Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

The Arabian Peninsula Symbolized on Maps, Medieval to Modern

The Arabian Peninsula Symbolized on Maps, Medieval to Modern

Dr. Naeema Al Hosani
Assistant Professor of Cartography
Geography & Urban Planning Dept.
United Arab Emirates University

Nathaniel V. KELSO

October 17, 2013
Tweet

More Decks by Nathaniel V. KELSO

Other Decks in Technology

Transcript

  1.     The  Arabian  Peninsula  Symbolized  on  Maps,   Medieval

     to  Modern Dr.  Naeema    Al  Hosani   Assistant  Professor  of  Cartography   Geography  &  Urban  Planning  Dept.     Faculty  of  Humani?es  &  Social  Sciences   United  Arab  Emirates  University   P.  O.  Box  17771,  Al  Ain,  UAE   Tel:  +9713-­‐7136411   Fax:  +9713-­‐7136937   E-­‐mail:  [email protected]  
  2. Abstract     Un?l  the  modern  era  the  people  of

     the  Arabian  Peninsula  had   liSle  need  for  maps  and  created  few,  since  most  of  them   depended  on  tradi?onal  knowledge  of  desert  landmarks,  the   movements  of  the  stars,  and  the  direc?ons  of  the  winds  for   wayfinding.  In  contrast,  Europeans  created  many  maps  of  Arabia   for  various  reasons  ranging  from  intellectual  curiosity  to  poli?cal,   economic,  and  military  interests.  This  paper  trace  sand  seeks  to   explain  the  changing  representa?on  of  the  Arabian  Peninsula  on   maps  from  the  medieval  period  to  the  modern  day.  It  considers   the  historical  development  of  map  symbols,  like  wri?ng,  from   pictures  to  conven?onal  pictorial  signs  to  abstract  symbols.  It   looks  at  the  differences  between  Arabian  and  European   mapmakers  and  their  underlying  cultural  biases.  It  explores  how   the  maps  were  designed  to  serve  different  purposes.  Out  of  this   study  of  map  symboliza?on  emerges  a  mul?-­‐faceted  view  of  the   Arabian  Peninsula  and  its  history  as  seen     through  the  eyes  of  many  mapmakers,  medieval  to  modern.     Keywords:  history  of  cartography,  maps  symbols,  map  design,   Arabian  Peninsula  
  3. A  map  is  a  graphic  representa?on  of  spa?al  concepts  in

      environment  that  conveys  geographic  informa?on.  Maps   are  communica?on  tool  and  easily  understood  regardless   of  language  or  culture;  since  it  abstracts  phenomena   (features,  or  objects)  by  different  kinds  of  graphics   symbols.  Old  maps  provide  much  informa?on  about  what   was  known  in  that  ?me;  also  it  delivers  the  culture  basis   of  the  map,  which  was  different  from  modern  cartography   (Merriam  1996).  
  4. Map  Symboliza?on     is  the  graphic  coding  of  informa1on

     and   placing  it  into  a  map  context.     is  the  characters,  le6ers,  or  similar   graphic  representa1ons  used  on  a  map   to  indicate  an  object  in  the  real  world.  
  5. Graphic  symbolism  that  is  used  to  iden?fy  different  phenomena  

    on  maps  can  also  be  classified  into  four  basic  categories  on  the   basis  of  the  dimensionality  of  the  symbol  form:         1-­‐  Point          (  City  )       2-­‐  Line              (  River  )       3-­‐  Area            (  Lake  )     4-­‐  Volume  (amount  of  vegeta3on  or  popula3on)      
  6. Map  Design  -­‐  What  Makes  A  Great  Map   Consider

     the  following  points  when  designing  a  map...     What  is  the  map's  purpose?     Create  a  story  for  the  map  to  tell.  Then  build  the  map  to  tell  the  story.     Establish  basic  informa?on  with  ?tle  or  cartouche  (symbol)     The  important  thing  is  to  tell  the  reader  what  the  story  is.  Consider  it   the  map's  introduc3on.  It  may  also  be  decorated  to  the  point  of  being   the  main  decora3on  on  the  map.  
  7. Indicate  direc?on  with  a  north  arrow,  compass  rose,  or  border

      labels   Maps  show  spa3al  rela3onships.  A  north  arrow,  compass  rose,  or   some  other  way  of  showing  direc3on  makes  a  map  instantly   iden3fiable.   When  embellished  it  can  create  a  beau3ful  decora3on.   Provide  well  understood  symbols  for  natural  features   Natural  feature  symbols  give  a  feeling  for  the  land.  Is  it   mountainous?  Are  there  rivers?  Forests?   Including  natural  features  differen3ates  desert  from  forest  and   mountains  from  plains.     Create  informa?ve  symbols  for  man-­‐made  features   Man-­‐made  features  give  a  point  of  access  for  people.  Ci3es,  roads,   railways,  and  boundaries  are  part  of  the  human  experience.   Including  these  features  tell  the  reader  where  people  live,  how  they   can  travel,  and  how  they  define  their  region.  
  8. Include  a  touch  of  fancy  with  figures,  animals,  monsters,  ships,

      architectural  features,  winds,  or  heraldic  devices     Added  with  taste,  these  can  add  enormously  to  a  map's   enjoyment.  They  can  also  be  used  to  de-­‐mark  interes3ng  historic   events,  points  of  interest,  or  any  other  informa3on  important  to   the  purpose  of  the  map.     Orienta?on     Although  maps  oriented  with  north  at  the  top  are  by  far  the   most  common,  consider  the  shape  of  the  area  you  are  mapping   in  your  design  choice.  Some3mes  a  different  orienta3on  can   make  a  map  design  both  unique  and  remarkable.  
  9. Principles  Of  Good  Symbol  Design     Good  symbol  design

