Share
Embed
Three-Phase Eutectic Microstructures: Influence of solid-solid interfacial energy anisotropy and diffusivities
Daniel Wheeler
July 21, 2022
Transcript
65 slides
-
Three-Phase Eutectic Microstructures: Influence of solid-solid interfacial energy anisotropy and
diffusivities Sumeet Khanna, Aramanda Shanmukha Kiran, Abhik Choudhury Department of Materials Engineering Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru -
Outline • A brief overview of my group’s activities •
Complications in three-phase eutectics • Solid-solid interfacial energy anisotropy and its influence • Three-phase eutectics: Anisotropy and diffusivity contrast • Our ongoing work -
My group’s activities • Multi-phase multi-component solidification • Multi-component growth
and coarsening • Multi-physics problems, that include coupling of electric, thermal and mechanical effects • Interfacial instabilities • Multi-scaling • Directional solidification experiments -
Experimental Microstructures Nb-Al-Ni; 2 fibrous Ag-Al-Cu; brick structure Ref: Contieri
et al., Materials Characterization, 2008 Ref: Dennstedt et al., IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng, 2014 -
Three-phase Eutectic Microstructures • Microstructure ideally classified into 5 distinct
types Lamellar ABC Ref: D. Lewis, et al., Journal of electronic materials, 2002 Hexagonal (all fibrous) Brick type Fibres in matrix Lamellar BABC Lamellar + fibrous -
Parameters affecting Microstructure • Phase fraction, liquidus slopes (thermodynamics) •
Solidification velocity • Interface energy (relative values) • Interface energy anisotropy(solid/solid and solid/liquid) • Diffusivities (contrast in the solutal diffusivities in multicomponent systems) -
Three-phase pattern formation during solidification (AgAlCu eutectic) Lorenz Ratke, Anne
Dennstedt, DLR Koln Coupling with databases using Choudhury et al.: Current Opinion in Solid-state and materials science, Vol. 287, 2015. -
Statistical characterization of structures (in collaboration with Prof. Surya Kalidindi
(Acta Materialia110 (2016) 131–141)) -
Ternary eutectics are more complicated than we thought, as we
found out upon doing our own experiments -
So things are quite complicated indeed !! In this talk
we are going to try to resolve two aspects pertinent to most metallic and multi- component systems 1) Influence of solid-solid anisotropy 2) The multicomponent nature of the problem and the influence of a diffusivity contrast between the solutes on pattern formation -
How can solid-solid interfacial energy anisotropy influence microstructure formation? Let
us look at a simplified binary first: Experiments and simulations Sn-Zn binary eutectic system -
Phase diagram of Sn-Zn system L⇌(Sn)+(Zn) Tm = 198.5 C
Volume percent: (Sn)=91, (Zn)=9. 21-07-2022 19 S n Zn BC T HCP -
21-07-2022 20 IPF and phase map of Sn-Zn alloy solidified
at V= 0.58μm/s Inverse pole figure map Phase map -
21-07-2022 21 Microstructures of Sn-Zn eutectic Transverse sections Bright phase
is tin(Sn) Dark phase is zinc(Zn) V= 0.58 μm/s V= 1 μm/s V= 5. 0μm/s V= 7.5 μm/s V= 10.0 μm/s V= 50 μm/s -
22 T = k1 V + k2 / Jackson-Hunt(1966, AIME)
predictions 2 min V = k2 /k1 Rods -
In the presence of solid-solid interfacial energy anisotropy, different interface
plane orientations for a fixed crystal orientation would have different energies Solid-solid interfacial energy anisotropy -
SEM images captured 20mm, 30mm, 40mm, 50mm and 60 mm
respectively from the bottom Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A volume 51, pages6387– 6405(2020) -
Phase-field Model • Phase evolution equation • Diffusion potential evolution
equation Phas e 𝜙 0 𝜙 1 𝜙 2 Sn 1 0 0 Zn 0 1 0 Liqui d 0 0 1 Ref: A Choudhury, B. Nestler - Physical Review E, 2012 M. Plapp - Physical Review E, 2011 -
Thermodynamics • Parabolic approximation to free-energies near the eutectic temperature
Ref: COST 507, Thermochemical database for light metal alloys, 1998 -
Simulation Setup • Representation of hexagonal symmetry White rectangle =
Actual simulation domain with reflective boundary conditions Zn = blue Sn = Red Directional solidification setup -
Implementation of Anisotropy in 𝛾 Sn-Zn Solid-Solid Interface Energy Anisotropy
with 2-fold Symmetry 𝜃 R = 0o 𝜃 R = 90o Polar plot of interface energy Equilibrium Rod Shape -
