Icons and Iconoclasm

Lecture given Tuesday October 30, 2012.

Transcript

1. !"#$%&'$(&!"#$#")'%*&
   !"#$%&'() &&
   *+,-(+#$+&",-&.-&
   .
   !#&'").
   /001234/&56&
   /01#&2&".
   &
   3"0.4"56(78,&9":+().
   !"#$+&78$89':#$+&;9#%<=$8%>%+&
   '",8>9#;#>8?'>+&;'))'(>@*+&!"#$#")'%*+&
   A'$?#<9'?#9+&B",8>9#;#>8?#%+&
   C,8#?#<#%+&D#(8E8?9>'+&F9'$%+&
   G)'",89$>:%%'+&6)8#@%'+&
   H)=<#;,>)%#@%'+&I8%?')+&!"#$#")'%?+&
   !"#$#;,>)8+&!"#$#(@)8+&!"#$#%?'%>%-&&
   3"0.;,&<6"&+().
   !  J1KJ+&7)'(>*>9&7>9E>$+&
   5#$%?'$:$#;)8+&24?,&58$?@9=&
   !  J14L+&7>9E>$&'$(&5,>)(&M>?,&
   N'>$?%&'$(&B$E8)%+&N?-&5'?,89>$8&
   '?&O?-&N>$'>+&%8"#$(&,')PP&?,8&
   Q?,&"8$?@9=-&
   !  AE-&43Q+&C,8&59@">RS>#$&'$(&
   !"#$#")'%?%&M,>?8M'%,>$E&'$&
   >"#$P&5,9>%?+&3=><$,?.@(#>+"5+&
   ./01J/-&
   !  J13K+&B$(98=&T@U)=#V+&C,8&F)(&
   C8%?'*8$?&C9>$>?=&WC,988&B$E8)%&
   7>%>:$E&BU9','*X+&23201234/-&
   

   View Slide

2. T8*>$(89&
   •  Y#@9&O=?,#)#E>"')&5#*;'9>%#$&>%&(@8&CD!N&
   CDZTN[BY&\#V-&2%?-&
   

   View Slide

3. ],'?&>%&'$&!"#$^&
   !  H8$89')_&CM#1
   (>*8$%>#$')&
   98;98%8$?':#$%&
   !  N;8">R"_&A>"?@98%P&
   ,#)=&;89%#$%+&8V8$?%+&
   V8$89'?8(&U=&?,8&
   6'%?89$&",@9",-&
   J14L+&7>9E>$&6$?,9#$8(&M>?,&N'>$?%&'$(&B$E8)%+&N?-&
   5'?,89>$8`%P&O#@$?&N>$'>+&6E=;?+&Q?,&58$?@9=&56-&&
   

   View Slide

4. G=a'$:$8&6*;>98&>$&?,8&Q?,&58$?@9=&
   

   View Slide

5. N?-&5'?,89>$8`%P&O#@$?&N>$'>+&6E=;?+&/?,&
   58$?@9=&56-&&
   

   View Slide

6. N?-&5'?,89>$8`%P&O#@$?&N>$'>+&6E=;?+&/?,&
   58$?@9=&56-&&
   

   View Slide

7. N?-&5'?,89>$8`%P&O#@$?&N>$'>+&6E=;?+&/?,&
   58$?@9=&56-&&
   

   View Slide

8. N?-&5'?,89>$8`%P&O#@$?&N>$'>+&6E=;?+&/?,&
   58$?@9=&56-&&
   

   View Slide

9. N?-&5'?,89>$8`%P&O#@$?&N>$'>+&6E=;?+&/?,&
   58$?@9=&56-&&
   !"#$#%?'%>%&
   

   View Slide

10. N?-&5'?,89>$8`%P&O#@$?&N>$'>+&6E=;?+&/?,&
    58$?@9=&56-&&
    !"#$#%?'%>%&
    

    View Slide

11. c D00D0DDN000000cD
    c
    B lo2 t X B
    2
    A 8 6 5 4 7 9 A
    3E S3
    ]#9%,>;&T#M&
    [88%>%&T#M&
    I8%?')&T#M&
    A9#;,8?%&T#M&
    T#MP&A'?9>'9",%&
    C=;>"')&!"#$#%?'%>%-&
    

