Share
Embed
Modeling of Neccessity Entrepreneuship via General Equilibrium Approach
MACSPro'2019 - Modeling and Analysis of Complex Systems and Processes, Vienna
21 - 23 March 2019
Maria Fomenko, Alexander Shapoval
Conference website http://macspro.club/
Website https://exactpro.com/
Linkedin https://www.linkedin.com/company/exactpro-systems-llc
Instagram https://www.instagram.com/exactpro/
Twitter https://twitter.com/exactpro
Facebook https://www.facebook.com/exactpro/
Youtube Channel https://www.youtube.com/c/exactprosystems
Transcript
53 slides
-
Modeling Neccessity Entrepreneuship via General Equilibrium Approach wri pomenkoD sh
hpovl National Research University Higher School of Economics Lab of Modeling and Control of Complex Systems wegro PHIWD wrh PPD PHIW Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 1 / 22 -
Motivation Aim of the talk gonstrut model of ouptionl
hoie under unertinty ixplin the existene of the neessity entrepreneurs in the frmework of this model Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 2 / 22 -
Motivation Aim of the talk gonstrut model of ouptionl
hoie under unertinty ixplin the existene of the neessity entrepreneurs in the frmework of this model Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 2 / 22 -
Motivation Aim of the talk gonstrut model of ouptionl
hoie under unertinty ixplin the existene of the neessity entrepreneurs in the frmework of this model Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 2 / 22 -
Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in
fvor of growthX qleser PHHUD pritsh IWWUD ghtterji PHIR qlol intrepreneurship wonitor reports motivtion of entrepreneurshipD eynolds et l PHHQ sn prtiulrD prt of entrepreneurs prefers slried jo ut fils to get n o'erY these individuls eome neessity entrepreneurs snnovtive usiness is ruil for eonomi developmentY neessity entrepreneurs re dly represented in innovtive usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22 -
Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in
fvor of growthX qleser PHHUD pritsh IWWUD ghtterji PHIR qlol intrepreneurship wonitor reports motivtion of entrepreneurshipD eynolds et l PHHQ sn prtiulrD prt of entrepreneurs prefers slried jo ut fils to get n o'erY these individuls eome neessity entrepreneurs snnovtive usiness is ruil for eonomi developmentY neessity entrepreneurs re dly represented in innovtive usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22 -
Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in
fvor of growthX qleser PHHUD pritsh IWWUD ghtterji PHIR qlol intrepreneurship wonitor reports motivtion of entrepreneurshipD eynolds et l PHHQ sn prtiulrD prt of entrepreneurs prefers slried jo ut fils to get n o'erY these individuls eome neessity entrepreneurs snnovtive usiness is ruil for eonomi developmentY neessity entrepreneurs re dly represented in innovtive usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22 -
Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in
fvor of growthX qleser PHHUD pritsh IWWUD ghtterji PHIR qlol intrepreneurship wonitor reports motivtion of entrepreneurshipD eynolds et l PHHQ sn prtiulrD prt of entrepreneurs prefers slried jo ut fils to get n o'erY these individuls eome neessity entrepreneurs snnovtive usiness is ruil for eonomi developmentY neessity entrepreneurs re dly represented in innovtive usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22 -
Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in
fvor of growthX qleser PHHUD pritsh IWWUD ghtterji PHIR qlol intrepreneurship wonitor reports motivtion of entrepreneurshipD eynolds et l PHHQ sn prtiulrD prt of entrepreneurs prefers slried jo ut fils to get n o'erY these individuls eome neessity entrepreneurs snnovtive usiness is ruil for eonomi developmentY neessity entrepreneurs re dly represented in innovtive usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs
MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs
MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of smll
nd medium size ompniesc elfEemployed individulsc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of smll
nd medium size ompniesc elfEemployed individulsc Self-employed are likely not ritil for growth to e neessity entrepreneurs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of smll
nd medium size ompniesc elfEemployed individulsc Self-employed are likely not ritil for growth to e neessity entrepreneurs In the model we nnot split entrepreneurs into groups euse of the model simpliity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of smll
nd medium size ompniesc elfEemployed individulsc Self-employed are likely not ritil for growth to e neessity entrepreneurs In the model we nnot split entrepreneurs into groups euse of the model simpliity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of smll
nd medium size ompniesc elfEemployed individulsc Self-employed are likely not ritil for growth to e neessity entrepreneurs In the model we nnot split entrepreneurs into groups euse of the model simpliity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of smll
nd medium size ompniesc elfEemployed individulsc Self-employed are likely not ritil for growth to e neessity entrepreneurs In the model we nnot split entrepreneurs into groups euse of the model simpliity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22 -
Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities yuptionl
