Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

Modeling of Neccessity Entrepreneuship via General Equilibrium Approach

Modeling of Neccessity Entrepreneuship via General Equilibrium Approach

MACSPro'2019 - Modeling and Analysis of Complex Systems and Processes, Vienna
21 - 23 March 2019

Maria Fomenko, Alexander Shapoval

Conference website http://macspro.club/

Website https://exactpro.com/
Linkedin https://www.linkedin.com/company/exactpro-systems-llc
Instagram https://www.instagram.com/exactpro/
Twitter https://twitter.com/exactpro
Facebook https://www.facebook.com/exactpro/
Youtube Channel https://www.youtube.com/c/exactprosystems

Exactpro

March 23, 2019
Tweet

More Decks by Exactpro

Other Decks in Research

Transcript

  1. Modeling Neccessity Entrepreneuship via General Equilibrium Approach w—ri— pomenkoD ƒ—sh—

    ƒh—pov—l National Research University Higher School of Economics Lab of Modeling and Control of Complex Systems wegƒ€ro PHIWD w—r™h PPD PHIW Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 1 / 22
  2. Motivation Aim of the talk gonstru™t — model of o™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™e under un™ert—inty ixpl—in the existen™e of the ne™essity entrepreneurs in the fr—mework of this model Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 2 / 22
  3. Motivation Aim of the talk gonstru™t — model of o™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™e under un™ert—inty ixpl—in the existen™e of the ne™essity entrepreneurs in the fr—mework of this model Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 2 / 22
  4. Motivation Aim of the talk gonstru™t — model of o™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™e under un™ert—inty ixpl—in the existen™e of the ne™essity entrepreneurs in the fr—mework of this model Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 2 / 22
  5. Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in

    f—vor of growthX ql—eser PHHUD prits™h IWWUD gh—tterji PHIR qlo˜—l intrepreneurship wonitor reports motiv—tion of entrepreneurshipD ‚eynolds et —l PHHQ sn p—rti™ul—rD — p—rt of entrepreneurs prefers — s—l—ried jo˜ ˜ut f—ils to get —n o'erY these individu—ls ˜e™ome ne™essity entrepreneurs snnov—tive ˜usiness is ™ru™i—l for e™onomi™ developmentY ne™essity entrepreneurs —re ˜—dly represented in innov—tive ˜usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22
  6. Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in

    f—vor of growthX ql—eser PHHUD prits™h IWWUD gh—tterji PHIR qlo˜—l intrepreneurship wonitor reports motiv—tion of entrepreneurshipD ‚eynolds et —l PHHQ sn p—rti™ul—rD — p—rt of entrepreneurs prefers — s—l—ried jo˜ ˜ut f—ils to get —n o'erY these individu—ls ˜e™ome ne™essity entrepreneurs snnov—tive ˜usiness is ™ru™i—l for e™onomi™ developmentY ne™essity entrepreneurs —re ˜—dly represented in innov—tive ˜usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22
  7. Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in

    f—vor of growthX ql—eser PHHUD prits™h IWWUD gh—tterji PHIR qlo˜—l intrepreneurship wonitor reports motiv—tion of entrepreneurshipD ‚eynolds et —l PHHQ sn p—rti™ul—rD — p—rt of entrepreneurs prefers — s—l—ried jo˜ ˜ut f—ils to get —n o'erY these individu—ls ˜e™ome ne™essity entrepreneurs snnov—tive ˜usiness is ™ru™i—l for e™onomi™ developmentY ne™essity entrepreneurs —re ˜—dly represented in innov—tive ˜usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22
  8. Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in

    f—vor of growthX ql—eser PHHUD prits™h IWWUD gh—tterji PHIR qlo˜—l intrepreneurship wonitor reports motiv—tion of entrepreneurshipD ‚eynolds et —l PHHQ sn p—rti™ul—rD — p—rt of entrepreneurs prefers — s—l—ried jo˜ ˜ut f—ils to get —n o'erY these individu—ls ˜e™ome ne™essity entrepreneurs snnov—tive ˜usiness is ™ru™i—l for e™onomi™ developmentY ne™essity entrepreneurs —re ˜—dly represented in innov—tive ˜usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22
  9. Motivation Entrepreneurship as an engine for growth intrepreneurship is in