    View Slide

12. C=;8%P&!"#$%&
    5,9>%?& 7>9E>$&'$(&5,>)(&
    B$E8)%&
    N'>$?%&
    I8%?')& \'99':V8&
    

    View Slide

13. 5,9>%?&
    5,9>%?&A'$?#"9'?#9+&
    N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&
    O#$'%?89=+&O?-&
    N>$'>+&Q?,&58$?@9=&
    56&
    5,9>%?&'%&O'$P&N#99#M%+&
    H988"8+&24?,&58$?@9=&
    B",8>9#;#>8?#%+&T@%%>'$+&24?,&
    58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

14. A'$?#<9'?#9&
    5,9>%?&A'$?#<9'?#9+&N?-&
    5'?,89>$8`%&O#$'%?89=+&O?-&
    N>$'>+&Q?,&58$?@9=&56&
    bC,8&B))&
    A#M89P@)c&
    

    View Slide

15. O'$P&N#99#M%&
    5,9>%?&'%&O'$P&
    N#99#M%+&H988"8+&24?,&
    58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

16. B",8>9#;#>8?#%+&T@%%>'$+&24?,&58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

17. C,8#?#<#%&d&C,8&G8'989P&H#(&
    O#%"#M+&2/?,&58$?@9=& 5#$%?'$:$#;)8+&23?,&
    58$?@9=&&
    F9'$%& 6)8#@%'&
    e=9>#:%%'& D#(8E8?9>'&
    7)'(>*>9&7>9E>$+&
    5#$%?'$:$#;)8+&24?,&
    58$?@9=&
    C,8&7>9E>$P&?,8&
    !$"'9$':#$+&T#*8+&
    22?,&58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

18. e=9>#:%%'+&D'E>'&
    N#;,>'+&5#$%?'$:$#;)8+&
    L?,&58$?@9=&
    e=9>#:%%'&
    bN,8&M,#&98>E$%&
    >$&*'f8%?=c&
    

    View Slide

19. D#(8E8?9>'+&
    5#$%?'$:$#;)8+&23?,&
    58$?@9=&&
    D#(8E8?9>'&
    bN,8&M,#&%,#M%&
    ?,8&M'=-c&
    

    View Slide

20. F9'$%&
    C,8&7>9E>$P&?,8&
    !$"'9$':#$+&T#*8+&22?,&
    58$?@9=&
    b7>9E>$P&?,8&
    %>E$-c&
    bA9'=>$E&7>9E>$c&
    F9&
    G)'",89$>:%%'&
    

    View Slide

21. 6)8#@%'&
    7)'(>*>9&7>9E>$+&
    5#$%?'$:$#;)8+&24?,&
    58$?@9=&
    b7>9E>$P&
    ?8$(89$8%%-c&
    F9&
    H)=<#;,>)%#@%'&
    b7>9E>$P&NM88?&
    e>%%8%c&
    

    View Slide

22. N'>$?%&
    N?-&A8?89+&N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&
    '?&O?-&N>$'>+&Q?,&58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

23. N?-&A8?89+&N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&
    '?&O?-&N>$'>+&Q?,&58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

24. B$E8)%&
    A#9?9'>?%& O>9'")8%&
    B9",'$E8)&
    H'U9>8)+&O#%"#M+&
    2K.J12KL/&
    B9",'$E8)&
    O>",'8)+&H988"8+&
    23?,&58$?@9=&&
    O>9'")8&'?&5,#$'8+&
    N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&
    O#$'%?89=&'?&O?-&
    N>$'>+&24?,&58$?@9=-&
    

    View Slide

25. O>9'")8%&
    O>9'")8&'?&5,#$'8+&
    N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&
    O#$'%?89=&'?&O?-&
    N>$'>+&24?,&58$?@9=-&
    

    View Slide

26. I8%?')&
    C,8&B$$@$">':#$+&bF,9>(&
    B$$@$">':#$+&O'"8(#$>'+&23?,&
    58$?@9=&
    C,8&\':V>?=+&N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&O?-&
    N>$'>+&J?,&58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

