Share
Embed
RxRE: Lean Thinking In Healthcare
Slides from Colliers International |Boston's RxRE: Lean Thinking in Healthcare seminar. February 28, 2013
Colliers International | Boston
February 28, 2013
Transcript
55 slides
-
Welcome February 28, 2013 PANELISTS Walter G. Armstrong Senior Vice
President, Capital Facilities & Engineering Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center Wendy Writer Gettleman Vice President, Facilities Management & Real Estate Dana-Farber Cancer Institute John Messervy, AIA Director of Capital & Facilities Planning Partners HealthCare William R. Seed Staff Vice President, Design & Construction Department Universal Health Services MODERATOR Daniel R. Quinn Executive Vice President, Development & Consulting Services Colliers International -
Tools to Assist in Lean Process Design Time Study RN
PDA Data Collection -
Hospitalist Activity Breakdown 37.6% 16.6% 14.2% 13.2% 12.9% 4.1% 1.4%
Writing Progress Note Chart Review Writing Orders Comm. w/ MD Patient Care Conf. By Nurse Station Activity 60.9% 13.9% 11.3% 6.1% 6.1% 1.7% Daily Rounds Subsequent Visit Admission Dishcarge Family Meeting Teaching By Patient Room Activity -
Euclidian Model The Centralized Nurse Station model requires multiple trips
to and from the Nurse Station and Patient Room. -
60.7% of all trips for RNs / CNAs / Techs
involve those to and from the Patient Room and Nurse Station. Travel Density -
• Transition from centralized nurse stations to decentralized care delivery
model • Decentralized supplies • Decentralized workstations • Medications decentralized to cabinets outside of each patient room PDA Data Informs Design of the IP Unit -
Lean Design Reduces Travel by 51% 0 5,000 10,000 15,000
20,000 25,000 Davenport 7 Davenport 9 West 1 Final Option 23,229 18,046 21,207 11,345 Estimated Travel Distance (Ft per Hr by Nurses) Existing Inpatient Units New Inpatient Design 11,884 Feet/Hour Travel Reduction -
6 beds 6 beds 6 beds 5 beds + 1
Isolation 5 beds + 1 Isolation 5 beds + 1 Isolation Design Impact on Care Delivery & Functionality 12 Bed Pod 12 Bed Pod 12 Bed Pod 36 beds grouped in 3 clusters of 12 based on hospitalist and nursing staffing models New Lobby below Public Elevators Patient Elevators -
Unit Cost Shell & Core Fit-out 1998 $158/sf $177/sf 2005
$296/sf $262/sf 2009 $428/sf $323/sf Project Cost Schematic Design: $117M $354/sf Design Development: $129M $343/sf GMP: $134M $353/sf Complete: $144M $379/sf - Increase: $ 27M $ 25/sf Delivered 2 months late Cost Creep -
Why is Lean Design and Construction Attractive to an Owner?
• Reduced risk • Improved management of project costs • Supports making sound decisions • Promotes the accumulation and sharing of knowledge -
Walter G. Armstrong Senior Vice President, Capital Facilities & Engineering
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center -
The Unique Contribution of a Lean/Toyota Production System Approach to
Design & Construction February 28, 2013 -
Lean is an effective tool in making hospital operations more
efficient. Background in engineer-led, heavy construction projects influences view Context: 21 -
• Integrated team with early collaboration among designers, constructors, commissioning
agents, etc. • Early and ongoing involvement of key stakeholders • Value engineering, constructability and operability reviews • Design software used to increased construction efficiencies and maintain quality control • Progressive contracting practices • Many more What Does Lean Expertise Bring to Design and Construction that Cannot be Gained by Improved Project Delivery Techniques such as: -
• East Campus Pharmacy upgrade $ 2.2 M • Pre-Admission
Testing Center $ 4.4 M • Western Cancer Center $ 32.0 M Application of Lean Expertise to Design Construction -
• Pharmacy – sub-consultant on design team • Pre-Admission Testing
Center – expert as part of architectural team • Western Cancer Center – separate contract with the owner, coordinating with other team members and stakeholders Different Placement of Lean Expertise on Design and Construction -
• 20 front-line staff off-line for a week • “Gemba”
walks of current space • Value stream map of current workflows • Work Breakdown Structure • Map IS flow process and document management Sample Lean Exercise: Pharmacy -
• Conduct Rapid Improvement exercises • Tour off-site locations for
best practices • Define standard work • Establish metrics • Define future workflows Sample Lean Exercise: Pharmacy -
• Designed equipment layout on paper with multiple teams •
Arranged full-sized equipment models on full-scale floor layouts • Each team’s layout was video taped and reviewed by all participants • Each team did 3 layouts in sequence followed by group discussions • Consensus reached on equipment layout Sample Lean Exercise: Pharmacy -
• Focus on GEMBA (“where the work is done”) •
Involvement of front-line staff • Structuring the input of front-line staff through standard tools and techniques • Understanding and improving the workflow prior to hardened design concepts • Obtaining input from the customer Enhanced Benefits of Lean -
• Finding Lean experts skilled in design, not operations •
