bodies. Different minds and brains can have the same thoughts. -
What are minds? ! Minds depend on bodies. Information gets
to mind from physical senses. Damaged brains mean damaged minds. ! Minds are independent of bodies. Different minds and brains can have the same thoughts. Brains and behavior alone do not reveal the contents of minds. -
An Analogy ! Computer software depends on hardware. Information gets
to software by means of physical circuits. -
An Analogy ! Computer software depends on hardware. Information gets
to software by means of physical circuits. Damaged hardware means software doesn’t work. -
An Analogy ! Computer software depends on hardware. Information gets
to software by means of physical circuits. Damaged hardware means software doesn’t work. ! Software is independent of hardware. -
An Analogy ! Computer software depends on hardware. Information gets
to software by means of physical circuits. Damaged hardware means software doesn’t work. ! Software is independent of hardware. Different machines can run the same programs. -
An Analogy ! Computer software depends on hardware. Information gets
to software by means of physical circuits. Damaged hardware means software doesn’t work. ! Software is independent of hardware. Different machines can run the same programs. Patterns of activity in circuits alone do not reveal the functions carried out by programs. -
Functionalism ! Minds are not things, but sets of capacities
(behaviorism is partly right). -
Functionalism ! Minds are not things, but sets of capacities
(behaviorism is partly right). ! Minds do not exist without some physical device to carry out mental functions (Mind/Brain Identity theory is partly right). -
Functionalism ! Minds are not things, but sets of capacities
(behaviorism is partly right). ! Minds do not exist without some physical device to carry out mental functions (Mind/Brain Identity theory is partly right). ! Minds are not identical with either behavior or any physical thing (dualism is partly right). -
Functionalism ! Minds are not things, but sets of capacities
(behaviorism is partly right). ! Minds do not exist without some physical device to carry out mental functions (Mind/Brain Identity theory is partly right). ! Minds are not identical with either behavior or any physical thing (dualism is partly right). ! Minds are sets of functions running in brains (all the other theories are partly wrong). -
Multiple Realizability ! A machine is defined by its function.
! The same function can be carried out by other machines. -
Multiple Realizability ! A machine is defined by its function.
! The same function can be carried out by other machines. ! If the mind is a set of functions, a machine besides the brain can be designed that implements the functions carried out by minds. -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. a person -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns off furnace. a person -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns off furnace. ! Coil winds tighter past a set point. a person -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns off furnace. ! Coil winds tighter past a set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns on furnace. a person -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns off furnace. ! Coil winds tighter past a set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns on furnace. a person ! Turing notices the room is too hot. -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns off furnace. ! Coil winds tighter past a set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns on furnace. a person ! Turing notices the room is too hot. ! He turns off the furnace. -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns off furnace. ! Coil winds tighter past a set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns on furnace. a person ! Turing notices the room is too hot. ! He turns off the furnace. ! Turing notices the room is cold. -
Compare and Contrast a thermostat ! Coil unwinds past a
set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns off furnace. ! Coil winds tighter past a set point. ! This triggers a switch that turns on furnace. a person ! Turing notices the room is too hot. ! He turns off the furnace. ! Turing notices the room is cold. ! He turns on the furnace. -
Finite State Machines ! A set of possible inputs. !
A set of internal states. -
Finite State Machines ! A set of possible inputs. !
A set of internal states. ! A set of possible outputs. -
Finite State Machines ! A set of possible inputs. !
A set of internal states. ! A set of possible outputs. ! A set of rules that relate inputs, internal states and outputs. -
Finite State Machines ! A set of possible inputs. !
A set of internal states. ! A set of possible outputs. ! A set of rules that relate inputs, internal states and outputs. Are minds nothing but very complex finite state machines? -
Mind as Machine ! inputs: millions of sensory receptors !
internal states: memories, brain states, chemical and hormonal states -
Mind as Machine ! inputs: millions of sensory receptors !
internal states: memories, brain states, chemical and hormonal states ! rules: instincts, reflexes, habits, thoughts, plans, ideas, emotions, learned routines -
Mind as Machine ! inputs: millions of sensory receptors !
internal states: memories, brain states, chemical and hormonal states ! rules: instincts, reflexes, habits, thoughts, plans, ideas, emotions, learned routines ! outputs: new internal states, motor outputs, spoken and written language