Share
Embed
[Openmind 2012] Mobile ecosystems? How open they really are, should or could be? by Kimmo Karhu (Researcher, Aalto University)
Openmind 2012 / Open Knowledge Festival 2012
http://okfestival.org/open-source-software/
COSS
September 19, 2012
Transcript
18 slides
-
Mobile ecosystems? How open they really are, should or could
be? Kimmo Karhu Researcher Aalto University [email protected] September 19, 2012 OKFestival 2012 -
Happy couple or a forced marriage? Seriously thinking: What are
the consequences of this handshake for openness in mobile ecosystems? -
Phenomenal success of App Store • More than 700 000
apps available for iPhone • These apps have been downloaded more than 30 billion times! • On average, each iPad user has downloaded around 100 apps • $5.5 billion paid to developers -
Business ecosystem • A company should be viewed not as
a member of a single industry but as part of a business ecosystem that crosses a variety of industries • Companies work cooperatively and competitively to support new products and satisfy customer needs Moore, J. F. Predators and prey: A new ecology of competition. Harvard Business Review, 71, 3, May-June 1993, 75-86. -
Coopetition - to cooperate and compete simultaneously • During the
last decade, a new coopetition business model has emerged where company chooses to collaborate with its direct competitors • For example, Amazon collaborates with other bookstores by providing them the infrastructure to market and sell their products online Bengtsson, M., and Kock, S. “Coopetition” in business networks - To cooperate and compete simultaneously. Industrial Marketing Management, 29, 5, 2000, 411-426. -
Mobile ecosystem, how does it look like? Adapted from: Karhu,
K., Botero, A., Vihavainen, S., Tang, T., & Hämäläinen, M. (2011). A Digital Ecosystem for Co-Creating Business with People. Journal of Emerging Technologies in Web Intelligence, 3(3). Retrieved from http://ojs.academypublisher.com/index.php/jetwi/article/view/jetwi0303197205 -
Problem of defining openness • Android platform is basically open-source,
but … – Official Android versions are fully controlled by Google – Google keeps value added services, such as Google Maps, Gmail, proprietary (For example, not available in Amazon ecosystem) – Prevents Android manufacturers from participating in forked ecosystems (Acer – Alibaba case) • Even though the platform is proprietary (such as iOS), APIs are open for developers to build their own apps – How much should this aspect contribute to the openness of the ecosystem? – Sarcastic note: “Open”, but you have to pay for it • Instead of trying to define and estimate “openness” directly, we estimated it from the level of competition and collaboration towards other actors in the ecosystems -
Measuring the level of competition and collaboration • For each
ecosystem, we estimated the level of competition and collaboration towards all different type of actors in the ecosystem • For example in Apple ecosystem: – Regarding phone manufacturers, Apple has high level of competition since it manufactures and sells phones itself and zero level of collaboration, since it doesn’t license its platform for other manufacturers • This process was repeated for each actor and each ecosystem -
Findings from the analysis • It seems that all platforms
have chosen or are moving towards closed and competitive policies – Tough business environment for other actors • However, there are also signs that more open platforms are emerging – For example, HTML5 and packaged web apps for mobiles -
What has really happened? Components Device Operating system Services Advertisement
Market place Content (incl. apps) Microsoft Used to be … Apple Google Amazon Now • Leaders behind the mobile ecosystems have emerged from different type of companies • They have all extended their business into virtually all business segments -
In these ecosystems, what kind of role is left for
other “species”, i.e. businesses? -
Are developer ”human rights” violated? • To be able to
test and run your own application in your own phone you have to pay ~$99 per year (iPhone, Windows) • Ad-hoc distribution: after paying this $99/year, you can share your apps to a maximum 100 other users (iPhone, Windows) – Windows phone puts a further time limit of 90 days! • Microsoft, Apple and Amazon reserve the right not to publish your application in their market place or remove it from there (for any reason or no reason) – Note! For Windows Phone there are no other ways to distribute your application! -
Mobile ecosystems are shifting away from original business ecosystem thinking
• It used to be so that business ecosystem meant true collaboration (and competition) between companies (each having their fair share of business) • For mobile ecosystems, instead, it seems that leading companies swear by vertical integration; they want to control and make business themselves in virtually all business areas -
Conclusions • Despite the “problems” in the openness of mobile
ecosystems, they have fostered unbelievable innovation and stream of new apps • Four biggest ecosystems seem to be moving towards closed “kingdoms” • For the next generation of ecosystems, there would be a call and possibility for a more open and fair ecosystem – Will HTML5, Mozilla or Jolla answer this call? -
Thank you. For more information, please contact: [email protected] +358 40
757 6871 http://fi.linkedin.com/in/kimmokarhu http://aalto-fi.academia.edu/kimmokarhu All Logos and Trademarks used or mentioned in this presentation are copyrighted property of their respective owners and are used only for illustrative purposes [email protected]