Share
Embed
Target trial emulationの概要
目標
①Target trial emulationのコンセプトを知る
② Target trial emulationを使っている論文を読めるようになる
Shuntaro Sato
December 17, 2023
Transcript
45 slides
-
ຊͷྲྀΕ 2 w ҼՌޮՌͷ͓͞Β͍ w ؍ݚڀͰੜ͡ΔόΠΞε w ަབྷ w ෆࢮ࣌ؒόΠΞε
w %FQMFUJPOPGTVTDFQUJCMFTCJBT w طଘॲํऀόΠΞε w 5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPO w 5JNF[FSP w *OUFOUJPOUPUSFBUޮՌɺ1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ w ࣮ྫ w Ͳͷ͙Β͍ΘΕ͍ͯΔ͔ʁ -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷ֓ཁ 3 3FTFBSDI2VFTUJPO ϥϯμϜԽൺֱࢼݧʢ3$5ʣ ؍ݚڀ ࣮ࡍ࣮ࢪͰ͖ͳ͍ w ద֨ج४ w ΞτΧϜ
w հೖʢରরʣ w Γ͍ͨޮՌ w ϑΥϩʔͷํ๏ ͠3$5ΛσβΠϯ͢ΔͳΒ Ͳ͏Ή͔ʁ w ద֨ج४ w ΞτΧϜ w հೖʢରরʣ w Γ͍ͨޮՌ w ϑΥϩʔͷํ๏ 5BSHFUUSJBM ͑ΔσʔλͰߟ͑Δ &NVMBUJPO ฿͢Δ -
ҩֶݚڀͷྨ 5 %FTDSJQUJPO &YQMPSJOH BTTPDJBUJPOT 1SFEJDUJPO $BVTBMJOGFSFODF %JBHOPTUJD QFSGPSNBODF FWBMVBUJPO
هड़ ؔ࿈ͷ୳ࡧ ༧ଌ ҼՌਪ அͷੑೳධՁ มͲΜͳ͔ʁ Ͳͷม͕ΞτΧϜʹ ؔ࿈͢Δ͔ʁ ΞτΧϜΛ༧ଌ͢Δ ॲஔ͕ΞτΧϜʹ Өڹ͢Δ͔ʁ ҙͷධՁํ๏ͷ அੑೳʁ w )FSOÂO." )TV+ )FBMZ#"4FDPOE$IBODFUP(FU$BVTBM*OGFSFODF3JHIU"$MBTTJ fi DBUJPOPG%BUB4DJFODF5BTLT$IBODF+BO r w 7JUUJOHIP ff & (MJEEFO%7 4IJCPTLJ4$ .D$VMMPDI$&3FHSFTTJPONFUIPETJOCJPTUBUJTUJDTMJOFBS MPHJTUJD TVSWJWBM BOESFQFBUFENFBTVSFTNPEFMT4QSJOHFS4DJFODF#VTJOFTT .FEJB ຊѻ͏ͷ ͜͜ -
ҼՌਪʢ$BVTBMJOGFSFODFʣ 6 " : w ॲஔ"ɺΞτΧϜ:ʹӨڹ͢Δ͔ʁ w ΞτΧϜ:ʹର͢Δॲஔ"ͷޮՌʁ
ݪҼ ॲஔʢ5SFBUNFOUʣ հೖʢ*OUFSWFOUJPOʣ മ࿐ʢ&YQPTVSFʣ ݁Ռ ΞτΧϜʢ0VUDPNFʣ -
3$5ͱ؍ݚڀͷ݁Ռʹҧ͍͕͋Δ 9 ຫੑਛଁױऀʹର͢Δɺಁੳͷ։࢝࣌ظ༧ޙʹӨڹ͢Δ͔ʁ 3$5ʢ*%&"-ࢼݧʣ ؍ݚڀ $PPQFS #" #SBOMFZ 1 #VMGPOF