    f—vor of growthX ql—eser PHHUD prits™h IWWUD gh—tterji PHIR qlo˜—l intrepreneurship wonitor reports motiv—tion of entrepreneurshipD ‚eynolds et —l PHHQ sn p—rti™ul—rD — p—rt of entrepreneurs prefers — s—l—ried jo˜ ˜ut f—ils to get —n o'erY these individu—ls ˜e™ome ne™essity entrepreneurs snnov—tive ˜usiness is ™ru™i—l for e™onomi™ developmentY ne™essity entrepreneurs —re ˜—dly represented in innov—tive ˜usiness Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 3 / 22
  10. Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of sm—ll

    —nd medium size ™omp—niesc ƒelfEemployed individu—lsc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22
  11. Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of sm—ll

    —nd medium size ™omp—niesc ƒelfEemployed individu—lsc Self-employed are likely not ™riti™—l for growth to ˜e ne™essity entrepreneurs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22
  12. Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of sm—ll

    —nd medium size ™omp—niesc ƒelfEemployed individu—lsc Self-employed are likely not ™riti™—l for growth to ˜e ne™essity entrepreneurs In the model we ™—nnot split entrepreneurs into groups ˜e™—use of the model simpli™ity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22
  13. Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of sm—ll

    —nd medium size ™omp—niesc ƒelfEemployed individu—lsc Self-employed are likely not ™riti™—l for growth to ˜e ne™essity entrepreneurs In the model we ™—nnot split entrepreneurs into groups ˜e™—use of the model simpli™ity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22
  14. Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of sm—ll

    —nd medium size ™omp—niesc ƒelfEemployed individu—lsc Self-employed are likely not ™riti™—l for growth to ˜e ne™essity entrepreneurs In the model we ™—nnot split entrepreneurs into groups ˜e™—use of the model simpli™ity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22
  15. Motivation Who are entrepreneurs? ywners of enterprisesc pounders of sm—ll

    —nd medium size ™omp—niesc ƒelfEemployed individu—lsc Self-employed are likely not ™riti™—l for growth to ˜e ne™essity entrepreneurs In the model we ™—nnot split entrepreneurs into groups ˜e™—use of the model simpli™ity Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 4 / 22
  16. Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities y™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™eX —n individu—l ™omp—res the pro(t of the (rm th—t she ™ould run —nd her s—l—ry if she ™hooses — s—l—ried jo˜Y — l—rger in™ome underlies the de™ision wore t—lented individu—ls ˜e™ome entrepreneurs „he ˜est entrepreneurs run ˜igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion „woEdimension—l ™hoi™e —s the ˜—l—n™e ˜etween returns —nd risk „he more entrepreneur likes riskD the ˜igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22
  17. Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities y™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™eX —n individu—l ™omp—res the pro(t of the (rm th—t she ™ould run —nd her s—l—ry if she ™hooses — s—l—ried jo˜Y — l—rger in™ome underlies the de™ision wore t—lented individu—ls ˜e™ome entrepreneurs „he ˜est entrepreneurs run ˜igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion „woEdimension—l ™hoi™e —s the ˜—l—n™e ˜etween returns —nd risk „he more entrepreneur likes riskD the ˜igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22
  18. Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities y™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™eX —n individu—l ™omp—res the pro(t of the (rm th—t she ™ould run —nd her s—l—ry if she ™hooses — s—l—ried jo˜Y — l—rger in™ome underlies the de™ision wore t—lented individu—ls ˜e™ome entrepreneurs „he ˜est entrepreneurs run ˜igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion „woEdimension—l ™hoi™e —s the ˜—l—n™e ˜etween returns —nd risk „he more entrepreneur likes riskD the ˜igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22
  19. Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities y™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™eX —n individu—l ™omp—res the pro(t of the (rm th—t she ™ould run —nd her s—l—ry if she ™hooses — s—l—ried jo˜Y — l—rger in™ome underlies the de™ision wore t—lented individu—ls ˜e™ome entrepreneurs „he ˜est entrepreneurs run ˜igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion „woEdimension—l ™hoi™e —s the ˜—l—n™e ˜etween returns —nd risk „he more entrepreneur likes riskD the ˜igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22
  20. Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities y™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™eX —n individu—l ™omp—res the pro(t of the (rm th—t she ™ould run —nd her s—l—ry if she ™hooses — s—l—ried jo˜Y — l—rger in™ome underlies the de™ision wore t—lented individu—ls ˜e™ome entrepreneurs „he ˜est entrepreneurs run ˜igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion „woEdimension—l ™hoi™e —s the ˜—l—n™e ˜etween returns —nd risk „he more entrepreneur likes riskD the ˜igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22
  21. Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities y™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™eX —n individu—l ™omp—res the pro(t of the (rm th—t she ™ould run —nd her s—l—ry if she ™hooses — s—l—ried jo˜Y — l—rger in™ome underlies the de™ision wore t—lented individu—ls ˜e™ome entrepreneurs „he ˜est entrepreneurs run ˜igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion „woEdimension—l ™hoi™e —s the ˜—l—n™e ˜etween returns —nd risk „he more entrepreneur likes riskD the ˜igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22
  22. Canonical models: nancial motivation Lukas (1978): heterogeneous entrepreneurial abilities y™™up—tion—l

