Share
Embed
Application of MaterialX and Standard Surface to Video Game Graphics
This is the English translation of CEDEC2022 "Application of MaterialX and Standard Surface to Video Game Graphics".
This document explains how to apply the Standard Surface described by MaterialX to Video Game Graphics.
Bandai Namco Studios Inc. PRO
September 12, 2022
Transcript
222 slides
-
Application of MaterialX and Standard Surface to Video Game Graphics
Bandai Namco Studios Inc. Wataru Tada Masayuki Suzuki -
Self introduction Past Projects ・Ace Combat 6 ・Ace Combat: Assault
Horizon ・Tales Of Card Evolve ・THE IDOLM@STER MILLION LIVE! ・Pokkén Tournament ・New Pokémon Snap Past talks ・CEDEC2011 Continuous integration of ACE COMBAT ASSAULT HORIZON ・CEDEC2011 In-game camera production example in “ACE COMBAT ASSAULT HORIZON” in-game camera production example ・CEDEC2015 Game editor design and implementation in Pokkén Tournament ・CEDEC2019 Basic design of game editor and stable and fast asset management in console video game development ・CEDEC2019 Implementation of Light Baker using DirectX Raytracing ・CEDEC2021 New Pokémon Snap Lighting Overview Wataru Tada I have worked as a character modeler, motion, background, lighting artist, shader artist, and now as a TA, I research graphics and support work for various projects. Past talks CEDEC2008 Linear space and physically correct lighting CEDEC2019 "Super Smash Bros. Ultimate" - To draw the borrowed IP as beautifully as possible CEDEC2020 HDRI production technique with high reliability CEDEC2021 Video Game Graphics for the Raytracing Generation, Get Grounded and Prepared - Quickly and Easily Validate Next-Generation Quality Real-Time Physically-Based Lighting with NVIDIA Falcor CEDEC2021 New Pokémon Snap Lighting Overview Masayuki Suzuki 2 -
Contents • About MaterialX • Implementation detail • Comparison with
DCC tools • Performance measurement • Other features • Conclusion 3 This slide has a gray background to prevent optical illusion. -
About MaterialX • MaterialX is a standard format and related
library for describing materials, developed by ILM, and published on GitHub(Apache 2.0 license). (https://github.com/AcademySoftwareFoundation/MaterialX) • MaterialX describes materials in XML (.mtlx file), and MaterialX can output shaders such as GLSL, MDL, and OSL. • Various DCC tools, such as Maya and Houdini support MaterialX, and MaterialX provides Python bindings. • MaterialX is mainly used for offline rendering, but this talk describes real-time rendering. • This talk uses MaterialX version 1.38.0 4 -
Material file (.mtlx) • Materials are described in XML (.mtlx
files) and represent node graphs. Nodes <nodegraph name=“BlendNode" nodedef="BlendNode"> <multiply name=“node1" type="color3"> <input name=“in1" type="color3" /> <input name="in2" type="float" /> </multiply> <add name="node2" type="color3"> <input name="in1" type="color3" nodename="node1" /> <input name="in3" type="color3" /> </add> <output name="out" type="color3" nodename="node2" /> </nodegraph> XML multiply node1 add node2 in1 in2 in3 out 5 -
About Standard Surface • Standard Surface is a standardized MaterialX
file (standard_surface.mtlx) that is used to represent physical materials and published on GitHub(Apache 2.0 license). https://github.com/Autodesk/standard-surface • Standard Surface has a horizontal and vertical layered structure and can represent most physical materials such as Diffuse, Subsurface scattering, Sheen, etc. 6 -
Parameters of Standard Surface • Standard Surface defines material parameters
for each category, such as Coating and Sheen. • In addition, Standard Surface standardizes parameters so that various DCC tools can handle the same material parameters. Maya+Arnold Houdini 7 -
Implementation in in-house LookDev environment • The in-house LookDev environment
has implemented MaterialX to use Standard Surface. • As a result, artists can handle the same material parameters as DCC tools, making it easier to control rendering. In-house LookDev environment Maya+Arnold Houdini 8 -
How to implement the in-house LookDev environment • MaterialX is
from the film industry and cannot be used for video game graphics as is. • MaterialX specifications are insufficient for symbolic representation of video game graphics, such as dither. • MaterialX's GLSL output is mainly fragment shaders, and processing cannot be described in vertex shaders. • So, We decided to disassemble the various MaterialX nodes and combine them with Video game nodes to implement them in the in- house shader editor. Video game graphics node MaterialX node In-house shader editor MaterialX node MaterialX 10 -
Implementation details 1. Determine the reference 2. HLSL porting of
MaterialX nodes 3. Implementation in in-house shader editor 4. Creating Standard Surface materials 11 -
Rendering flow of in-house LookDev environment • The in-house LookDev
environment uses Forward Rendering, because Standard Surface had many parameters and the GBuffer could be large. Traditional PBR Standard Surface • Base Color • Roughness • Metallic • Specular • Emissive • Opacity • Base • Base Color • Diffuse Roughness • Metalness • Specular • Specular Color • Specular Roughness • Specular IOR • Specular Anisotropy • Specular Rotation • Transmission • Transmission Color • Coat • Coat Color • Coat Roughness • Coat Anisotropy • Coat Rotation • Coat IOR • Coat Affect Color • Coat Affect Roughness • Thin Film Thickness • Thin Film IOR • Emission • Emission Color • Opacity • Thin Walled • Subsurface • Subsurface Color • Subsurface Radius • Subsurface Scale • Subsurface Anisotropy • Sheen • Sheen Color • Sheen Roughness 12 -
Rendering flow of in-house LookDev environment • The rendering flow
is to draw the luminance value to the render target and apply the exposure. [CEDEC2021][SIGGRAPH ASIA 2021] New Pokémon Snap Lighting Overview Draw to 16bit float render target with luminance 1000cd/㎡ as 1 in GPU Apply exposure to render target 13 -
Determine the reference • The reference is the preview tool
MaterialX View included in MaterialX. 14 -
Application of exposure • MaterialX View does not support exposure,
so we modified the program to apply exposure. Added Exposure to Advanced Settings MaterialX View uniforms Exposure Apply exposure to output MaterialX View fragment shader output 15 -
In-house HDRI Support • We applied the HDRI and sun
directional light sources used in the in- house LookDev environment to the MaterialX View (The in-house LookDev environment uses directional light and HDRI IBL for lighting) <?xml version="1.0"?> <materialx version="1.37"> <directional_light name="dir_light" type="lightshader"> <input name="direction" type="vector3" value="0.464839160, -0.538476706, 0.702828169" /> <input name="color" type="color3" value="34.84, 29.67, 24.9" /> <input name="intensity" type="float" value="3.14159256" /> </directional_light> <nodedef name="ND_exposure" node="exposure"> <input name="ev" type="float" value="14.03" /> <output name="out" type="float" /> </nodedef> </materialx> MaterialX file describing the directional light source of the sun HDRI Applies to MaterialX View Exposure Split Direct Light 16 -