- $PMMJOT +' $SBJH +$ 'SBFOLFM .# )BSSJT " +PIOTPO %8 ,FTTFMIVU + -J ++ -VYUPO ( 1JMNPSF " 5JMMFS %+ )BSSJT % $ 1PMMPDL $" *%&"-4UVEZ "SBOEPNJ[FE DPOUSPMMFEUSJBMPGFBSMZWFSTVT MBUFJOJUJBUJPOPGEJBMZTJT5IF/FX&OHMBOE+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF rͷ 'JHVSF# ༧ޙʹࠩͳ͍ ޙظ։࢝ͷํ͕༧ޙ͕ྑ͍ 4VTBOUJUBQIPOH 1 "MUBNJNJ 4 "TILBS . #BML &. 4UFM 74 8SJHIU 4 +BCFS #- ('3BUJOJUJBUJPOPGEJBMZTJTBOENPSUBMJUZJO$,%BNFUBBOBMZTJT "NFSJDBO+PVSOBMPG,JEOFZ%JTFBTFT5IF0 ff i DJBM+PVSOBMPGUIF/BUJPOBM,JEOFZ 'PVOEBUJPO rͷ'JHVSF -
ෆࢮ࣌ؒόΠΞεʢ*NNPSUBMUJNFCJBTʣ 11 ૣظಁੳ։࢝ ױऀɺമ࿐͕͡·Δ·Ͱɾ؍͞Εଓ͚͍ͯΔ $,%ױऀ ؍։࢝ ͜ͷ͔࣌Βίϗʔτͷ ϑΥϩʔ͕͡·Δ ܈͕ܾ·͍ͬͯͳ͍ ޙظಁੳ։࢝
ෆࢮ࣌ؒ ෆࢮ࣌ؒ മ࿐·ͰͰ͖͍ͯΔͱ͍͏͜ͱɺͦΕ·ͰΞτΧϜΛൃੜ͍ͯ͠ͳ͍ ෆࢮ͕͍࣌ؒํʹ༗ར -
Ͳͷ͘Β͍ͷݚڀͰόΠΞε͕ੜ͍ͯ͡Δ͔ʁ 15 #ZLPW , 1BUPSOP & %`"OESFB & )F .
-FF ) (SB ff +4 'SBOLMJO +. 1SFWBMFODFPG"WPJEBCMFBOE#JBT*O fl JDUJOH.FUIPEPMPHJDBM1JUGBMMTJO3FBM8PSME4UVEJFTPG .FEJDBUJPO4BGFUZBOE& ff FDUJWFOFTT$MJOJDBM1IBSNBDPMPHZBOE5IFSBQFVUJDT rͷ5BCMFΛվม -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷ֓ཁ 18 3FTFBSDI2VFTUJPO ϥϯμϜԽൺֱࢼݧʢ3$5ʣ ؍ݚڀ ࣮ࡍ࣮ࢪͰ͖ͳ͍ w ద֨ج४ w ΞτΧϜ
w հೖʢରরʣ w Γ͍ͨޮՌ w ϑΥϩʔͷํ๏ ͠3$5ΛσβΠϯ͢ΔͳΒ Ͳ͏Ή͔ʁ w ద֨ج४ w ΞτΧϜ w հೖʢରরʣ w Γ͍ͨޮՌ w ϑΥϩʔͷํ๏ 5BSHFUUSJBM ͑ΔσʔλͰߟ͑Δ &NVMBUJPO ฿͢Δ -
Ͳ͏͍͏σʔλΛ͏ͷ͔ʁ 19 ݚڀͷͨΊʹߏங͞Εͨσʔλϕʔε ݚڀͷͨΊʹߏங͞Εͳ͔ͬͨσʔλϕʔε w Ӹֶݚڀσʔλ w ױऀϨδετϦσʔλ w όΠΦόϯΫ