    ™hoi™eX —n individu—l ™omp—res the pro(t of the (rm th—t she ™ould run —nd her s—l—ry if she ™hooses — s—l—ried jo˜Y — l—rger in™ome underlies the de™ision wore t—lented individu—ls ˜e™ome entrepreneurs „he ˜est entrepreneurs run ˜igger (rms Kilhstrom & Laont (1979): heterogeneous risk aversion „woEdimension—l ™hoi™e —s the ˜—l—n™e ˜etween returns —nd risk „he more entrepreneur likes riskD the ˜igger (rm she runs Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 5 / 22
  23. Canonical models: Financial gain Open questions ‡ho —re ne™essity entrepreneursc

    ‡h—t is their role in the e™onomyc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 6 / 22
  24. Canonical models: Financial gain Open questions ‡ho —re ne™essity entrepreneursc

    ‡h—t is their role in the e™onomyc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 6 / 22
  25. Canonical models: Financial gain Open questions ‡ho —re ne™essity entrepreneursc

    ‡h—t is their role in the e™onomyc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 6 / 22
  26. Necessity entrepreneurs and unemployment x—rit— @PHIRAD uum—r 8 ƒ™huetze @PHHUAX

    unemployment in equili˜rium due to imperfe™t se—r™h for employees wil¡ —n @PHIPAX selfEemployment is used —s — route out of unemployment ‡e propose — simpler —ppro—™h th—t le—ds to simil—r ™on™lusions Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 7 / 22
  27. Necessity entrepreneurs and unemployment x—rit— @PHIRAD uum—r 8 ƒ™huetze @PHHUAX

    unemployment in equili˜rium due to imperfe™t se—r™h for employees wil¡ —n @PHIPAX selfEemployment is used —s — route out of unemployment ‡e propose — simpler —ppro—™h th—t le—ds to simil—r ™on™lusions Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 7 / 22
  28. Perception about entrepreneurs Ð Ø × Ê × Æ Ó

    Ò ¹ Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 8 / 22
  29. Perception about entrepreneurs Ð Ø × Ê × Æ Ó

    Ò ¹ Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 8 / 22
  30. Perception about entrepreneurs Ð Ø × Ê × Æ Ó