In-house HDRI Support • MaterialX View can now use the
same exposures and HDRIs as the in-house LookDev environment so that rendering results can be compared. HDRI for debugging MaterialX View In-house LookDev environment MaterialX View In-house LookDev environment MaterialX View In-house LookDev environment 17 -
HLSL porting of MaterialX nodes • We ported the GLSL
in the libraries/lights/genglsl, pbrlib, stdlib folders of the MaterialX repository to HLSL. • Add include guard • Type change (vec3 to float3, etc.) • Change the multiplication order of mul • Change $envMatrix to ConstantBuffer • In-house shader editor outputs shaders using ported HLSL functions. mx_oren_nayar_diffuse_bsdf.hlsl mx_dielectric_bsdf.hlsl ... mx_oren_nayar_diffuse_bsdf.glsl mx_dielectric_bsdf.glsl ... 18 -
Implementation in in-house shader editor • The in-house shader editor
has a node for each function ported to HLSL. • For consistency of terminology, the node names are the same as the MaterialX node names. Compute node example of in-house shader editor 19 -
BSDF node implementation • BSDF functions are separate nodes for
Reflection, Indirect, and Transmission. BSDF node example of in-house shader editor Reflection node (used for Direct Lighting) Indirect node (used for Indirect Lighting) Transmission node (used for Specular transmission) 20 -
Creating Standard Surface materials • We created the Standard Surface
material using the Standard Surface documentation(https://autodesk.github.io/standard- surface/) and the Standard Surface GLSL code as a reference. • Since MaterialX View's shader file output features do not output specular transmission, we used the shader code output by Nsight. Nsight shader code display 21 -
Standard Surface node structure • The Standard Surface material consists
of Direct Lighting, Indirect Lighting, and Transmission. • When adding a light source, it is necessary to add a node. Direct Lighting Indirect Lighting Standard Surface Pixel shader output (RGB) Pixel shader input Add Transmission Pixel shader output (alpha) 23 -
Direct Lighting node structure • Indirect Lighting has a similar
node structure • Each element such as Diffuse and Subsurface has a weight. Diffuse Subsurface Translucent Sheen Transmission Dielectric Metal Coat Emission 出力 Lerp Multiply Add 24 Add Coat and Emission to get the same results as in MaterialX View. Input Emission output to Coat, same as Arnold. -
Contents • About MaterialX • Implementation detail • Comparison with
DCC tools • Performance measurement • Other features • Conclusion 25 -
Rendering comparison • We compared Arnold with MaterialX View and
the in-house Lookdev environment to confirm the following. • How correct is the Standard Surface material implementation in the in- house Lookdev environment? • How similar is real-time rendering to offline rendering? In-house Lookdev environment MaterialX View Maya + Arnold 26 -
Standard surface material comparison • We compared renderings by writing
parameters such as base_color in Excel and outputting a MaterialX file from Excel; in the Arnold and in-house Lookdev environments, the scripts directly referenced the Excel file to set material parameters. Excel MaterialX View In-house Lookdev environment MaterialX file (.mtlx) Arnold 27 -
Camera Parameter setting • The Excel file for material comparison
can also describe camera parameters, screenshots can be taken with the same camera in Arnold, MaterialX View, and in-house Lookdev environment. • MaterialX View can take screenshots with startup arguments. • The background HDRI in the in-house Lookdev environment is in LatLong format to match MaterialX View. Arnold MaterialX View In-house Lookdev environment 28 -
Arnold rendering • We applied the parameters of the MaterialX
file to aiStandardSurface to render Arnold. • aiMaterialXShader can also be used to render the MaterialX file. aiStandardSurface aiMaterialXShader 29 -
Comparison of MaterialX View and aiStandardSurface We compared rendering in
MaterialX View and Arnold. Arnold for Maya Materials • Standard Surface • aiStandard Surface ← used for comparison • aiMaterialXShader 30 -
Comparison of MaterialX View and aiStandardSurface Comparison result of MaterialX
View and Arnold • There are many small differences. • Some differences can be resolved with parameter mapping. • The big difference is imperfect transmission. • Subsurface may also have problems. • There are many layers that are not compatible with indirect light. 31 -
Comparison of MaterialX View and aiStandardSurfacet • Scene settings •
1m radius sphere • Taken with a 400mm lens and 35mm film at a distance of 38m from the origin (depending on the situation) • Lighting composed of IBL and directional light sources • Arnold settings • RayDepth is basically 1 (Transmission and Transparency are 2 at DoubleSide) 32 -
Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal) Only use BaseColor and Specular •
base (1.0) • base_color(0.5, 0.5, 0.5) • diffuse_roughness(0) • specular(1.0) • specular_color(1, 1, 1) • specular_IOR(1.5) • Change specular_roughness 33 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Arnold Daytime Night Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal) Daytime Night MaterialX View 34 -
Arnold Daytime Night Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal) Overlay images for
comparison specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 35 -
MaterialX View Daytime Night Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal) Overlay images
for comparison specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 36 -
Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal) Overlay images for comparison No practical
problem. Next, compare from Specular MaterialX View Daytime Night specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 37 -
Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal)- Specular Only use Specular • specular(1.0)
• specular_color(1, 1, 1) • specular_IOR(1.5 Partially 3.0) • Change specular_roughness 38 -
Arnold From front From above Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal)- Specular
- Direct Light Overlay images for comparison 39 specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 specular_roughness 1 IOR 3 IOR 1 -
MaterialX View Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal)- Specular - Direct Light
Overlay images for comparison From front From above 40 specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 IOR 1 specular_roughness 1 IOR 3 -
Comparison - Dielectric (nonmetal)- Specular - Direct Light Overlay images
for comparison MaterialX View is a little brighter at higher roughness, but the difference is not noticeable at IOR 1.5. Next, check with indirect light 41 MaterialX View From front From above specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 IOR 1 specular_roughness 1 IOR 3 -
White indirect light Overlay images for comparison Arnold Comparison -
Dielectric (nonmetal)- Specular - Indirect Light 42 specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 IOR 1 specular_roughness 1 IOR 3 -