w ిࢠΧϧςσʔλ w ߦσʔλ w ࣏ࣗମ͕อ༗͢Δݸਓͷଐੑσʔλ w อݥٻσʔλ w σʔλͷਫ਼ߴ͍ w ଌఆޡ͕ࠩগͳ͍ w ݚڀͷͨΊʹߏங͞Εͳ͔ͬͨ σʔλϕʔεͱൺֱͯ͠ɺσʔ λྔ͕গͳ͍ w σʔλྔ͕গͳ͍ w ܽଌ͕ଟ͍ w ଌఆޡࠩ͋Δ͔͠Εͳ͍ w ͑Δσʔλͷछྨ੍ݶ͞ΕΔ͔͠Ε ͳ͍ -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷϑϨʔϜϫʔΫ 20 )FSOÂO." 3PCJOT+.6TJOH#JH%BUBUP&NVMBUFB5BSHFU5SJBM8IFOB3BOEPNJ[FE5SJBM*T/PU"WBJMBCMF"N+&QJEFNJPM"QS r ཁૉ 5BSHFUUSJBMͰͷܭը ؍ݚڀσʔλͰ฿͢ΔͳΒ ద֨ج४
ʢ&MJHJCJMJUZDSJUFSJBʣ ࣏ྍܭը ʢ5SFBUNFOUTUSBUFHJFTʣ ࣏ྍׂΓͯ ʢ"TTJHONFOUQSPDFEVSFTʣ ؍ظؒ ʢ'PMMPXVQQFSJPEʣ ΞτΧϜ ʢ0VUDPNFʣ ؔ৺ͷ͋ΔҼՌޮՌ ʢ$BVTBMDPOUSBTUTPGJOUFSFTUʣ ղੳܭը ʢ"OBMZTJTQMBOʣ w ฿͢Δ3$5͕͋ΔͳΒɺ ͦͷ3$5ͷใΛهࡌ͢Δ w ͳ͍ͳΒɺ ߟ͑ͯใΛهࡌ͢Δ w 5BSHFUUSJBMʹ४ͯ͡ هࡌ͢Δ w ར༻Ͱ͖ΔσʔλͰɺ ՄೳͳݶΓࣅΔΑ͏ʹ͢Δ -
5JNF[FSPɿ5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷΩʔϙΠϯτ 21 R 3$5 ؍ݚڀ 5JNF[FSP w ద֨ج४ͷஅ w ܈ͷܾఆ
w ؍։࢝ ؍։࢝ w ద֨ج४ͷஅ w ܈ͷܾఆ w ద֨ج४ͷஅ w ܈ͷܾఆ w ؍։࢝ *NNPSUBMUJNFCJBT %FQMFUJPOPGTVTDFQUJCMFTCJBT -
؍ݚڀͰ5JNF[FSPΛఆΊΔ 22 ؍։࢝ w ద֨ج४ͷஅ w ܈ͷܾఆ w ద֨ج४ͷஅ w
܈ͷܾఆ w ؍։࢝ 5JNF[FSP w ద֨ج४ͷஅ w ܈ͷܾఆ w ؍։࢝ w 5JNF[FSPΛἧ͑ΒΕͳ͍߹͋Δ w σβΠϯղੳํ๏Ͱରॲ *NNPSUBMUJNFCJBT %FQMFUJPOPGTVTDFQUJCMFTCJBT -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷྫʢʣ 23 'V &- &WBOT . $BSSFSP ++ 1VUUFS )
$MBTF $. $BTLFZ '+ 4[ZND[BL . 5PSJOP $ $IFTOBZF /$ +BHFS ,+ 8BOOFS $ %FLLFS '8 WBO%JFQFO . 5JNJOH PGEJBMZTJTJOJUJBUJPOUPSFEVDFNPSUBMJUZBOEDBSEJPWBTDVMBSFWFOUTJOBEWBODFEDISPOJDLJEOFZEJTFBTFOBUJPOXJEFDPIPSUTUVEZ#.