statement about student’s learning outside of or at end of learning WHAT Summative, with a score and consequences EXAMPLES Test after a unit or course completed for a grade, SAT, MCAS, A-Levels, etc. Source: Stiggins, Arter, Chappuis, Chappuis (2006) & Earl (2006)
still occurring WHY To make a statement about student’s learning outside of or at end of learning To solidify new learning, diagnose needs, next steps, help students feel in control & improve. WHAT Summative, with a score and consequences Formative, data informs next steps EXAMPLES Test after a unit or course completed for a grade, SAT, MCAS, A-Levels, etc. Q&A in class, games, low-stakes quizzes with right/wrong feedback Source: Stiggins, Arter, Chappuis, Chappuis (2006) & Earl (2006)
is still occurring While students are monitoring their own learning WHY To make a statement about student’s learning outside of or at end of learning To solidify new learning, diagnose needs, next steps, help students feel in control & improve. To promote self-directed learning, deepen understanding WHAT Summative, with a score and consequences Formative, data informs next steps Formative, Self-assessment, peer-assessment EXAMPLES Test after a unit or course completed for a grade, SAT, MCAS, A-Levels, etc. Q&A in class,, games, low-stakes quizzes with right/wrong feedback Rubrics, checklists, self-assessment surveys, goal setting tools Source: Stiggins, Arter, Chappuis, Chappuis (2006) & Earl (2006)
Illinois, Urbana-Champaign When the cook tastes the soup, that’s formative... When the guests taste the soup, that’s summative. “ ” learning Assessment learning
do we want to measure it? What will we do with the output? job-task analysis (JTA); learning objectives, blueprints, content Timing, format, scoring methodology: length and structure, Frequency, costs Stakes: dictate security, (Proctoring, id validation); consequences for the learner
I want to know if a learner has met a predetermined standard regardless of others Norm-referenced: I want to know where a learner ranks relative to others
a predetermined standard regardless of others Norm-referenced: I want to know where a learner ranks relative to others depends on what you want to measure & why
Fight the human tendency to simplify complex results: remember the jaggedness principle • Assessments are only part of a bigger landscape of dependencies required to overcome bias and disparities: make sure your organization is on the right side of this work. More in the Boston Globe: The Great Divide
Doing It Right Using It Well, 2nd edition. • The Perfect Assessment System, Rick Stiggins • The End of Average, Todd Rose • Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing, AERA • Handbook of Test Development, Lane, Raymond & Haladyna • The MisMeasure of Man, Stephen Jay Gould • Weapons of Math Destruction, Cathy O’Neill