Overlay images for comparison MaterialX View White indirect light Comparison
- Dielectric (nonmetal)- Specular - Indirect Light 43 specular_roughness 1 IOR 3 specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 IOR 1 -
Overlay images for comparison MaterialX View White indirect light Comparison
- Dielectric (nonmetal)- Specular - Indirect Light MaterialX View is a little brighter at higher roughness, but the difference is not noticeable at IOR 1.5. Next, check diffuse_roughness 44 specular_roughness 1 IOR 3 specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 IOR 1 -
Only use Base • base(1.0) • base_color(0.5, 05, 05) •
Change diffuse_roughness Comparison - Diffuse 45 -
The difference between DiffuseRoughness and SpecularRoughness is in the bonus
slides. Inter-reflection between microfacet irregularities 46 -
Arnold Comparison - Diffuse diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66
diffuse_roughness 1 Daytime Night Daytime Night MaterialX View 47 -
diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 Arnold Daytime
Night Comparison - Diffuse Overlay images for comparison 48 -
MaterialX View Comparison - Diffuse Daytime Night Overlay images for
comparison diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 49 -
MaterialX View The difference is significant, especially when roughness is
high. Next, check with only a directional light source. Comparison - Diffuse Daytime Night Overlay images for comparison diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 50 -
Arnold From front From above Comparison - Diffuse - Direct
Light Overlay images for comparison diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 51 -
MaterialX View From front From above Overlay images for comparison
Comparison - Diffuse - Direct Light diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 52 -
MaterialX View From front From above From Arnold's value, we
found that dividing by Π√2 gives a match. Next, compare the diffuse_roughness of MaterialX View to 1/4.44 Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Diffuse - Direct Light diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 53 -
Arnold From front From above Overlay images for comparison Comparison
- Diffuse - Direct Light diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 54 -
From front From above Comparison - Diffuse - Direct Light
Overlay images for comparison MaterialX View diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.075 diffuse_roughness 0.15 diffuse_roughness 0.225 55 -
Match. We found that there were changes since Arnold 6.0.1.0
that made a difference. Next, check with indirect light. From front From above Comparison - Diffuse - Direct Light Overlay images for comparison MaterialX View diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.075 diffuse_roughness 0.15 diffuse_roughness 0.225 56 -
Arnold White indirect light Comparison - Diffuse - Indirect Light
Overlay images for comparison diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 57 -
MaterialX View White indirect light Overlay images for comparison Comparison
- Diffuse - Indirect Light diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 58 -
MaterialX View In Arnold, diffuse_roughness shows that the coarser it
gets, the darker it gets, but MaterialX View shows no difference in diffuse_roughness. Next, check the indirect light using HDRI White indirect light Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Diffuse - Indirect Light diffuse_roughness 0 diffuse_roughness 0.33 diffuse_roughness 0.66 diffuse_roughness 1 59 -
• In MaterialX View, the IrradianceMap corresponding to HDRI is
used, but if it is unavailable, the HDRI is converted to SH 2nd order in MaterialX View and used as IrradianceMap. • In this case, we did not prepare an IrradianceMap, which is different from the SH 2nd order. Therefore, check the difference. Comparison - Diffuse - IBL Indirect Light 60 • base(1.0) • base_color(1, 1, 1) • diffuse_roughness(0) -
HDRI Result MaterialX View • This can be a problem
because SH second order cannot reproduce rapid changes. • This method is not good at extreme IBLs like the second from the right. Comparison - Diffuse - IBL Indirect Light 63 -
Regarding Diffuse roughness, Arnold and MaterialX View do not consider
the effect of inter-reflection between microfacets. On the other hand, the Roughness of metal reflection corresponds to the effect of inter-reflection. Inter-reflection between microfacet irregularities 64 -
Inter-reflection between microfacet irregularities 65 Bonus slides describes the effects
of inter-reflection between microfacets. -
Comparison - Metal Only use BaseColor • base(1) • base_color
(1, 1, 1) • metalness (1) • Change specular_roughness 66 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Arnold Daytime Night Daytime Night MaterialX View Comparison - Metal 67 -
Comparison - Metal Arnold specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3
specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Night Overlay images for comparison 68 -
MaterialX View Comparison - Metal specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness
0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Night Overlay images for comparison 69 -
MaterialX View Slightly different. Next, check from direct light. Comparison
- Metal specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Night Overlay images for comparison 70 -
Comparison - Metal - Direct Light specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1
specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 From front From above Overlay images for comparison Arnold 71 -
Comparison - Metal - Direct Light MaterialX View specular_roughness 0
specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 From front From above Overlay images for comparison 72 -
Comparison - Metal - Direct Light MaterialX View specular_roughness 0
specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 From front From above Overlay images for comparison Slightly different. Next, check with indirect light. 73 -
Comparison - Metal - Indirect Light specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1
specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Gray indirect light Overlay images for comparison Arnold 74 -
MaterialX View specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5
specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Gray indirect light Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - Indirect Light 75 -
MaterialX View Not much difference. specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness
0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Gray indirect light Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - Indirect Light 76 -
Concentric pattern problem in MaterialX View It can be improved
by changing the sampler for reflection from Anisotropy to Linear. Comparison - Metal - Indirect Light 77 -
Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet Check the
effect by adding color to the base color 78 • base(1) • base_color (0.9, 0.62, 0.19) • metalness (1) • specular(0) • Change specular_roughness -