+ Fͷ4VQQMFNFOUBSZ5BCMF" ཁૉ 5BSHFUUSJBMͰͷܭը ؍ݚڀσʔλͰ฿͢ΔͳΒ ద֨ج४ w ࡀҎ্ w F('3͕N-NJON 5BSHFUUSJBMͱಉ͡ ࣏ྍܭը ಁੳͷಋೖ࣌ظΛɺF('3Λ͔ΒͷൣғΛ NࠁΈͰͷ۠ʹ͚Δ 5BSHFUUSJBMͱಉ͡ ࣏ྍׂΓͯ ϥϯμϜׂ͚ ಛघͳղੳख๏ʢDMPOJOHʣʹΑΓϥϯμϜԽΛ฿ ؍ظؒ ϥϯμϜԽ࣌Ͱ؍Λ։࢝͠ɺࢮɺ৺݂Πϕϯ τɺ݄·Ͱɺ·ͨؒͷ͍ͣΕ͔ૣ ͍࣌Ͱऴྃ͢Δ ͯ͢ͷద֨ج४Λຬ͔ͨͯ͠Βɺ։࢝ ΞτΧϜ શࢮɺओཁ༗৺݂Πϕϯτ w UBSHFUUSJBMͱಉ༷ w ৺݂Πϕϯτ*$%ίʔυͰఆٛ ؔ৺ͷ͋ΔҼՌޮՌ *OUFOUJPOUPUSFBUޮՌɺ1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ ղੳܭը ͦΕͧΕͷޮՌʹదͨ͠ղੳํ๏ ޮՌʹదͨ͠౷ܭղੳख๏ *%&"-ࢼݧΛΑΓৄࡉʹͨ͠ͷΛ5BSHFUUSJBMʹ͢Δ -
Γ͍ͨޮՌԿʁ 25 3FTFBSDI2VFTUJPO ܕපױऀʹ͓͚ΔୈҰબༀͱͯ͠ɺ 4(-5્ༀͱϝτϗϧϛϯͲͪΒ͕ྑ͍͔ʁ ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ
4(-5્ༀ ࣏ྍ͕ܧଓతʹΘΕͨͱ͖ͷޮՌ ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ ࣏ྍΛ։࢝ͨ͠ͱ͖ͷޮՌ ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ -
*OUFOUJPOUPUSFBUޮՌͱ1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ 26 ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ ࣏ྍ͕ܧଓతʹΘΕͨͱ͖ͷޮՌ ϝτϗϧϛϯ
4(-5્ༀ ࣏ྍΛ։࢝ͨ͠ͱ͖ͷޮՌ ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ *OUFOUJPOUPUSFBUޮՌ *55ޮՌ ୯ʹ࣏ྍޮՌͱ͍͏ͱ͖ ͪ͜ΒΛΠϝʔδ͍ͯ͠Δ͜ͱ͕ଟ͍ -
ཧతͳϥϯμϜԽൺֱࢼݧͱ*55ͷݪଇ 27 ױऀ ױऀ ױऀ #BTFMJOF N w ׂΓ͚ΒΕ࣏ͨྍΛ९क͠ w
མ͕ͳ͘ w ೋॏݕ͕อͨΕΔ ׂΓ͚ͨ ࣏ྍ ΞτΧϜ ަབྷҼࢠ ױऀ N N R ৽ن ࣏ྍ ϓϥ ηϘ ࣏ྍΛׂΓ͚ΒΕͨױऀ͕ɺ 3$5 ະଌఆɾະͷҼࢠؚΉ ࣏ྍΛϥϯμϜʹׂΓ͚Δ͜ͱͰɺ࣏ྍͱަབྷҼࢠͱͷؔΛΔ *55ूஂʹ͓͚Δɺ ΞτΧϜʹର͢ΔׂΓ͚࣏ͨྍͷޮՌɺ όΠΞεΛ͏͚ͳ͍ ׂΓ͚ͨूஂΛͯ͢ղੳʹ͏ˠ*55 *OUFOUJPOUPUSFBU ͷݪଇ ަབྷͷ͜ͱߟ͑ͣɺൺֱత୯७ͳղੳͰਪఆͰ͖Δ *55ੳ -