27. F9?,#(#S&I8%?')&['=%&
    !  I8'%?&('=% (898(&U=&"')8$('9&('?8&
    !  G';:%*P&g8%@%&U=&g#,$&?,8&I#989@$$89&Wg'$@'9=&QX&
    !  C,8&A98%8$?':#$P&g8%@%&>$&?,8&C8*;)8&WI8U9@'9=&4X&
    !  C,8&B$$@$">':#$&WO'9",&4/X&
    !  C,8&T'>%>$EP&h'a'9@%&WN'?@9('=&U8P#98&A')*&N@$('=X&
    !  6$?9=&>$?#&g89@%')8*&WA')*&N@$('=X&
    !  C,8&59@">RS>#$&WH##(&I9>('=X&
    !  C,8&T8%@998":#$&W6'%?89 &D#)=&A'%",'X&
    !  C,8&B%"8$%>#$&W30&('=%&'i89&6'%?89X&
    !  O8%#1A8$?8"#%?&Wg8%@%+&24&=8'9%)(+&)8"?@98%&?,8&g8M>%,&
    A9>8%?%&>$&?,8&C8*;)8X&
    !  C,8&[8%"8$?P&?,8&D#)=&N;>9>?&WA8$?8"#%?+&/0&('=%&'i89&
    6'%?89X&
    !  C,8&C9'$%RE@9':#$&WB@E@%?&QX&
    !  C,8&[#9*>:#$P&?,8&D#)=&7>9E>$&j&WB@E@%?&2/X&
    !  C,8&\':V>?=P&?,8&7>9E>$&O'9=&WN8;?8*U89&.X&
    !  C,8&6S')?':#$P&?,8&59#%%&WU=&B9",-&k>$#$+&5#@9?8%=&
    F9?,#(#S&]#9)(X&j&
    !  C,8&A98%8$?':#$P&?,8&7>9E>$&>$&?,8&C8*;)8&W\#V8*U89&
    42X&
    !  C,8&\':V>?=P@9&h#9(&g8%@%&5,9>%?&W[8"8*U89&4/X&&
    C,8&\':V>?=+&N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&O?-&
    N>$'>+&J?,&58$?@9=&
    

    View Slide

28. \'99':V8%&
    C,8&h'((89P&[>V>$8&B%"8$?+&
    P9#*&N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&'?&O#@$?&
    N>$'>+&J?,&58$?@9=-&
    B$(98=&T@U)=#V+&C,8&F)(&
    C8%?'*8$?&C9>$>?=&WC,988&B$E8)%&
    7>%>:$E&BU9','*X+&23201234/-&
    

    View Slide

29. C,8&h'((89P&[>V>$8&B%"8$?+&
    P9#*&N?-&5'?,89>$8`%&'?&
    O#@$?&N>$'>+&J?,&58$?@9=-&
    

    View Slide

30. J13K+&B$(98=&T@U)=#V+&C,8&
    F)(&C8%?'*8$?&C9>$>?=&
    WC,988&B$E8)%&7>%>:$E&
    BU9','*X+&23201234/-&
    

    View Slide

31. j!"#"$%&'#&>%&?,8&'"?P&,#$#9>$E&
    5,9>%?&'$(&%'>$?%&?,9#@E,&?,8>9&>*'E8-&&
    A9#"8%%>#$%&
    

    View Slide

32. View Slide

33. j!"#"$%&'#&>%&?,8&'"?P&,#$#9>$E&
    5,9>%?&'$(&%'>$?%&?,9#@E,&?,8>9&>*'E8-&&
    e>%%>$E&
    

    View Slide

34. View Slide

35. j!"#"$%&'#&>%&?,8&'"?P&,#$#9>$E&
    5,9>%?&'$(&%'>$?%&?,9#@E,&?,8>9&>*'E8-&&
    A9#%<=$8%>%&
    

    View Slide

36. View Slide

37. !"#$#")'%*&
    W6><#$&d&!*'E8X&l&We)'#&d&G98'