Arnold specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0.66 specular_roughness 1 Daytime
Night Daytime Night MaterialX View The rougher the specular_roughness, the darker the color. Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet 79 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0.66 specular_roughness 1 Arnold Daytime
Night Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet 80 -
MaterialX View specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0.66 specular_roughness 1
Daytime Night Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet 81 -
MaterialX View Since the result is difficult to understand, check
with white indirect light specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0.66 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Night Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet 82 -
Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet specular_roughness 0
specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0.66 specular_roughness 1 Overlay images for comparison White indirect light Arnold 83 -
MaterialX View Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0.66 specular_roughness 1 White indirect light Overlay images for comparison 84 -
MaterialX View The effect of darkening colors is weaker in
MaterialX View. Comparison - Metal - Color difference by microfacet specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0.66 specular_roughness 1 White indirect light Overlay images for comparison 85 The red component is bright even if coarse, so the attenuation is small. The blue component is highly attenuated, so the color is darker. -
Comparison - Metal - anisotropy Enable Base. Use specular parameters
• base(1) • base_color (1, 1, 1) • metalness (1) • specular(0) • specular_rotaion(0.25 = 1/4 turn) • Change specular_anisotropy • Change specular_roughness 86 -
specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 Arnold Daytime Night specular_anisotropy
0.33 specular_anisotropy 0.66 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 specular_anisotropy 1 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - anisotropy 87 -
specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Night specular_anisotropy 0.33
specular_anisotropy 0.66 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 specular_anisotropy 1 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 MaterialX View Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - anisotropy 88 -
specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Night specular_anisotropy 0.33
specular_anisotropy 0.66 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 specular_anisotropy 1 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.4 specular_roughness 1 Patterns of sampled results are similar Higher roughness makes MaterialX View darker. MaterialX View Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Metal - anisotropy 89 -
Opacity is an object disappearing (not existing in reality?). Comparison
- Transmission - Opacity and Transmission Transparent Opaque → Transparent 91 -
In Transimission, diffuse reflections disappear. Transparent Opaque → Transparent Comparison
- Transmission - Opacity and Transmission 92 -
not filled (thin_walled enabled) filled (thin_walled disabled) We are enabling
and disabling thin_walled and the difference between DoubleSide and SingleSide. Comparison - Transmission - Thin walled and DoubleSide specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.33 DoubleSide SingleSide DoubleSide SingleSide 93 -
Comparison - Transmission MaterialX View does not currently support the
representation of filled materials. Rendering with thin_walled • specular(1) • specular_color(1, 1, 1) • specular_IOR(1.5) • Change specular_roughness • transmission(1) • transmission_color(1, 1, 1) • thin_walled(true) 94 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Arnold 昼 の シ ー ン The background is also blurred because it is refracted by the roughness of the surface (thin frosted glass). Furthermore, it is emphasized because it is taken from a distance with a telephoto lens. 400mm lens Distance 38m 21mm lens Distance 3m Both specular_roughness is 0.1 in the following figure, but the impression changes with the lens. 95 MaterialX View does not support refraction of transmitted light due to specular_roughness and its variation. Therefore, Arnold also renders with less variation for comparison. Comparison - Transmission - Transmission by specular_roughness -
Comparison - Transmission - extra roughness Variation of refracted light
depends on surface roughness (specular_roughness) transmission_extra_roughness can give additional Roughness of the materials It is possible to make the surface smooth and the materials coarse without using coat. It is also possible to make the surface rough but the materials smooth again. specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.5 transmission_extra_roughness 0.5 transmission extra_roughness -0.5 specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.5 96 (Is this difficult in reality?) -
Comparison - Transmission Since refraction is not available in MaterialX
View, Arnold uses Extra roughness to compare under the same conditions. • specular(1) • specular_color(1, 1, 1) • Change specular_roughness • specular_IOR(1.5) • transmission(1) • transmission_color(1, 1, 1) • transmission_extra_roughness(roughnessCounter) • thin_walled(true) Extra roughness is grayed out in the UI when thin walled is enabled but can be used. 97 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Arnold Daytime Comparison - Transmission The value of specular_roughness was countered with transmission_extra_roughness to keep the transmitted light from being scattered. Overlay images for comparison 98 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission MaterialX View Overlay images for comparison 99 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission MaterialX View MaterialX View does not maintain high brightness. The higher the transparency, the more problematic it is. Blending is a problem. At least blending with multiplied alpha would improve it. Overlay images for comparison 100 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission In-house LookDev environment uses multiplied alpha and render target in float16 format. Compare with Arnold In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison 101 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Arnold Daytime Comparison - Transmission Overlay images for comparison 102 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison 103 -
specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7
specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission Only specular_roughness 0 is very different. In Arnold, only when thin walled is enabled during transmission and specular_roughness is 0, there is a phenomenon where reflections become stronger. We reported this to Autodesk and received a response that there was a problem. In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison 104 -