*55ޮՌɿ*55ੳ͔Βਪఆ͞ΕΔޮՌ 28 w ׂΓ͚࣏ͨྍ͕ɺෆ९कམʹΑΓ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍͱҟͳ͍ͬͯͨ߹Ͱɺ ׂΓ͚࣏ͨྍͷޮՌΛਪఆ͍ͯ͠Δ w ࣮ࡍͷݱͰɺ९कঢ়گ͕ѱ͔ͬͨΓɺ࣏ྍΛଓ͚ΒΕͳ͍ױऀҰఆ͍Δ ͜ΕΒΛड͚ೖΕΔ*55ޮՌɺ࣮ྟচͰͷײ֮ʹ͋ͯ·ΔޮՌͱߟ͑ΒΕΔ͔͠Εͳ͍ ׂΓ͚ͨ ࣏ྍ
࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍ ΞτΧϜ ަབྷҼࢠ 㱠 ױऀ ױऀ ױऀ #BTFMJOF N ױऀ N N ৽ن ࣏ྍ ϓϥ ηϘ མ ৽ن࣏ྍ )FSOÂO." )FSOÂOEF[%ÍB[4#FZPOEUIFJOUFOUJPOUPUSFBUJODPNQBSBUJWFF ff FDUJWFOFTTSFTFBSDI$MJO5SJBMT'FC r -
؍ݚڀͰɺͲͷΑ͏ʹ*55ޮՌΛਪఆ͢Δ͔ʁ 29 5JNF[FSPͰ ܾΊ࣏ͨྍ ΞτΧϜ ަབྷҼࢠ ʢϕʔεϥΠϯʣ ϕʔεϥΠϯʢ5JNF[FSP·Ͱʹܾ·ΔʣͷަབྷҼࢠͰௐ 5JNF[FSPͰ ܾΊ࣏ͨྍ
ΞτΧϜ ަབྷҼࢠ ʢϕʔεϥΠϯʣ 5JNF[FSPͰ ܾΊ࣏ͨྍ ΞτΧϜ ަབྷҼࢠ ʢϕʔεϥΠϯʣ ௐ ϚονϯάɺॏΈ͚ -
*55ੳͷҙ 30 w ෆ९कམ͕͋Δ߹ɺ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍޮՌͱҟͳΔ w ϓϥηϘରরͷ3$5Ͱɺ*55ޮՌ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍޮՌΑΓอकతͳਪఆͱͳΔ ˠ෭࡞༻ͳͲͷ҆શੑΛΤϯυϙΠϯτʹͨ͠ࢼݧඇྼੑࢼݧͰɺ ɹաʹʮ҆શʯͰ͋ͬͨΓɺʮඇྼੑʯʹͳΓ͘͢ͳΔ w ࣮ༀରরͷ3$5ͰɺอकతʹͳΔͱݶΒͳ͍
ׂΓ͚ͨ ࣏ྍ ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍ ΞτΧϜ ަབྷҼࢠ 㱠 )FSOÂO." )FSOÂOEF[%ÍB[4#FZPOEUIFJOUFOUJPOUPUSFBUJODPNQBSBUJWFF ff FDUJWFOFTTSFTFBSDI$MJO5SJBMT'FC r ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍޮՌͱʁ -
֤ޮՌͷରूஂɺൺֱ͢Δ܈ɺޮՌͷҙຯ 31 *55ޮՌ 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ ղੳରूஂ ׂΓ͚ͨूஂ ׂΓ͚ͨूஂ ൺֱ͢Δ܈ ׂΓ͚ͨ܈ ࣮ࡍʹ͓͜ͳ࣏ͬͨྍʹैͬͨ܈
ޮՌͷҙຯ ׂΓ͚࣏ͨྍͷޮՌ ͯ͢ͷใΛ࣏ͬͨྍͷޮՌ खज़ ༀࡎ ैདྷ࣏ྍ खज़ ༀࡎ ैདྷ࣏ྍ खज़ ༀࡎ ैདྷ࣏ྍ खज़܈ ༀࡎ܈ खज़ ༀࡎ ैདྷ࣏ྍ खज़ ༀࡎ ैདྷ࣏ྍ खज़ ༀࡎ ैདྷ࣏ྍ खज़܈ ༀࡎ܈ ׂΓ͚ͨ ࣏ྍ ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍ ൺֱ͢Δ܈ ׂΓ͚ͨ ࣏ྍ ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍ ൺֱ͢Δ܈ -