Spacing = 1.05𝜆 min ➢ No departure from hexagonal rod
arrangement 𝜃 R = 0o 𝜃 R = 90o Isotropic Steady state Solid-Liquid Interface -
Spacing = 1.4𝜆 min Equilibrium Solid-Liquid Interface 𝜃 R =
0o 𝜃 R = 90o ➢ Transformation to lamellar and rectangular arrangement of Zn-phase -
Solid-Liquid Interface Temperature 𝜃 R = 0o 𝜃 R =
90o T I M E Interfaces with higher undercooling get eliminated -
Extended Simulations All Zn-rods oriented in only 1 direction with
respect to the Sn-matrix -
You can find more details about this combined study in
two publications: a) Role of Solid–Solid Interfacial Energy Anisotropy in the Formation of Broken Lamellar Structures in Eutectic Systems Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A volume 51, pages 6327– 6345(2020) b) Crystallographic and Morphological Evidence of Solid–Solid Interfacial Energy Anisotropy in the Sn-Zn Eutectic System Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A volume 51, pages 6387– 6405(2020) -
Intermediate conclusions • The solid-solid interfacial energy anisotropy influences solidification
dynamics although there is no kinetics in the solid!! • In the resultant morphology the orientations of the solid-solid interface correspond to lower energy directions in the gamma-plot -
Experimental observations • Turns out there are orientation relationships and
associated solid-solid interfacial anisotropy even in three-phase eutectics, you can find more information here: • Quasi-isotropic and locked grain growth dynamics in a three-phase eutectic system Samira Mohagheghi, Melis Serefoglu; Acta Materialia 151 (2018) 432e442 • Effects of interphase boundary anisotropy on the three-phase growthdynamics in the β(In) – In2Bi – γ(Sn) ternary-eutectic system; S Mohagheghi, U Hecht, S Bottin-Rousseau, S Akamatsu, G Faivre3, M Şerefoğlu1 IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 529 (2019) 012010 -
c A c B c C 0.333 0.333 0.333 0.6
0.2 0.2 0.2 0.6 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.6 Thermodynamics: Symmetric Phase diagram Parabolic free energies for each phase: Phase composition at T eutectic -
Phase-field Model • Phase evolution equation Ref: A Choudhury, B.
Nestler - Physical Review E, 2012 M. Plapp - Physical Review E, 2011 Gradient energy Driving force • Diffusion potential evolution equation -
Simulation Setup • Directional Solidification setup in constrained domain settings
• Simulations with different spacing Hexagonal configuration Regular Brick Alternating Brick Cross-section of solid-liquid interface Periodic Boundary Neumann Boundary -
Hexagon Regular Brick Isotropic Interfacial Energies • At lower spacings,
hexagon transform to lamellae • At larger spacings, hexagon transforms to smaller hexagons • Bricks cannot transform to lamella at smaller spacings -
Unequal diffusivities: Isotropic Interfacial Energy • Presence of curved triple
lines • Reduction in volume fraction • Shape Factor where, -
Unequal diffusivities: Isotropic Interfacial Energy • The perimeter/area of the
phase richer in slower diffusing component increases -
Unequal diffusivities: Anisotropic Interfacial Energy Distorted Hexagon Brick Brick Lamella
𝜆/𝜆𝑚𝑖𝑛 > 1.27 < 0.83 𝜆/𝜆𝑚𝑖𝑛 > 1.27 -
Unequal diffusivities: Undercooling-Spacing Plot • Similar to equal diffusivities, undercooling
decreases with increasing number of anisotropic interfaces -
Extended Simulations Perimeter ratio: • Unequal diffusivities leads to a
higher perimeter ratio -
Conclusion • Hexagonal microstructures are most probable when everything is
symmetric---uncommon in experimental situations • Brick microstructures occur most frequently in simulations • Lamellar microstructures occur when all the solid-solid interfaces are anisotropic and the anisotropy functions have the same orientations • Unequal diffusivities lead to curved triple-line projections and the patterns have reduced symmetry • Combination of diffusivities and interfacial energy anisotropy leads to diverse microstructure even when the eutectic solid phases have equal volume fraction -
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT • SERC (Supercomputing facility at IISc, Cray XC- 40)
• Thematic Unit of Excellence-Computational Materials Science (TUE-CMS) • Department of Science and Technology DSTO1679 THANK YOU