Comparison - Transmission – Transmission color About Transmission Color Compare
the case of coloring Transmission in the previous state 105 -
Arnold specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness
0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Transmission - Transmission color 106 -
MaterialX View specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5
specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Transmission - Transmission color 107 -
MaterialX View Color is not supported in MaterialX View and
is converted to gray internally. Alpha blend does not support color. In the in-house LookDev environment, blend using the pixel shader Src1Color. specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Transmission - Transmission color 108 -
Colored the same way as Arnold's StandardSuraface. Compare with Arnold
again In-house Lookdev environment specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission - Transmission color Overlay images for comparison 109 -
Arnold specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness
0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Transmission - Transmission color 110 -
In-house Lookdev environment specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness
0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission - Transmission color Overlay images for comparison 111 -
Except for the problem when specular_roughness is 0 Same result
as Arnold's aiStandardSuraface In-house Lookdev environment specular_roughness 0 specular_roughness 0.1 specular_roughness 0.3 specular_roughness 0.5 specular_roughness 0.7 specular_roughness 1 Daytime Comparison - Transmission - Transmission color Overlay images for comparison 112 -
Comparison - Thin Film 113 https://docs.arnoldrenderer.com/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thin-film_interference Interference occurs when
the thickness becomes as thin as the wavelength of light. No thin film With thin film -
Comparison - Thin Film Enable only Specular and change the
thickness of the film (thickness unit is nm) • specular(1) • specular_color(1, 1, 1) • specular_roughness(0) • specular_IOR(1) • transmission(0 and 1) • transmission_color(1,1,1) • thin_film_IOR(1.4) • Change thin_film_thickness 114 -
thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm Arnold Comparison - Thin
Film transmission 0 thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm transmission 1 Overlay images for comparison Daytime White IBL (Black background color) 115 -
thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm Comparison - Thin Film
transmission 0 thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm transmission 1 MaterialX View Overlay images for comparison Daytime White IBL (Black background color) 116 In transmission1, it is thin due to the blending problem mentioned earlier. Check with in-house LookDev that solves it. -
thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm Comparison - Thin Film
transmission 0 thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm transmission 1 In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison Daytime White IBL (Black background color) Compare with Arnold again in this state 117 -
thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm Arnold Comparison - Thin
Film transmission 0 thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm transmission 1 Overlay images for comparison Daytime White IBL (Black background color) 118 -
thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm Comparison - Thin Film
transmission 0 thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm transmission 1 In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison Daytime White IBL (Black background color) 119 -
thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm Comparison - Thin Film
transmission 0 thin_film_thickness 350nm thin_film_thickness 500nm thin_film_thickness 650nm transmission 1 In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison Daytime White IBL (Black background color) Color appearance is similar, but the in-house LookDev environment has lower saturation. 120 -
Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color Comparison using color for
Opacity We left opacity_color only red and increased the transparency. 121 -
opacity 1,1,1 opacity 1, 0.95, 0.95 opacity 1, 0.5, 0
opacity 1, 0, 0 Daytime Arnold Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 122 -
opacity 1,1,1 opacity 1, 0.95, 0.95 opacity 1, 0.5, 0
opacity 1, 0, 0 Daytime MaterialX View Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 123 -
opacity 1,1,1 opacity 1, 0.95, 0.95 opacity 1, 0.5, 0
opacity 1, 0, 0 Daytime MaterialX View In MaterialX View, opacity colors are converted to grayscale and processed. Blending using Src1Color as before Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 124 -
opacity 1,1,1 opacity 1, 0.95, 0.95 opacity 1, 0.5, 0
opacity 1, 0, 0 Daytime In-house Lookdev environment The in-house LookDev environment uses Src1Color and supports OpacityColor, as described earlier. Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 125 -
opacity 1,1,1 opacity 1, 0.95, 0.95 opacity 1, 0.5, 0
opacity 1, 0, 0 Daytime Arnold Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 126 -
opacity 1,1,1 opacity 1, 0.95, 0.95 opacity 1, 0.5, 0
opacity 1, 0, 0 Daytime In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 127 -
opacity 1,1,1 opacity 1, 0.95, 0.95 opacity 1, 0.5, 0
opacity 1, 0, 0 Daytime In-house Lookdev environment Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 128 Same result as Arnold. -
What does it mean that Opacity is colored? Is there
such a thing in the real world? Transmission: Transmits a specific color, and the rest are absorbed. Opacity: Transmits a specific color and reflects the rest. Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color 129 R G B RGB Opacity Transmission -
Reflection is real. R G B RGB 130 For example,
a dichroic mirror transmits specific wavelengths and reflects the rest. Comparison - Opacity – Opacity color RGB Blue (Transmission) Red (Reflection) -
Comparison - Sheen 131 With Sheen No Sheen https://docs.arnoldrenderer.com/ sheen
is the density of raised hairs sheen_roughness is the variation in the orientation of the raised hairs -
Comparison - Sheen Only use Sheen • sheen(1) • sheen_color(White)
• Change sheen_roughness 132 -
Arnold Daytime Comparison - Sheen sheen_roughness 0 sheen_roughness 0.05 sheen_roughness
0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 Overlay images for comparison 133 -
MaterialX View Comparison - Sheen Daytime sheen_roughness 0 sheen_roughness 0.05
sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 Overlay images for comparison 134 -
MaterialX View Comparison - Sheen Daytime sheen_roughness 0 sheen_roughness 0.05
sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 Overlay images for comparison Slightly different. MaterialX View has a strong boundary between lighted and unlighted areas. Check only with directional light sources 135 -
Comparison - Sheen – Direct Light sheen_roughness 0 sheen_roughness 0.05
sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 From front From above Arnold Overlay images for comparison 136 -
Comparison - Sheen – Direct Light MaterialX View sheen_roughness 0
sheen_roughness 0.05 sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 From front From above Overlay images for comparison 137 -
Comparison - Sheen – Direct Light MaterialX View sheen_roughness 0
sheen_roughness 0.05 sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 From front From above Overlay images for comparison 138 Also check with indirect light. -
sheen_roughness 0 sheen_roughness 0.05 sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66
sheen_roughness 1 Arnold White indirect light Comparison - Sheen – Indirect Light Overlay images for comparison 139 -
Comparison - Sheen – Indirect Light MaterialX View sheen_roughness 0
sheen_roughness 0.05 sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 White indirect light Overlay images for comparison 140 -
Comparison - Sheen – Indirect Light MaterialX View sheen_roughness 0
sheen_roughness 0.05 sheen_roughness 0.2 sheen_roughness 0.33 sheen_roughness 0.66 sheen_roughness 1 White indirect light Overlay images for comparison 141 There is a difference. -
MaterialX View uses curvature to represent subsurface, so the result
differs from Arnold. MaterialX View does not support subsurface_anisotropy and does not support indirect light. Comparison - Subsurface 142 -
Arnold's subsurface type is random walk by default. Change subsurface_scale
(the coefficient on radius) Only use Specular and Subsurface • specular(1) • specular_color(1, 1, 1) • specular_IOR(1.5) • specular_roughness(0) • subsurface(1) • subsurface_color(0.84, 0.55, 0.45) • subsurface_radius(1, 0.1, 0.03) • Change subsurface_scale Comparison - Subsurface 143 -
Comparison - Subsurface Arnold Daytime subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale
0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0 Overlay images for comparison 144 -
Comparison - Subsurface Daytime MaterialX View subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03
subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0 Overlay images for comparison 145 -
Comparison - Subsurface Daytime MaterialX View subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03
subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0 The colors are very different from Arnold’s. Arnold seems to be darker than the color specified by subsurface_color (MaterialX View has more natural colors). Check SubsurfaceColor only with directional light source and white directional light. Overlay images for comparison 146 -
subsurface_color 0.8, 0.8, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.3, 0.3, 0.3 subsurface_color 0.8,
0.5, 0.2 subsurface_color 0.4, 0.5, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.8, 0.9, 0 Arnold Directional light White IBL Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color Overlay images for comparison 147 -
subsurface_color 0.8, 0.8, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.3, 0.3, 0.3 subsurface_color 0.8,
0.5, 0.2 subsurface_color 0.4, 0.5, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.8, 0.9, 0 MaterialX View Directional light White IBL Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color Overlay images for comparison 148 -
subsurface_color 0.8, 0.8, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.3, 0.3, 0.3 subsurface_color 0.8,
0.5, 0.2 subsurface_color 0.4, 0.5, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.8, 0.9, 0 MaterialX View MaterialX View is light in color. (Arnold is darker). Directional light White IBL Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color Overlay images for comparison 149 -
The color difference problem was improved by squaring the Arnold
value for subsurface_color. Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color 150 -
subsurface_color 0.64, 0.64, 0.64 subsurface_color 0.09, 0.09, 0.09 subsurface_color 0.64,
0.25, 0.04 subsurface_color 0.16, 0.25, 0.64 subsurface_color 0.64, 0.81, 0 Directional light White IBL Same for color Compare again Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color Overlay images for comparison MaterialX View 151 -
subsurface_color 0.8, 0.8, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.3, 0.3, 0.3 subsurface_color 0.8,
0.5, 0.2 subsurface_color 0.4, 0.5, 0.8 subsurface_color 0.8, 0.9, 0 Arnold Directional light White IBL Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color Overlay images for comparison 152 -
subsurface_color 0.64, 0.64, 0.64 subsurface_color 0.09, 0.09, 0.09 subsurface_color 0.64,
0.25, 0.04 subsurface_color 0.16, 0.25, 0.64 subsurface_color 0.64, 0.81, 0 Directional light White IBL Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color Overlay images for comparison MaterialX View 153 -
subsurface_color 0.64, 0.64, 0.64 subsurface_color 0.09, 0.09, 0.09 subsurface_color 0.64,
0.25, 0.04 subsurface_color 0.16, 0.25, 0.64 subsurface_color 0.64, 0.81, 0 Directional light White IBL Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color Overlay images for comparison MaterialX View 154 The subsurface_radius on the left is 0.01 (1cm), but there is a problem that the width of the subsurface cannot be reduced. -
Comparison about the problem that Subsurface Radius cannot be reduced
• subsurface(1) • subsurface_color(1, 1, 1) • subsurface_radius(1, 0.1, 0.03) • Change subsurface_scale Check with direct light only Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface color 155 -
Arnold Red diffuse transmitted light is gradually penetrating. subsurface_scale 0.01
subsurface_scale 0.05 subsurface_scale 0.2 subsurface_scale 0.5 From the side Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface scale 156 -
If SubsurfaceRadius is smaller than a specific value, there is
a problem that it cannot be made smaller. If the SubsurfaceRadius is smaller than a specific value, the color will be gray. The problem is that it cannot blur only a few centimeters. (The sphere in the figure has a radius of 1 meter.) There is a limit on the radius in the code, so remove the limit. MaterialX View subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.05 subsurface_scale 0.2 subsurface_scale 0.5 From the side Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface scale 157 -
SubsurfaceScale0.01 could be expressed. We have posted a GitHub issue
about this. There was a problem that the degree of hanging changed depending on the camera zoom (the model was scaled); this has also been reported. Next, compare with indirect light. subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.05 subsurface_scale 0.2 subsurface_scale 0.5 In-house Lookdev environment From the side Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface – Subsurface scale 158 -
Arnold has Subsurface effect even with indirect light. Arnold IBL
subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0 Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface – Indirect Light 159 -
Subsurface in MaterialX View is not working for indirect light.