    Ò ¹ Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× Ò ØÖ Ô Ö Ò Ù Ö× ÖÑ × Þ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 8 / 22
  31. Concept of Equilibrium Income axis, α is a tax rate

    b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 9 / 22
  32. Concept of Equilibrium Income axis, α is a tax rate

    b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ This scheme determines equilibrium if no˜ody is motiv—ted or not —˜le to ™h—nge the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™eX …nemployed —gents —re not —˜le to run — (rm —nd get —n in™ome th—t is l—rger th—n b xo˜ody ™—n get — jo˜ o'er Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 9 / 22
  33. b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø

    Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 10 / 22
  34. b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø

    Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ ÏÓÖ Ö× ÍÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ ÒØ× ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ× φb φw A B C D γ(ϕ) Ð Ø × sndividu—ls with entrepreneuri—l —˜ilities φb —nd φw ™—n e—rn —fterEt—x pro(t b —nd (1 − α)w respe™tivelyD when running — (rm Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 10 / 22
  35. Baseline Model: Assumptions ‡e ™onsider — single se™tor e™onomy with

    monopolisti™—lly ™ompeting singleEprodu™t (rms — l¡ — hƒ @IWUUA sndividu—ls —re heterogeneous with respe™t to their entrepreneuri—l —˜ilities ˜ut homogeneous —s workers —nd ™onsumersY —iming —t — l—rger in™omeD they de™ide upon entrepreneurship —nd the entr—n™e to the l—˜or m—rketD whi™h le—ds to — jo˜ o'er or unemploymentY „he distri˜ution of —˜ilities is ™ommon knowledge i—™h spe™i(™ —gent does not —'e™t the m—rket „wo st—ge o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™eX Initial occupational choice can be altered if the alternation increases the income Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 11 / 22
  36. Occupational choice as a two stage tree y™™up—tion—l ghoi™e intrepeneurship

    intrepreneurship to˜ w—rket ƒ—l—ried to˜ …nemployment to˜ w—rket ƒ—l—ried to˜ …nemployment Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 12 / 22
  37. Occupational choice as a backward induction foth st—gesX vet Ξe,1

    —nd Ξe,2 ˜e the set of entrepreneurs @—nd the set of (rmsD —nd the set of v—rieties of the di'erenti—ted goodA —fter the Ist —nd Pnd st—ges respe™tivelyF sndividu—l ξ ∈ Ξe,∗ ⇐⇒ IncomeEntrepreneur IncomeJob Market. „he se™ond st—ge de™ision is p—r—metrized ˜y the out™ome of the (rst st—ge „he (rst st—geX individu—ls —nti™ip—te the ˜est o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™e of the se™ond st—geF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 13 / 22
  38. Occupational choice: Second stage Risk aversion sndividu—ls who —re —˜le

    to e—rn —fter t—x pro(t ex™eeding the unemployment ˜ene(t (1 − α)πϕ,2 b ™hoose entrepreneurshipF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 14 / 22
  39. Occupational choice: First stage ξϕ ∈ Ξe,1 ⇐⇒ (1 −

    α)πϕ,1 E + A(1 − α)πϕ,2 EE τ1(1 − α)w W + Aτ1ρ(1 − α)w WW + Aτ1(1 − ρ)(1 − α)πϕ,2 WU + (1 − τ1)b U + A(1 − τ1)(1 − α)πϕ,1 UE . - A is — dis™ount f—™tor - α indi™—tes t—xes - w —nd π —re the w—ges —nd pro(ts - τ1 —nd ρ —re the pro˜—˜ilities to get — jo˜ o'er —t the (rst st—ge —nd to keep the work —t the se™ond st—ge - ED WD U m—rk individu—ls —fter the (rst o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™eX entrepreneurD workerD unemployed individu—l - „wo sym˜olsD iF eFD WU m—rk the result of the se™ond o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™e Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 15 / 22
  40. Supply intrepreneur ξ ∈ Ξe with entrepreneuri—l —˜ilities ϕ =