࣏ྍ͕มΘΔͱɺͬͱେม 33 ׂΓ͚ͨ ࣏ྍ ࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍʢ࣌ʣ ΞτΧϜ ަབྷҼࢠ ʢϕʔεϥΠϯʣ ަབྷҼࢠ ʢ࣌ʣ
࣮ࡍͷ࣏ྍʢ࣌ʣ ަབྷҼࢠ ʢ࣌ʣ -
Γ͍ͨޮՌΛܾΊΔͱɺऩू͢Δσʔλ͖͢σʔλܾ·Δ 35 ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ ϝτϗϧϛϯ
4(-5્ༀ *55ޮՌ ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ ܧଓͯ͠༩͞Ε͍ͯΕɺ5JNF[FSP͚ͩͰྑ͍͕ ९कঢ়گΓ͍ͨ 5JNF[FSPޙͷใඞཁ -
ద֨ج४ϕʔεϥΠϯͰຬͨ͢ 36 ܕ%. ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ ϝτϗϧϛϯ 4(-5્ༀ 5JNF[FSP ద֨ج४ͷஅ 5JNF[FSPޙͷใ͋Δ͚Ͳɺ
ద֨ج४ͷஅʹΘͳ͍ બόΠΞεͷൃੜ -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷϑϨʔϜϫʔΫ࠶ܝ 37 'V &- &WBOT . $BSSFSP ++ 1VUUFS )
$MBTF $. $BTLFZ '+ 4[ZND[BL . 5PSJOP $ $IFTOBZF /$ +BHFS ,+ 8BOOFS $ %FLLFS '8 WBO%JFQFO . 5JNJOHPG EJBMZTJTJOJUJBUJPOUPSFEVDFNPSUBMJUZBOEDBSEJPWBTDVMBSFWFOUTJOBEWBODFEDISPOJDLJEOFZEJTFBTFOBUJPOXJEFDPIPSUTUVEZ#.+ Fͷ4VQQMFNFOUBSZ5BCMF" ཁૉ 5BSHFUUSJBMͰͷܭը ؍ݚڀσʔλͰ฿͢ΔͳΒ ద֨ج४ w ࡀҎ্ w F('3͕N-NJON 5BSHFUUSJBMͱಉ͡ ࣏ྍܭը ಁੳͷಋೖ࣌ظΛɺF('3Λ͔ΒͷൣғΛ NࠁΈͰͷ۠ʹ͚Δ 5BSHFUUSJBMͱಉ͡ ࣏ྍׂΓͯ ϥϯμϜׂ͚ ಛघͳղੳख๏ʢDMPOJOHʣʹΑΓϥϯμϜԽΛ฿ ؍ظؒ ϥϯμϜԽ࣌Ͱ؍Λ։࢝͠ɺࢮɺ৺݂Πϕϯ τɺ݄·Ͱɺ·ͨؒͷ͍ͣΕ͔ૣ ͍࣌Ͱऴྃ͢Δ ͯ͢ͷద֨ج४Λຬ͔ͨͯ͠Βɺ։࢝ ΞτΧϜ શࢮɺओཁ༗৺݂Πϕϯτ w UBSHFUUSJBMͱಉ༷ w ৺݂Πϕϯτ*$%ίʔυͰఆٛ ؔ৺ͷ͋ΔҼՌޮՌ *OUFOUJPOUPUSFBUޮՌɺ1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ ղੳܭը ͦΕͧΕͷޮՌʹదͨ͠ղੳํ๏ ޮՌʹదͨ͠౷ܭղੳख๏ ϑϨʔϜϫʔΫͷߏཁૉͯ͢ॏཁ -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷྫʢ$,%ʹର͢Δ3"4JͷޮՌʣ 38 ຫੑਛଁපױऀ ϨχϯɾΞϯδΦςϯγϯܥ્ༀʢ3"4JʣͷΈ ΧϧγϜ፰߅ༀʢ$$#ʣͷΈ ࠷ؒϑΥϩʔ ΞτΧϜ w ਛସྍ๏ w