IBL subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0 Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface – Indirect Light MaterialX View 160 -
The problem that subsurface_radius cannot be made slight and subsurface_color
color does not match has been improved and compared. Comparison - Subsurface 161 -
Daytime Arnold subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3
subsurface_scale 1.0 Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface 162 -
In-house Lookdev environment Daytime subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1
subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0 Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface 163 -
In-house Lookdev environment Closer to Arnold Arnold has a feature
that when subsurface_radius is relatively large, the complementary color appears on the opposite side, but MaterialX View does not have this feature. Also, subsurface_anisotropy is not supported. Daytime subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0 Overlay images for comparison Comparison - Subsurface 164 -
MaterialX View uses Subsurface with Curvature, so objects with a
slight curvature or flat surfaces will not be the same as Arnold. Comparison – Subsurface - Shapes that cannot use curvature 165 -
Arnold subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale
1.0 Comparison – Subsurface - Shapes that cannot use curvature Overlay images for comparison 166 -
subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0
MaterialX View Comparison – Subsurface - Shapes that cannot use curvature Overlay images for comparison 167 -
subsurface_scale 0.01 subsurface_scale 0.03 subsurface_scale 0.1 subsurface_scale 0.3 subsurface_scale 1.0
MaterialX View Comparison – Subsurface - Shapes that cannot use curvature Overlay images for comparison 168 Such materials cannot be represented in MaterialX View -
Thin Walled during Subsurface This is used to express the
diffuse transmission of a thin plate-like paper or leaves. The value of Subsurface determines how much light is diffused to the back side. • base(1) • base_color(1, 1, 1) • Change subsurface • subsurface_color(0, 1, 0) • subsurface_scale(1) Comparison - Subsurface –Thin Walled 169 -
Arnold weight 0 weight 0.1 weight 0.3 weight 1 Daytime
Light source from the left IBL Comparison - Subsurface –Thin Walled Overlay images for comparison 170 -
weight 0 weight 0.1 weight 0.3 weight 1 MaterialX View
Daytime Light source from the left IBL Comparison - Subsurface –Thin Walled Overlay images for comparison 171 -
weight 0 weight 0.1 weight 0.3 weight 1 MaterialX View
Daytime Light source from the left IBL Comparison - Subsurface –Thin Walled Overlay images for comparison 172 No difference between Arnold and MaterialX View -
Coat is the same as the specular layer added to
the top layer Coloring the coat will color the bottom layer Comparison - Coat 173 No Coat With coat -
Check by coloring the coat for diffuse only • base(1)
• base_color(0.5, 0.5, 0.5) • coat(0 and 1) • coat_color(White(1, 1, 1) Red(1, 0.05, 0.02) Green(0.02, 1, 0.02)) 174 Comparison - Coat -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 175 Comparison - Coat Daytime Arnold -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 176 Comparison - Coat Daytime MaterialX View -
There is a problem for emission. Colored coat for emission
only • emission(1) • emission_color(1, 1, 1) • coat(0 and 1) • coat_color(White(1, 1, 1) Red(1, 0.05, 0.02) Green(0.02, 1, 0.02)) 177 Comparison - Coat - Relation to emission -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 178 Comparison - Coat Arnold Daytime Daytime(Enlarge) -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 179 Comparison - Coat MaterialX View Daytime Daytime(Enlarge) -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 180 Comparison - Coat MaterialX View Daytime Daytime(Enlarge) The reflection at the edges is uncomfortable. The coat should be on top of the emission layer, but it doesn't look like it. -
The problem with MaterialX View is that emission is added
after coating. Check with black IBL for easy identification. 181 Comparison - Coat -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 182 Comparison - Coat Arnold Black IBL Black IBL(Enlarge) -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 183 Comparison - Coat MaterialX View Black IBL Black IBL(Enlarge) -
Overlay images for comparison coat 0 coat_color (1,1,1) coat_color (1,
0.05, 0.02) coat_color (0.02 ,1, 0.02) 184 Comparison - Coat MaterialX View Black IBL Black IBL(Enlarge) We have posted about this issue in the MaterialX View GitHub issue In addition, Arnold does not support the coat_affect parameter (aiMaterialX supports it), but there may be a problem with coat_affect_color processing, so it is under investigation (already reported) -
The significant difference is the unsupported transmission. Other than that,
it is relatively close with some modifications. However, the performance is not practical in many parts, so it is necessary to customize the contents for each layer. MaterialX is a good reference. The important thing is to follow the layer structure of Standard Surface. If you follow it, even if the processing in each layer is slightly different, there will not be a big difference overall. Is MaterialX practical for Video Game Graphics? 185 -
Contents • About MaterialX • Implementation detail • Comparison with
DCC tools • Performance measurement • Other features • Conclusion 186 -
Performance measurement • Since video game graphics require performance, we
measured performance using our in-house Lookdev environment. OS Windows11 21H2 CPU Core i9-10900X GPU Geforce 2080 Ti Resolution 3840 x 2160 Number of sphere model vertices 6559 Measurement software PIX 2203.30 Measurement Environment Screenshot 187 -
Importance sampling • MaterialX uses importance sampling with a Radiance
environment map and GGX Directional Albedo. • MaterialX provides alternative functions for performance. (There are some side effects when using Pre-filter, for example, Specular Anisotropic cannot be used.) Radiance Environment Map GGX Directional Albedo Drawcall duration(msec) Screenshot Filtered importance sampling (256 sampling) Importance sampling (64 sampling) 52.82 Pre filter Importance sampling (64 sampling) 23.35 Pre filter Approximate function (Curve fit) 1.07 Standard Surface with all elements 188 -
Deletion of Standard Surface elements • The rendering duration can
be reduced by outputting a shader with the minimum necessary elements for each material. For example, remove transmission and metal calculations. Diffuse Subsurface Translucent Sheen Transmission Dielectric Metal Coat Emission Output Diffuse Translucent Dielectric Output Standard Surface with all elements Node structure with some elements reduced (same as traditional PBR) Emission Metal 189 -
Performance measurement example Standard surface element Drawcall duration(msec) Screenshot Diffuse,
Subsurface, Translucent, Sheen, Transmission, Dielectric, Metal, Coat, Emission (All elements) 1.07 Diffuse, Translucent, Dielectric, Metal, Emission (Traditional PBR) 0.48 Diffuse, Dielectric, Emission 0.29 Diffuse 0.13 • Pre Filter for Radiance environment map and approximate function for GGX Directional Albedo. • The reduction of material elements not related to the representation can reduce rendering duration. 190 -
Contents • About MaterialX • Implementation detail • Comparison with
DCC tools • Performance measurement • Other features • Conclusion 191 -