    ϕ(ξ) ™h—rges pri™e pϕ in order to m—ximize the pro(t πϕ = pϕqϕ − qϕw ϕ → max, @IA where qϕ —nd w —re the —ggreg—te dem—nd —nd w—ges respe™tivelyF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 16 / 22
  41. Demand under monopolistic competition „he e™onomy produ™es — single di'erenti—ted

    good represented ˜y — set of v—rieties th—t h—ve mu™h in ™ommonF et st—ge i = 1, 2D — ™onsumer ξ ∈ Ξ with the in™ome Yξ,i ™hooses the dem—nds Qj,ξD j ∈ Ξe,iD to m—ximize her utility U = Ξe,i Qj,ξ σ − 1 σ j,ξ dj σ σ−1 → max, @PA su˜je™t to the ˜udget ™onstr—in Ξe,i pjQj,ξ dj Yξ,i, @QA where pj is the pri™e for the v—riety j —t the st—ge i = 1Y σ ∈ (0, 1) is the el—sti™ity of su˜stitution ˜etween v—rieties of the di'erenti—ted goodF Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 17 / 22
  42. Unemployment benet e p—rt α of w—ges —nd pro(ts is

    redistri˜uted equ—lly —mong unemployed —gents Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 18 / 22
  43. Initial choice b (1 − α)w ¯ Y ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ

    Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ where ¯ Y is the expe™ted in™ome of jo˜ m—rket ™—ndid—tes Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 19 / 22
  44. Initial choice b (1 − α)w ¯ Y ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ

    Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 19 / 22
  45. Initial choice and adjustment b (1 − α)w ¯ Y

    ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × Ð ×× Ø Ð ÒØ ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ× ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ b (1 − α)w ÙÒ ÑÔÐÓÝ Ò Ø Ø Ö¹Ø Ü Û × ÒØÖ ÔÖ Ò ÙÖ׳ Ø Ö¹Ø Ü ÔÖÓ Ø× ÁÒ ÓÑ Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 19 / 22
  46. Equilibrium Proposition 1 Equilibrium exists and it is unique. In

    equilibrium, rms do not hire any additional worker. Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 20 / 22
  47. Concluding remarks ‡e introdu™e the me™h—nism of the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™e

    th—t le—d to gener—l equili˜rium with ne™essity entrepreneurs —nd unemployed —gentsF xe™essity entrepreneurship redu™es the unemployment r—te v—˜or—tory experiment th—t models the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™eF €rogr—mming the rules G g—me @—n open pro˜lemA wultiEst—ge modelX numeri™—l solutionF ixisten™e —nd uniqueness of the equili˜riumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22
  48. Concluding remarks ‡e introdu™e the me™h—nism of the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™e

    th—t le—d to gener—l equili˜rium with ne™essity entrepreneurs —nd unemployed —gentsF xe™essity entrepreneurship redu™es the unemployment r—te v—˜or—tory experiment th—t models the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™eF €rogr—mming the rules G g—me @—n open pro˜lemA wultiEst—ge modelX numeri™—l solutionF ixisten™e —nd uniqueness of the equili˜riumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22
  49. Concluding remarks ‡e introdu™e the me™h—nism of the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™e

    th—t le—d to gener—l equili˜rium with ne™essity entrepreneurs —nd unemployed —gentsF xe™essity entrepreneurship redu™es the unemployment r—te v—˜or—tory experiment th—t models the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™eF €rogr—mming the rules G g—me @—n open pro˜lemA wultiEst—ge modelX numeri™—l solutionF ixisten™e —nd uniqueness of the equili˜riumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22
  50. Concluding remarks ‡e introdu™e the me™h—nism of the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™e

    th—t le—d to gener—l equili˜rium with ne™essity entrepreneurs —nd unemployed —gentsF xe™essity entrepreneurship redu™es the unemployment r—te v—˜or—tory experiment th—t models the o™™up—tion—l ™hoi™eF €rogr—mming the rules G g—me @—n open pro˜lemA wultiEst—ge modelX numeri™—l solutionF ixisten™e —nd uniqueness of the equili˜riumc Fomenko & Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 21 / 22
  51. „ r e x u ‰ y … Fomenko &

    Shapoval (HSE) Necessity Entrepreneurs MACSPro, 2019 22 / 22