ಁੳ·ͨਛҠ২ w શࢮҼࢮ w ओཁ༗৺݂Πϕϯτ $,% ຫੑਛଁපױऀʹ͓͚ΔɺΧϧγϜ፰߅ༀͱൺֱͨ͠ ϨχϯɾΞϯδΦςϯγϯܥ્ༀͷ༧ޙʢಁੳࢮʣͷӨڹධՁ 'V &- 5BSHFU5SJBM&NVMBUJPOUP*NQSPWF$BVTBM*OGFSFODFGSPN0CTFSWBUJPOBM%BUB8IBU 8IZ BOE)PX +PVSOBMPGUIF"NFSJDBO4PDJFUZPG/FQISPMPHZ+"4/ r -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷྫʢ$,%ʹର͢Δ3"4JͷޮՌʣ 39 ཁૉ 5BSHFUUSJBMͰͷܭը ؍ݚڀσʔλͰ฿͢ΔͳΒ ద֨ج४ w ࡀҎ্ w F('3N-NJON
w ਛҠ২ྺͳ͠ w աڈؒʹ3"4J·ͨ$$#Λ͍ͬͯͳ͍ˠ ɹطଘॲํऀόΠΞεΛ͙త 5BSHFUUSJBMͱಉ͡ ࣏ྍܭը w 3"4JͷΈΛ։࢝ w $$#ͷΈΛ։࢝ 5BSHFUUSJBMͱಉ͡ ࣏ྍׂΓͯ ϥϯμϜԽɺݕԼͳ͠ w ద֨ऀϕʔεϥΠϯ࣌ʹɺ࣏ྍΛܾఆ w ϥϯμϜԽΛ฿͢ΔͨΊʹɺϕʔεϥΠϯͷަབྷ ҼࢠΛௐ ؍ظؒ ϥϯμϜԽ͔Β؍։࢝ɺΤϯυϙΠϯτͷൃੜɺ ଧͪΓɺؒͰऴྃ ॲํ͕Ͱ͔ͯΒ։࢝ɺΤϯυϙΠϯτͷൃੜɺ ଧͪΓɺؒͰऴྃ ΞτΧϜ w ਛସྍ๏ w શࢮҼࢮ w ओཁ༗৺݂Πϕϯτ w 5BSHFUUSJBMͱಉ͡ w Ұ෦*$%ίʔυ͔Βಛఆ ؔ৺ͷ͋ΔҼՌޮՌ w *55ޮՌ w 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ 'V &- 5BSHFU5SJBM&NVMBUJPOUP*NQSPWF$BVTBM*OGFSFODFGSPN0CTFSWBUJPOBM%BUB8IBU 8IZ BOE)PX +PVSOBMPGUIF"NFSJDBO4PDJFUZPG/FQISPMPHZ+"4/ rͷ5BCMFΛվม -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷྫʢ$07*%ʹର͢ΔεςϩΠυ࣏ྍͷޮՌʣ 40 w ೖӃͨ͠$07*%ױऀʹରͯ͠ɺεςϩΠυ࣏ྍ͕ࢮʹӨڹ͢Δ͔ධՁ͢Δࢼݧ w 5BSHFUUSJBMɿ3&$07&3:ࢼݧ w 3&$07&3:$PMMBCPSBUJWF(SPVQ )PSCZ1 -JN84