hoieX n individul ompres the pro(t of the (rm tht she ould run nd her slry if she hooses slried joY lrger inome underlies the deision wore tlented individuls eome entrepreneurs he est entrepreneurs run igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion woEdimensionl hoie s the lne etween returns nd risk he more entrepreneur likes riskD the igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22 -
Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities yuptionl
hoieX n individul ompres the pro(t of the (rm tht she ould run nd her slry if she hooses slried joY lrger inome underlies the deision wore tlented individuls eome entrepreneurs he est entrepreneurs run igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion woEdimensionl hoie s the lne etween returns nd risk he more entrepreneur likes riskD the igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22 -
Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities yuptionl
hoieX n individul ompres the pro(t of the (rm tht she ould run nd her slry if she hooses slried joY lrger inome underlies the deision wore tlented individuls eome entrepreneurs he est entrepreneurs run igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion woEdimensionl hoie s the lne etween returns nd risk he more entrepreneur likes riskD the igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22 -
Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities yuptionl
hoieX n individul ompres the pro(t of the (rm tht she ould run nd her slry if she hooses slried joY lrger inome underlies the deision wore tlented individuls eome entrepreneurs he est entrepreneurs run igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion woEdimensionl hoie s the lne etween returns nd risk he more entrepreneur likes riskD the igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22 -
Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities yuptionl
hoieX n individul ompres the pro(t of the (rm tht she ould run nd her slry if she hooses slried joY lrger inome underlies the deision wore tlented individuls eome entrepreneurs he est entrepreneurs run igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion woEdimensionl hoie s the lne etween returns nd risk he more entrepreneur likes riskD the igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22 -
Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities yuptionl
hoieX n individul ompres the pro(t of the (rm tht she ould run nd her slry if she hooses slried joY lrger inome underlies the deision wore tlented individuls eome entrepreneurs he est entrepreneurs run igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion woEdimensionl hoie s the lne etween returns nd risk he more entrepreneur likes riskD the igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22 -
Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities yuptionl
hoieX n individul ompres the pro(t of the (rm tht she ould run nd her slry if she hooses slried joY lrger inome underlies the deision wore tlented individuls eome entrepreneurs he est entrepreneurs run igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion woEdimensionl hoie s the lne etween returns nd risk he more entrepreneur likes riskD the igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22 -
Canonical models: Financial gain Open questions ho re neessity entrepreneursc
ht is their role in the eonomyc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 6 / 22 -
Canonical models: Financial gain Open questions ho re neessity entrepreneursc
ht is their role in the eonomyc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 6 / 22 -
Canonical models: Financial gain Open questions ho re neessity entrepreneursc
ht is their role in the eonomyc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 6 / 22 -
Necessity entrepreneurs and unemployment xrit @PHIRAD uumr 8 huetze @PHHUAX
unemployment in equilirium due to imperfet serh for employees wil¡ n @PHIPAX selfEemployment is used s route out of unemployment e propose simpler pproh tht leds to similr onlusions Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 7 / 22 -
Necessity entrepreneurs and unemployment xrit @PHIRAD uumr 8 huetze @PHHUAX
unemployment in equilirium due to imperfet serh for employees wil¡ n @PHIPAX selfEemployment is used s route out of unemployment e propose simpler pproh tht leds to similr onlusions Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 7 / 22 -
Perception about entrepreneurs Ð Ø × Ê × Æ Ó
Ò ¹ Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 8 / 22 -
Perception about entrepreneurs Ð Ø × Ê × Æ Ó
Ò ¹ Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 8 / 22 -
Perception about entrepreneurs Ð Ø × Ê × Æ Ó
Ò ¹ Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× ÖÑ × Þ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 8 / 22 -
Concept of Equilibrium Income axis, α is a tax rate
b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 9 / 22 -
Concept of Equilibrium Income axis, α is a tax rate
b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ This scheme determines equilibrium if noody is motivted or not le to hnge the ouptionl hoieX nemployed gents re not le to run (rm nd get n inome tht is lrger thn b xoody n get jo o'er Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 9 / 22 -
b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø
Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 10 / 22 -
b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø
Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ ÏÓÖ Ö× ÍÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ ÒØ× ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ× φb φw A B C D γ(ϕ) Ð Ø × sndividuls with entrepreneuril ilities φb nd φw n ern fterEtx pro(t b nd (1 − α)w respetivelyD when running (rm Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 10 / 22 -