    View Slide

38. !"#$#")'%?%&WG98'<89%P&!*'E8%X_&
    2X  !"#$%&'98&'<>$&?#&?,8&bE9'V8$&>*'E8%c&*8$:#$8(&
    >$&?,8&%8"#$(&"#**'$(*8$?_&()*+,'-*.,%/0*#'0*
    1%2"*-#0'*0,""*%#3*4$%5"#*61%4"7*'$*%#3*/62"#"..*
    !"#$%'()%**0,%0*)+*6#*,"%5"#*%8'5"7*'$*0,%0*)+*6#*
    0,"*"%$0,*8"#"%0,7*'$*0,%0*)+*6#*0,"*9%0"$*-#:"$*
    0,"*"%$0,;,**0,'-*.,%/0*#'0*8'9*:'9#*0,3."/<*0'*
    0,"17*#'$*."$5"*0,"1=>*?-.!/0+*@A;*)BCD*
    4X  !"#$%&'98&*'$&*'(8+&'%;#%8(&?#&98)>"+&'$(&(#&
    $#?&(8%89V8&?#&U8&V8$89'?8(_&(+,"*:656#"*#%0-$"*6.*
    E'1F/"0"/3*-#E6$E-1.E$68%8/"*%#:*E%##'0*8"*
    :"F6E0":*'$*$"F$"."#0":*83*%$&.0.*6#*%#3*1":6-1*
    9,%0.'"5"$=>*?GE'#'E/%.&E*H'-#E6/7*IC)D&
    

    View Slide

39. !"#$#(@)8%&Wh#V89%P&!*'E8%X_&
    2X  !"#$%&'98&;#M89P@)&(>('":"&?##)%_&(J#*61%4"*6.7*%K"$*
    %//7*%*$"16#:"$L*60*6.*0'*0,"*6//60"$%0"*9,%0*%*8''2*6.*
    0'*0,"*/60"$%0"7*%#:*9,%0*0,"*9'$:*6.*0'*,"%$6#47*0,"*
    61%4"*6.*0'*.64,0=>*?M',#*'<*N%1%.E-.D*
    4X  !"#$%&'98&'&V')@'U)8&;9#S=&U=&M,>",&?,8&P'>?,P@)&"#@)(&
    (8*#$%?9'?8&?,8>9&)#V8&'$(&,#$#9&P#9&?,8&(>V>$8_&
    (O':*E$"%0":*1%#*0'*,6.*'9#*61%4">*?O"#".6.*P;@ID&
    KX  !"#$%&'98&'&V')>(&M'=&?#&"#**@$>"'?8&5,9>%?`%&
    ,@*'$>?=&'$(&%@m89>$E_&(Q'97*6#:"":7*E%#*0,"*R'#*
    '<*O':*8"*%E2#'9/":4":*0'*,%5"*8""#*%*1%#*/62"*-.
    S,"*9,'*9%.*:"64#":*0'*8"*E%//":*'-$*8$'0,"$S6<*
    ,"*E%##'0*8"*:"F6E0":T>*
    

    View Slide

40. AE-&43Q+&C,8&59@">RS>#$&
    '$(&!"#$#")'%?%&
    M,>?8M'%,>$E&'$&>"#$P&
    5,9>%?+&3=><$,?.@(#>+"5+&
    ./01J/-&
    

    View Slide

41. N>*#$&O'E@%&'$(&
    A'?9>'9",&
    \><8;,#9#%+&
    3=><$,?.@(#>+"5+
    ./01J/-&
    

    View Slide

42. B$E8)&[9'EE>$E&!"#$#")'%?+&3=><$,?.@(#>+"5+
    ./01J/-&
    

    View Slide

43. C,8#(#9'&!$%?9@":$E&,89&['@E,?89%&>$&?,8&78$89':#$&
    #P&!"#$%+&O'(9>(&N<=)>?a8%+&24?,&58$?@9=-&&
    

    View Slide

44. !"#$P&?,8&
    C9>@*;,P&
    F9?,#(#S=+&
    5#$%?'$:$#;)8+&
    2300-&
    

    View Slide

45. 59>:"')&C,>$<>$E&n@8%:#$%&
    2-  ],'?&>%&'$&>"#$^&&],'?&9#)8&(>(&?,8=&;)'=&>$&
    G=a'$:$8&M#9%,>;^&
    4-  D#M&(#8%&?,8&>"#$&>$?89'"?&M>?,&?,8&%'"98(^&
    K-  ],'?&'98&?,8&'9E@*8$?%&P#9&'$(&'E'>$%?&?,8&
    @%8P&>"#$%&>$&?,8&",@9",^&
    3-  ],'?&>%&!"#$#")'%*^&&],'?&M898&?,8&
    ">9"@*%?'$"8%&?,'?&)8(&?#&?,8&!"#$#")'%*^&
    

    View Slide