     for  a  map  doesn't  have  to  be  difficult.  Keep   these  principles  in  mind  when  designing  your  own...       Make  it  easy  to  iden?fy   Make  it  memorable  (closed  in  form)   Be  careful  of  abstrac?on  level       Make  it  reducible     Design  for  one  color     Use  nega?ve  space   Give  it  appropriate  weight   Give  it  appropriate  direc?on   Don't  mix  line-­‐outline  and  silhoueSe  symbols  
  10. Map  Symbol  Forms     Map  symbols  need  to  communicate

     informa1on  in  a  clear  way.  Decora1ve  maps   symbols  should  go  further  to  communicate  in  a6rac1ve  way.       There  are  many  different  kinds  of  symbols:     Pictorial     Geometric          
  11. Varie?es  of  symbols     Symbols  are  used  to  represent

     the  topographic  features  of  a  map  and  can  be  divided  into  five   categories  oPen  grouped  by  color...     Hydrography       (Water  features  usually  represented  in  blue)       Culture   (Man-­‐made  features  usually  represented  by  black  or  red)       Hypsography     Relief  features  including  hills  and  mountains  usually  represented  in  brown     Vegeta?on  and  cul?va?on     Natural  and  agricultural  features  usually  represented  in  green       Special  symbols    This  is  a  catch  category  usually  represented  in  purple  or  orange      
  12. Map  Symbols  For  Buildings  And  Ci?es     The  ubiquitous

     circle  =  city  will  instantly  be  recognized,  but  if  not   offset  by  other  decora1on  and  ornamenta1on  will  look  boring.   Consider  an  old-­‐style  or  pictorial  representa1on  instead.   Make  your  map  interes1ng  by  including  side-­‐view  profiles  of   famous  spots  such  as  lighthouses.  They  are  instantly  recognizable   and  will  add  a  great  deal  of  connec1on  with  viewers.   This  can  be  really  effec1ve  in  a  pictorial  city  representa1on!   Here  are  some  symbols  from  his  book  Principles  of  Cartography...   Here  are  some  stylized  building  symbols  from  old  maps  from   Heather  Child's  book  "Decora1ve  Maps".  
  13. Map  Symbols  For  Mountains     Here  are  some  stylized

     mountain  symbols  from  old  maps  from  Heather  Child's  book   "Decora1ve  Maps".  
  14. Map  Symbols  For  River  Features     Here  are  some

     stylized  river  feature  symbols  from  old  maps  from   Heather  Child's  book  "Decora1ve  Maps".  
  15. In  the  following  pages   there  are  set  of  symbols

      were  used  to  create   historical  looking  maps!!      
  16. In  the  following  maps  for  the  Persian  Gulf  will  show

     the   different  map  design  elements  that  were  used  for   example:       1-­‐  Texture:  becomes  the  representa1on  of  water  body   waves  (gulf).  The  movement  of  the  water  makes  it  a  great   piece  of  art.  The  waves  are  designed  to  relate  to  the  actual   height  of  waves.  Simple  gradated  lines  or  waves  near  the   shoreline  can  add  interes1ng  texture,  also...   2-­‐  Color:  Colored  an1que  maps  also  have  varia1on...  It   adds  a  lot  of  visual  interest.  Even  large  spaces  such  as  the   city  and  the  surrounding  country  have  variability  so  that  it   feels  like  organic  land.        
  17. 3-­‐  DecoraIve  symbols  (An1que  compass  roses):    evolved  out  of

     a  historical   use  of  maps  for  naviga1on.  That  purpose  required  a  need  for  finding  a  bearing,  or   direc1on  of  movement,  from  a  point  on  the  map  to  another  point   on  the  map.     An  an1que  compass  rose  tends  to  be  more  elaborate  than  modern,  simplified   designs.  They  oPen  have  a  complex  stack  of  direc1onal  layers  with  an  elaborate   center  and  oPen  a  fleur  de  lis  or  some  other  symbol  for  the  north  point...   The  ornate  an1que  compass  rose  is  the  opposite  of  the  streamlined  simplified   modern  north  arrow  compass  rose.     This  complex  design  fits  in  with  the  ornate  nature  of  an1que  maps.     This  is  the  reason  a  map  designer  should  take  the  gestalt,  or  overall  look  of  a   map,  into  considera1on...   A  highly  ornate  an1que  compass  rose  just  doesn't  fit  into  a  simplified  map.  And  a   design  emula1ng  an  an1que  maps  doesn't  look  right  without  an  ornate  compass   rose...   However,  deriving  a  simplified  version  can  really  bring  a  decora1ve  map  to  life.      
  18. Map  Symbols  Today           Map  symbols

     are  simply  pictures  that  stand  in  for  words.     Modern  maps  tend  to  use  simple,  smaller,  abstract  symbols   to  represent  features  on  maps.       These  stylized  symbols  are  efficient,  but  not  very  decora1ve   or  compelling  to  look  at.  But  this  simplicity  and  smallness  of   mapping  symbols  is  necessary  because  the  density  of   informa1on  on  the  map  demands  it.      
  19. My  preferences     I  like  pictorial  symbols.  To  me

     it  adds  a  lot  of  expressiveness  to  the   map  and  allows  the  map  ar1st  to  express  a  point  of  view.   I  also  tend  to  like  organic  representa1ons.         What  are  your  preferences?       Look  at  maps  you  really  enjoy  and  decide  what  about  the  symbols   appeals  to  you.