Share
Embed
Transcript
39 slides
-
1 Unveiling the Physics of the EoR and Cosmic Dawn
with LOFAR and NenUFAR Florent Mertens (LUX, Paris Observatory) GT ICR @ L2S - 19/05/2025 Image credit: Michale Goh/ICRAR-Curtin -
2 Cosmic Dawn ➔ Appearance of first stars/Bhs (PopIII?) ➔
Ly-α radiation field ➔ Impact of Baryonic Bulk Flows ➔ First X-ray heating sources Epoch of Reionization ➔ Reionization by stars & mini-quasars ➔ PopIII - PopII transition ➔ Emergence of the visible universe PLANCK VLT E-ELT Credit: NAOJ Cosmic Dawn Epoch of Reionization The history of our universe -
3 S Epoch of Reionization Cosmic Dawn Credit: NAOJ LOFAR
NenuFAR 21-cm HI line, probe of the first billion years -
4 The 21-cm experiments LOFAR-EoR Observation started in 2012 +
3500 h observed ➔ Properties of the IGM and ionising sources. ➔ History of reionization. NenuFAR Cosmic Dawn Observation started in 2019 + 1000 h observed ➔ Testing of non-standard models. SKA CD/EoR Completion ~2028 ➔ Nature of the first stars. ➔ Morphology of ionized regions. Bowman et al. 2018 Simulation 21-cm du LERMA LOFAR NenuFAR -
5 A challenging experiment Foregrounds emission 21-cm signal Extra-galactic sources
Galactic emission Processing pipeline Observation -
6 The Foregrounds radio sources Hardcastle et al. 2020 De
Gasperin et al. 2020 Cygnus A Cassiopeia A Taurus A Virgo A Pictor A Fornax A -
7 The challenge of the foregrounds Extragalactic point sources Galactic
diffuse emission Instrumental effects Foregrounds 21-cm signal -
8 Signature of the foregrounds 21-cm signal Astrophysical Foregrounds
Extragalactic sources Galactic diffuse emission Instrumental effects PSF/beam chromaticity Calibration errors -
9 Mitigation strategies A. Observing field selection B. Extragalactic sources
subtraction C. Residual foregrounds subtraction D. Foregrounds avoidance B + D: MWA B + C: LOFAR, AARTFAAC, NenuFAR D: HERA -
10 Selecting the right observing field Barry, Bernardi, Greig, Kern,
Mertens 2021 Criteria (tracking experiments): ➔ Low galactic emission ➔ No strong sources in the field ➔ No strong sources in sidelobes ➔ Calibrator in the field (?) ➔ High elevation (dec ~ latitude) Synergies with other surveys For drift-scan experiments: ➔ LST bins selection HERA MWA LOFAR -
11 Avoid strong sources in sidelobes Strong radio sources in
the sky may pass through the side lobes and grating lobe of the instrument: introduce strong direction-dependent effect Cygnus A Taurus A Cas A 45 MHz 60 MHz 75 MHz North Celestial Pole Observation with NenuFAR. Beam simulated with nenupy (A. Loh) -
12 Elevation of the target matters Foreground wedge extend depends
on target elevation: observing at higher elevation helps in mitigating foreground emission NCP Zenith crossing Munshi, Mertens et al 2025a -
13 Impact of RFI depends on target field Satellite image
of spot A Satellite image of spot B Spot A: delay and Fringe Rate power spectra for an example baseline Foregrounds Near-field image 12/12/2021 61 –72 MHz | NCP | A-team masked Spot A Spot B -
14 Spectral characterization of the local sources of RFI Impact
of RFI depends on target field Munshi, Mertens et al 2025b -
15 Confusion limited foregrounds + low level residuals Inner 4°
x 4° where we look for the signal Before After Point-source subtraction ➔Need accurate sky-model ➔Solve for instruments gains in direction of sources LOFAR | NCP | 140 hours | 134-146 MHz Mertens et al. 2020 -
16 Point-source subtraction NenuFAR | NCP | 11 hours |
61-72 MHz Cygnus A Cassiopeia A Taurus A Virgo A Munshi, Mertens et al. 2024 ➔Need accurate sky-model ➔Solve for instruments gains in direction of sources -
17 Gaussian Process Regression After point-source subtraction, residual foregrounds still
dominates ➔ GPR: Fits data without assuming a specific functional form. ➔ Prior Information: Encoded through a parametrized covariance function. ➔ Parameters Optimization: Covariance parameters are determined by maximizing the marginal likelihood. ➔ Data fitting: Conditioning the prior model to the data, we obtain fit + uncertainty. -