MaterialX file export • In-house Lookdev environment exports material parameters
to MaterialX files so MaterialX View can display the same materials. MaterialX View In-house Lookdev environment MaterialX file (.mtlx) 192 -
MaterialX file import • The in-house Lookdev environment can import
simple materials from AMD's MaterialX Library and other sources, which helps render comparisons. (https://matlib.gpuopen.com/main/materials/all) Import result to in-house Lookdev environment AMD’s MaterialX Library 193 -
Conclusion • Standard Surface can now be applied in video
game graphics. • Artists can now control video game materials with the same material parameter names as the DCC tool. • It is now possible to import MaterialX format materials from publicly available material libraries and compare drawing results with offline renderers such as Arnold. • Since MaterialX has become a standard language, it has become possible to discuss openly with other companies. • Information is communicated to the Arnold development team, and verification questions are posted to the MaterialX GitHub issue. 194 -
Shader source code reference example Standard Surface fragment shader output
main Indirect Light Standard Surface Emission Direct Light Conductor BSDF Translucent BSDF Diffuse BSDF Sheen BSDF Subsurface BSDF Dielectric BSDF(Specular) Dielectric BSDF(Coat) Ambient Occlusion 198 -
Standard Surface guide for Artists • The in-house LookDev environment
has a Standard Surface hierarchy diagram for artists, with a guide that shows which layer corresponds to the material parameter currently being edited. • Clicking on a material element in the diagram selects the corresponding parameter. Using the guide 199 -
BaseColor alpha value • The node configuration allows switching using
the BaseColor alpha value as Opacity or Transmission. • Using the alpha value of the BaseColor texture as Opacity is similar to traditional game graphics. Uses for BaseColor alpha values Opacity output Transmission output same as Standard Surface Opacity value Transmission value Opacity BaseColor alpha Opacity value Transmission Opacity value BaseColor alpha Opacity 0.1 (10% translucency in traditional game graphics) Transmission 0.9 (Specular is not missing) 201 -
Radiance environment map mip offset • MaterialX uses a fixed
value (-1.5) as the mipmap offset when referencing the radiance environment map in filtered importance sampling. • However, this value depends on the HDRI resolution (2048x1024) included with the MaterialX View, so the in-house Lookdev environment uses a variable value. Offset -1.5 Offset 0.5 MaterialX View In-house Lookdev environment Offset -1.5 202 -
Irradiance Environment Map • MaterialX View can choose to use
a pre-created Irradiance environment map or to bake an Irradiance environment map based on SH values. • Still, we decided to use SH values to have the same values as the in- house LookDev environment. The SH values inside MaterialX View are output as text and referenced in the in-house LookDev environment. Irradiance environment map baked based on SH values SH HDRI MaterialX View In-house Lookdev environment 203 -
Dichroic filter • Since Opacity has RGB information, the material
can now represent a dichroic filter using the pixel shader Src1Color (Dual source blending). Blend Settings Direct Lighting Indirect Lighting Standard Surface Pixel shader output(Src0) Pixel shader input Transmission Pixel shader output(Src1) Rendering result Dichroic filter example(Photo) 204 -
Difference between DiffuseRoughness and SpecularRoughness • Specular is greatly affected
by fine irregularities on the surface, but Diffuse is not. • Snow and skin are also diffuse, but they are the same, with more light penetrating the interior than ordinary objects. What is DiffuseRoughness? 205 -
Refraction and Reflection of Light What is DiffuseRoughness? 206 Light
entering and exiting a plate of glass at IOR 1.5 Intensity is distributed by reflection angle, refraction angle, and critical angle. Reflection and refraction several times -
Cross section of nonmetallic object What is DiffuseRoughness? 207 Incident
light Specular reflection (one reflection refraction) An object composed of IOR 1.5 and air crystals Outgoing light is indicated by the yellow line. Diffuse reflection (multiple reflection refraction) -
Cross section of nonmetallic object What is DiffuseRoughness? 208 Incident
light Specular reflection (one reflection refraction) When the surface is polished smooth, the specular becomes sharp. Diffuse changes tiny and has little effect on surface roughness. Diffuse reflection (multiple reflection refraction) -
Cross section of nonmetallic object What is DiffuseRoughness? 209 What
does it mean to have a rougher diffuse surface? Differences appear in more significant irregularities than in specular roughness. Incident light Diffuse reflection (multiple reflection refraction) Specular reflection (one reflection refraction) -
Cross section of nonmetallic object What is DiffuseRoughness? 210 Specular
reflection (one reflection refraction) An example of coarse diffuse but smooth specular About the same as the coat Diffuse reflection (multiple reflection refraction) Viewed from a distance -
Effects of diffuse_roughness on microfacets between uneven shape Arnold and
MaterialX View are both Oren-Nayer, but they do not consider the bounce between the bumps. • The coarser the color, the darker the color • However, the brighter the albedo, the more the bounce mitigated the effect. • These are not taken into account. Inter-reflection between dielectric microfacet irregularities 211 -
Rendering with a nonmetallic model of fine irregularities such as
the following Inter-reflection between dielectric microfacet irregularities 212 Rendered with more bounce times 500 convexities 100,000 convexities -
Rendering with variation in uneven height difference Inter-reflection between dielectric
microfacet irregularities 213 base_color is coarse in white but not darkened. 500 convexities 100,000 convexities -
Indirect light set to 0.5 gray Inter-reflection between dielectric microfacet
irregularities 214 If base_color is white, it is coarse but not darkened If bace_color is white, there is no energy loss, so it will look the same as the background even if it is coarse 500 convexities 100,000 convexities -
Oren-Nayar Reference Inter-reflection between dielectric microfacet irregularities 215 https://mimosa-pudica.net/improved-oren-nayar.html Parts
that are brighter as the base_color are brighter ρ: bese_color Coefficient multiplied by base_color. The rougher the sigma (something like roughness), the larger Losses are avoided in the following areas -
Oren-Nayar Reference Inter-reflection between dielectric microfacet irregularities 218 https://mimosa-pudica.net/improved-oren-nayar.html Comparison
If the loss is compensated As diffuse_roughness is increased, the image becomes brighter and the colors darker. For example, on desert ground, the difference in appearance is significant. -
Is Arnold's aiMaterialXShader the same as aiStandardSurface? We compared some
parameters. Are aiStandardSurface and aiMaterialXShader the same? 219 -
Is Arnold's aiMaterialXShader the same as aiStandardSurface? We compared some
parameters. Are aiStandardSurface and aiMaterialXShader the same? 220 -
Is Arnold's aiMaterialXShader the same as aiStandardSurface? We compared some
parameters. Are aiStandardSurface and aiMaterialXShader the same? 221 Basically, the same result. Same for Maya standardSurface