&NCFSTPO+3 .BGIBN. #FMM+- FUBM%FYBNFUIBTPOFJO)PTQJUBMJ[FE1BUJFOUTXJUI$PWJE/&OHM+.FE'FC r w )P ff NBO,- 4DIFODL&+ 4BUMJO.+ 8IBMFO8 1BO% 8JMMJBNT/ FUBM$PNQBSJTPOPGB5BSHFU5SJBM&NVMBUJPO'SBNFXPSLWT$PY3FHSFTTJPOUP&TUJNBUFUIF"TTPDJBUJPOPG $PSUJDPTUFSPJET8JUI$07*%.PSUBMJUZ+"."/FUX0QFO0DU FͷF5BCMFΛվม ཁૉ 5BSHFUUSJBMͰͷܭը ؍ݚڀσʔλͰ฿͢ΔͳΒ ద֨ج४ w ਓͷ$07*%ͷೖӃױऀ w ࣏ݧʹࢀՃͨ͠߹ʹେ͖ͳةݥʹ͞Β͞ΕΔՄೳੑ ͷ͋Δපྺͷͳ͍ױऀ w ਓͷ$07*%ͷೖӃױऀ w ຫੑతʹεςϩΠυΛ͍ͬͯͳ͍ ࣏ྍܭը w ༰ྔεςϩΠυ༩ ʢσΩαϝλκϯNHɺճؒʣʴඪ४࣏ྍ w ඪ४࣏ྍ w εςϩΠυʼNHLH ʢॏͷࢎૉൃੜ͔࣌Βؒʣʴඪ४࣏ྍ w ඪ४࣏ྍ ࣏ྍׂΓͯ ొ࣌ʢ͓ͦΒ͘ೖӃ࣌ʣʹɺϥϯμϜׂ͚ ೖӃ࣌ʹϥϯμϜׂΓ͚͞ΕͨΑ͏ʹമ࿐ΛܾΊΔ ؍ظؒ ϥϯμϜԽ࣌Ͱ؍Λ։࢝͠ɺ·Ͱɺࢮɺ ·ͨෆೳͷ͍ͣΕ͔ૣ͍࣌Ͱऴྃ͢Δ മ࿐ܾఆ͔࣌Β؍Λ։࢝͠ɺ·Ͱɺࢮɺ ·ͨෆೳͷ͍ͣΕ͔ૣ͍࣌Ͱऴྃ͢Δ ΞτΧϜ ࢮ ࢮ ؔ৺ͷ͋ΔҼՌޮՌ *55ޮՌ 1FSQSPUPDPMޮՌ -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷ݁Ռʢͷ3$5Λݕ౼ʣ 43 8BOH 47 4DIOFFXFJTT 4 3$5%61-*$"5&*OJUJBUJWF 'SBOLMJO +. %FTBJ
3+ 'FMENBO 8 (BSSZ &. (MZOO 3+ -JO ,+ 1BJL + 1BUPSOP & 4VJTTB 4 %`"OESFB & +BXBJE % -FF ) 1BXBS " 4SFFEIBSB 4, 5FTGBZF ) #FTTFUUF -( ʜ2VJOUP , &NVMBUJPOPG3BOEPNJ[FE$MJOJDBM5SJBMT8JUI/POSBOEPNJ[FE%BUBCBTF"OBMZTFT3FTVMUTPG $MJOJDBM5SJBMT+"."5IF+PVSOBMPGUIF"NFSJDBO.FEJDBM"TTPDJBUJPO r ͋Δఔ͍ۙΛࣔ͢ -
5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷใࠂ͕͋ΔྖҬ 45 4DPMB ( $IJT4UFS " #FBO % 1BSFFL /
&NTMFZ 3 -BOEBV 4 *NQMFNFOUBUJPOPGUIFUSJBMFNVMBUJPOBQQSPBDIJONFEJDBMSFTFBSDIBTDPQJOHSFWJFX#.$.FEJDBM 3FTFBSDI.FUIPEPMPHZ ͷ'JHVSFΛվม ॥ث খࣇ ൻث ൽෘ ࢈Պɾ්ਓՊ ϦϚν w 5BSHFUUSJBMFNVMBUJPOͷ είʔϐϯάϨϏϡʔ w ·Ͱͷௐࠪ ਫ਼ਆҩֶ ֎Պ ਆܦֶ ਛଁֶ ͕Μ ײછ ɹɹɹ ʹಛԽͨ͠5BSHFUUSJBM FNVMBUJPOͷղઆจ͋Γ ʢ؍ൣғͰ͢ʣ