18 GPR for 21-cm experiments Extra-galactic Galactic emission Instrumental effects
No functional forms but very different spectral characteristic → Statistical model prior made of Gaussian Process (GP). → Learnt kernel is used for the 21-cm prior covariance. 21-cm signal Hyper-parameters of the covariance prior to be optimized with the data Intrinsic FG Mode-mixing FG 21-cm Coherence-scale V a r i a n c e Frequency slice Freq-freq covariance Mertens et al. 2018 Mertens, Bobin, Carucci 2024 -
19 Learned covariance function VAE: Trained to minimize: ➔ Reconstruction
error. KL divergence to standard Gaussian in latent space. ✔ Compressed information (lower dimension latent space). ✔ Generative. 21-cm covariance Latent-space parameters Input Output Encoder Decoder Latent space Variational Auto-Encoder (VAE) 21cmFast Training set Decoder PS to cov Mertens, Bobin, Carucci 2024 -
21 The Epoch of Reionization with LOFAR The LOFAR-EoR team
The LOFAR telescope -
23 Deeper multi-redshift LOFAR upper limits A reduction in upper
limits by a factor ~5 to 10 for the three LOFAR redshifts (Mertens, et al. 2025) (54 mK)2 (69 mK)2 (66 mK)2 -
24 New LOFAR constraints on EoR IGM Preliminary IGM parameter
constraint analysis allows us to reject many scenarii of cold IGM (Ghara, et al. 2025) -
25 The Cosmic Dawn with NenuFAR The NenuFAR Cosmic Dawn
team The NenuFAR telescope -
26 First NenuFAR upper limit NCP field, 11.5 hours, 61-72.5
MHz, z ~ 20 (Munshi, Mertens et al. 2024) The deepest upper limit on the 21-cm power-spectra at z~20 ... but limited by bright source contamination and local RFI -
27 NenuFAR search for a “darker” deep field 2022 –
2023 observation campaign on 5 candidates deep fields Selection strategy: ➔ Minimize apparent flux from Bright A-team sources. ➔ Transit close to zenith for maximum sensitivity. Mertens et al. in prep. -
28 New NenuFAR upper limit NT04 field, 26.1 hours, z
~ 20 & z~17 (Munshi, Mertens et al. in prep.) An improvement by a factor 50 ! -
30 The goal: recover the power-spectra of a 21-cm signal
from a simulated SKA data cubes The DOTSS-21 team : 24 members (FR : 10, NL : 11) Our approach: Build on the LOFAR-EoR and NenuFAR Cosmic Dawn experience. The SKA Data Challenge 3a Bonaldi et al. 2025 -
31 DOTSS-21 results @ z~ 7.2 Step 1: Detect and
subtract compact sources Step 2: Model and subtract the Galactic diffuse emission Step 3: Extract the 21-cm signal with ML- GPR (Mertens et al. 2018, 2024) -
34 Step 1: Detect and subtract compact sources Step 2:
Model and subtract the Galactic diffuse emission Step 3: Extract the 21-cm signal with ML- GPR (Mertens et al. 2018, 2024) DOTSS-21 results @ z~ 7.2 -
35 Step 1: Detect and subtract compact sources Step 2:
Model and subtract the Galactic diffuse emission Step 3: Extract the 21-cm signal with ML-GPR (Mertens et al. 2018, 2024) DOTSS-21 results @ z~ 7.2 -
36 Step 1: Detect and subtract compact sources Step 2:
Model and subtract the Galactic diffuse emission Step 3: Extract the 21-cm signal with ML-GPR (Mertens et al. 2018, 2024) DOTSS-21 results @ z~ 7.2 -
37 DOTSS-21 results Results can be improved further • Issues
with fast evolution over the 15 MHz • Recovered image cube not perfect -
38 Summary ➔ The 21-cm signal from the Cosmic Dawn
and EoR promises a new and unique probe of the first billion year of the Universe, but very challenging experiment ➔ Status of the LOFAR-EoR project: New multi-redshift upper-limits at z=8.3, 9.1 and 10.1 Deepest @ k=0.075 cMpc-1, z ~ 9: Δ2 < (54 mK)2 Only 5% of data processed ! ➔ Status of the NenuFAR Cosmic Dawn project: First upper limit at z ~ 20 published from NCP deep field New “darker” deep field (NT04) promises exiting results ! Deepest @ k=0.04 cMpc-1, z ~ 20: Δ2 < (1414 mK)2 ➔ We are scaling-up processing significantly (LOFAR and NenuFAR) ! ➔ Our DOTSS-21 team won the SKA Data Challenge 3a !