Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …

On minimum quality in typeface design

Gerry Leonidas
November 29, 2014

On minimum quality in typeface design

Lecture delivered at the 5th Encontro de Tipografia, Barcelos, Portugal

Gerry Leonidas

November 29, 2014
Tweet

More Decks by Gerry Leonidas

Other Decks in Design

Transcript

  1. 5ET | 29 November 2014
    On minimum quality 

    in typeface design

    Gerry Leonidas

    View Slide

  2. [start with an observation about 

    the car industry in the 1970s]
    This talk will cover three 

    notions, one argument, 

    and one call to action.

    View Slide

  3. 1 industry and ownership
    2 value and visibility
    3 information and quality
    > trends, genre, and creativity
    > some intentions to act

    View Slide

  4. Industry and ownership

    View Slide

  5. A comparison of type-making
    technologies, with a comment on the 

    shift from manufacturing processes with
    dedicated equipment to knowledge
    professions with generic capital
    equipment.

    View Slide

  6. Linotype & Machinery Type Drawing Office

    View Slide

  7. Joana Correia’s workspace

    View Slide

  8. A comment on the economics 

    of early DTP equipment

    View Slide

  9. View Slide

  10. Discussion of “objects” that embody IP.
    Story of Linotype’s conversion to a rights
    holder, and Monotype’s transition to a
    digital services company.

    View Slide

  11. View Slide

  12. When industries open up, 

    existing ideas about ownership 

    and contribution change.
    First notion

    View Slide

  13. Value and visibility

    View Slide

  14. View Slide

  15. View Slide

  16. Comments on the disembodiment 

    of type, and the difficulties of identifying
    reliable representations of a typeface

    View Slide

  17. font-making environments 

    are commoditised

    View Slide

  18. the marginal cost 

    of a new font 

    trends to zero

    View Slide

  19. The added value of design 

    is redefined away from the 

    visible acts of practice
    Second notion

    View Slide

  20. Information and quality

    View Slide

  21. Discussing “how to evaluate quality?” 

    in relation to the range of possible 

    outputs.

    View Slide

  22. baby, these curves
    make me think
    naughty thoughts

    View Slide

  23. baby,  these  curves    
    make  me  think    
    naughty  thoughts
    baby, these curves
    make me think
    naughty thoughts
    baby, these curves
    make me think
    naughty thoughts
    baby, these curves
    make me think
    naughty thoughts
    baby, these curves
    make me think
    naughty thoughts
    baby, these curves
    make me think
    naughty thoughts
    baby, these curves
    make me think
    naughty thoughts

    View Slide

  24. A typeface does not contain 

    enough information 

    to explain itself.
    Third notion

    View Slide

  25. A typeface can only be evaluated 

    in relation to a context 

    that is external to anything that
    identifies the typeface as itself.

    View Slide

  26. 1 Ownership and contribution 

    change with the means of making.
    2 Value of design is disembodied.

    3 Evaluation relies on context.
    Recap

    View Slide

  27. Trends, genres, and creativity
    Extending the discussion

    View Slide

  28. SCH: …almost anything is possible 

    if a good argument is provided,[…] if
    the design is not among the accepted
    conventions of the moment possibly
    it will be in the future (or not)
    (A student question)

    View Slide

  29. The rules for evaluation are
    determined by context.
    Starting point, then

    View Slide

  30. These rules aren't linear: 

    they apply with a force that 

    is analogous to the deviation 

    from the convention.

    View Slide

  31. Then let’s assume that we can represent
    them as points in a coordinate space (this
    is oversimplifying, but imagining more than
    two dimensions is tricky): they will form a
    cloud that is fairly dense. The strength of
    the patterns for new typefaces that do a
    comparable job will be very weak near the
    centre of the cloud, and progressively
    stronger as you move away.

    View Slide

  32. So, if Minion is at the centre, then Cardea 

    is a little bit further out (so the designer
    can make it individual but it still is a
    “comfortably readable typeface for prose 

    in Northern Europe”, and Capucine is 

    going too far.

    View Slide

  33. View Slide

  34. Cardea
    Minion
    Capucine

    View Slide

  35. This “context cloud” shifts slowly,
    across genres.

    View Slide

  36. [Oversimplifying] Conventions develop
    slowly, gradually populated by a cloud of
    typefaces. 

    Imagine a cloud moving slowly from an
    “old-style / transitional serifs” position 

    to a “low-contrast slabs” position, to a
    “modulated sans” position over twenty 

    or thirty years, as peoples’ reading habits
    evolve.

    View Slide

  37. > trends
    > genres
    > motivators
    > outliers

    View Slide

  38. Redefining trends of use;
    genres of typefaces for specific uses;
    motivator typefaces that shift genres to
    contribute to a trend; and
    outlier typefaces, that may generate spikes
    of attention, and enable other typefaces to
    act as motivators

    View Slide

  39. So how to judge quality beyond 

    genre, purpose, and identity?

    View Slide

  40. We can set “objective” criteria 

    for well-formed shapes, spaces, 

    and behaviours.

    View Slide

  41. /gerryleonidas

    View Slide

  42. Reminder of criteria for type reviews, 

    which are embedded in a previous
    presentation in Warsaw

    View Slide

  43. Pointers for typeface reviews (1/3):
    > fit of typeset text within the brief
    > key dimensions within the body
    > stroke thickness range
    > balance of key strokes and space 

    within and between letters

    View Slide

  44. Pointers for typeface reviews (2/3):
    > stroke modulation
    > in/out stroke recipes
    > alignments in H and V axes
    > transitions between letter elements

    View Slide

  45. Pointers for typeface reviews (3/3):
    > relating of inner and outer strokes
    > letter shapes within key patterns
    > integration of exceptions

    View Slide

  46. How do we support this 

    on a global scale?

    View Slide

  47. Verdana and Georgia (1996) embody 

    Microsoft’s first moves away from 

    print.
    The  ClearType  fonts (2003)    represented 

    a  bet  in portable, flat  screens.

    View Slide

  48. Adobe’s Source Sans Pro 

    and Serif Pro are just notable
    examples in a very long line 

    of fonts that set baselines.

    View Slide

  49. We have a plan to make available 

    online a series of resources to support
    people who want to start learning 

    about typeface design

    View Slide

  50. Two phases:
    > Typeface and typeform 

    fundamentals
    > Design for typographic setting

    View Slide

  51. - Key properties of text typefaces
    - Shapes contributing to homogeneity / individuality
    - Key proportions in the lowercase
    - Stroke thickness as a unit of measurement
    - Balancing key strokes and space
    - Stroke modulation and transitions to vertical strokes
    - In- and outstroke recipes
    - Optical alignments in the horizontal axis
    - Patterns and exceptions in lettershapes
    - Dimensions within and across cases

    View Slide

  52. - Setting parameters from a typographic brief
    - Body sizing for paragraph setting
    - Case differentiation for different briefs
    - Family composition planning
    - Mapping families to CSS weights
    - Planning weights and styles within paragraphs
    - Planning weights and styles for editorial typography
    - Planning weights and styles for complex texts

    View Slide

  53. What next?
    Closing comments

    View Slide

  54. Thank you, and get in touch
    @gerryleonidas
    @typefacedesign
    reading.ac.uk/typography
    typefacedesign.net

    View Slide