Baseline Model: Assumptions e onsider single setor eonomy with
monopolistilly ompeting singleEprodut (rms l¡ h @IWUUA sndividuls re heterogeneous with respet to their entrepreneuril ilities ut homogeneous s workers nd onsumersY iming t lrger inomeD they deide upon entrepreneurship nd the entrne to the lor mrketD whih leds to jo o'er or unemploymentY he distriution of ilities is ommon knowledge ih spei( gent does not 'et the mrket wo stge ouptionl hoieX Initial occupational choice can be altered if the alternation increases the income Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 11 / 22 -
Occupational choice as a two stage tree yuptionl ghoie intrepeneurship
intrepreneurship to wrket lried to nemployment to wrket lried to nemployment Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 12 / 22 -
Occupational choice as a backward induction foth stgesX vet Ξe,1
nd Ξe,2 e the set of entrepreneurs @nd the set of (rmsD nd the set of vrieties of the di'erentited goodA fter the Ist nd Pnd stges respetivelyF sndividul ξ ∈ Ξe,∗ ⇐⇒ IncomeEntrepreneur IncomeJob Market. he seond stge deision is prmetrized y the outome of the (rst stge he (rst stgeX individuls ntiipte the est ouptionl hoie of the seond stgeF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 13 / 22 -
Occupational choice: Second stage Risk aversion sndividuls who re le
to ern fter tx pro(t exeeding the unemployment ene(t (1 − α)πϕ,2 b hoose entrepreneurshipF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 14 / 22 -
Occupational choice: First stage ξϕ ∈ Ξe,1 ⇐⇒ (1 −
α)πϕ,1 E + A(1 − α)πϕ,2 EE τ1(1 − α)w W + Aτ1ρ(1 − α)w WW + Aτ1(1 − ρ)(1 − α)πϕ,2 WU + (1 − τ1)b U + A(1 − τ1)(1 − α)πϕ,1 UE . - A is disount ftor - α indites txes - w nd π re the wges nd pro(ts - τ1 nd ρ re the proilities to get jo o'er t the (rst stge nd to keep the work t the seond stge - ED WD U mrk individuls fter the (rst ouptionl hoieX entrepreneurD workerD unemployed individul - wo symolsD iF eFD WU mrk the result of the seond ouptionl hoie Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 15 / 22 -
Supply intrepreneur ξ ∈ Ξe with entrepreneuril ilities ϕ =
ϕ(ξ) hrges prie pϕ in order to mximize the pro(t πϕ = pϕqϕ − qϕw ϕ → max, @IA where qϕ nd w re the ggregte demnd nd wges respetivelyF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 16 / 22 -
Demand under monopolistic competition he eonomy produes single di'erentited
good represented y set of vrieties tht hve muh in ommonF et stge i = 1, 2D onsumer ξ ∈ Ξ with the inome Yξ,i hooses the demnds Qj,ξD j ∈ Ξe,iD to mximize her utility U = Ξe,i Qj,ξ σ − 1 σ j,ξ dj σ σ−1 → max, @PA sujet to the udget onstrin Ξe,i pjQj,ξ dj Yξ,i, @QA where pj is the prie for the vriety j t the stge i = 1Y σ ∈ (0, 1) is the elstiity of sustitution etween vrieties of the di'erentited goodF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 17 / 22 -
Unemployment benet e prt α of wges nd pro(ts is
redistriuted eqully mong unemployed gents Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 18 / 22 -
Initial choice b (1 − α)w ¯ Y ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ
Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ where ¯ Y is the expeted inome of jo mrket ndidtes Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 19 / 22 -
Initial choice b (1 − α)w ¯ Y ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ
Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 19 / 22 -
Initial choice and adjustment b (1 − α)w ¯ Y
ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × Ð ×× Ø Ð ÒØ ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ× ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 19 / 22 -
Equilibrium Proposition 1 Equilibrium exists and it is unique. In
equilibrium, rms do not hire any additional worker. Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 20 / 22 -
Concluding remarks e introdue the mehnism of the ouptionl hoie
tht led to generl equilirium with neessity entrepreneurs nd unemployed gentsF xeessity entrepreneurship redues the unemployment rte vortory experiment tht models the ouptionl hoieF rogrmming the rules G gme @n open prolemA wultiEstge modelX numeril solutionF ixistene nd uniqueness of the equiliriumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22 -
Concluding remarks e introdue the mehnism of the ouptionl hoie
tht led to generl equilirium with neessity entrepreneurs nd unemployed gentsF xeessity entrepreneurship redues the unemployment rte vortory experiment tht models the ouptionl hoieF rogrmming the rules G gme @n open prolemA wultiEstge modelX numeril solutionF ixistene nd uniqueness of the equiliriumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22 -
Concluding remarks e introdue the mehnism of the ouptionl hoie
tht led to generl equilirium with neessity entrepreneurs nd unemployed gentsF xeessity entrepreneurship redues the unemployment rte vortory experiment tht models the ouptionl hoieF rogrmming the rules G gme @n open prolemA wultiEstge modelX numeril solutionF ixistene nd uniqueness of the equiliriumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22 -
Concluding remarks e introdue the mehnism of the ouptionl hoie
tht led to generl equilirium with neessity entrepreneurs nd unemployed gentsF xeessity entrepreneurship redues the unemployment rte vortory experiment tht models the ouptionl hoieF rogrmming the rules G gme @n open prolemA wultiEstge modelX numeril solutionF ixistene nd uniqueness of the equiliriumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22 -
r e x u y Fomenko &
Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 22 / 22