Finding Lean experts comfortable in working in the engineering/construction environment with its emphasis on cost and schedule • Finding architectural firms which have integrated operations experts/industrial engineers into their practice • Assisting front-line employees to conceptualize new workflows in new spaces, rather than improving workflows in existing environments Challenges -
Wendy Writer Gettleman Vice President, Facilities Management & Real Estate
Dana-Farber Cancer Institute -
Yawkey Center for Cancer Care Designed by patients, families and
staff, for patients, families and staff. It all started with our design principles: 1. Promote personalized, multidisciplinary, safe, respectful, compassionate cancer care for patients and families in a healing environment 2. Stimulate translation of research into the care of patients 3. Optimize flexibility and utility of space 4. Streamline the flow of patients and materials, minimize wait and treatment times 5. Foster productivity and collaboration of staff 6. Create a new front entrance and presence -
Yawkey Design Process 2006 - 2007 Established user groups to
inform design process > 30 design committees & user groups > 300 participants in planning & design process including: Defined decision makers & roles • user groups and committees informed • 2020 group packaged clinical decisions • Steering committee provided recommendations • Leadership Triad made timely decisions • More than 25 MDs • More than 25 RNs • More than 30 patient and family members • More than 250 DF/BWCC employees -
How is this LEAN design? LEAN is all about process
improvement ~ Pulling patients, family members, staff and leadership together to: › establish project goals › define and remove waste & “work arounds” › incorporate safe design features › then integrate what we learn into the design -
LEAN tools used during design, construction & post occupancy Lab
Services (Phlebotomy) Goal: Streamline the flow of patients and materials, minimize wait and treatment times During design: simulation exercises with Tefen to understand flow and impacts of Centralization During construction: get it right the first time! Limit & manage change orders. Communicate. Coordinate. Work as a team. Post occupancy: Kaizen with staff & patients to review flow and opportunities for improvement -
Public side Staff Consult rooms Bridge Exam Infusion vitals Check
out Check in Challenges • Staff turn-over between design & occupancy • Hard to imagine and plan operational change so far in advance (2006-2011) • Last minute operational changes • New technology + new space = higher hurdles Overcome these challenges by: • documenting assumptions & decisions as they are made • revisit these decisions during operational planning • work through operational needs as a team to limit change Meeting space -
Measuring success • Under budget & occupied ahead of schedule
• Press Ganey scores in the 90s - higher than ever! • Association of General Contractors (AGC) National Build America Award for “New: Construction Management” & AGC Build New England Honor Award • Boston Society of Architects (BSA) Healthcare Facilities Design Award 2013 • Construction Management Association of America (CMAA), New England Chapter, Project Achievement Award for New Building Construction over $200M • American Council of Engineering Companies of Massachusetts (ACEC/MA) Silver Engineering Excellence Award • Deep Foundations Institute National First Runner-up for the Outstanding Project Award • Modern Healthcare Design, Design Citation Award • International Interior Design Association New England (IIDA) – Healthcare Project Award • LEED Gold certification -
William R. Seed Staff Vice President, Design & Construction Department
Universal Health Services -
Texoma Medical Center Conditions of Satisfaction • Reduce cost by
$4 million – overall goal is $94 million • Deliver project in 17 months – November 2009 • No punch list • No injuries • No rfi’s • No change orders • No rework Conditions of Satisfaction • Final construction cost was $97.9 million • $1.7 million in savings pool • $7 million in value adds • Project delivered first week in December despite 87 rain days • No punch list at owner turn over • Only 4 minor recordable injuries • 190 rfi’s • 40 related to early steel package • Many were confirming • $1.4 million in change orders • $1.1 million was owner driven • Rework greatly minimized through collaborative efforts -
• 80 beds/58,000 sf • $213/sf construction cost • $279/sf
all in cost • $205k per bed • $249/sf if built in KY • $231k per bed Springwoods BH Fayetteville, AK 2008 -
Cumberland Hall Hopkinsville, KY 2011 • 100 beds/68,000 sf •
$184/sf construction cost • $250/sf all in cost • $171k per bed • $184/sf built in KY • 30% less cost -
IPD Experience • 50 Projects IPD-ish • $1MM to $150MM
• 18 completed • Results: Outstanding • 17 under construction • Watching efficiencies improve daily • 15 in design phase • Phenomenal collaboration, Learning, BIM, Results • 28 Full Consensus Doc 300 IFOA -
Temecula Valley Hospital 2013 • 40% below market cost •
30% operational cost improvement • 200%+ increase in labor productivity • 7 IFOA partners • Rapid improvement • Exceptional team work • Lots of FUN -
Published late 2011 • All projects $5MM + IFOA •
Partnership Charter • Training Curriculum • Regionalized vendor pool • Benchmark project target pricing • High Expectations